ARCHIVED - Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2011-43
This page has been archived on the Web
Information identified as archived on the Web is for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. Archived Decisions, Notices and Orders (DNOs) remain in effect except to the extent they are amended or reversed by the Commission, a court, or the government. The text of archived information has not been altered or updated after the date of archiving. Changes to DNOs are published as “dashes” to the original DNO number. Web pages that are archived on the Web are not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards. As per the Communications Policy of the Government of Canada, you can request alternate formats by contacting us.
Ottawa, 25 January 2011
Revised lists of eligible satellite services – Annual compilation of amendments
1. In Broadcasting Public Notice 2006-55, the Commission announced that it would periodically issue public notices setting out revised lists of eligible satellite services that include references to all amendments that have been made since the previous public notice setting out the lists was issued.
2. Accordingly, in Appendix 1 to this regulatory policy, the Commission sets out all amendments made to the revised lists since the issuance of Broadcasting Regulatory Policy 2010-57. In addition, the lists of eligible satellite services approved as of 31 December 2010 are set out in Appendix 2.
3. The Commission notes that, as set out in Broadcasting Regulatory Policy 2010-839, it approved a request by TELUS Communications Company for the addition of 17 new language tracks to Baby TV, a non-Canadian service already included on the lists of eligible satellite services for distribution on a digital basis.
Secretary General
Related documents
- Addition of 17 new language tracks to Baby TV, a service already included on the lists of eligible satellite services for distribution on a digital basis, Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2010-839, 10 November 2010
Appendix 1 to Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2011-43
Amendments made to the lists of eligible satellite services since the issuance of Revised lists of eligible satellite services – Annual compilation of amendments, Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2010-57, 4 February 2010
Addition of GMA Life TV to the lists of eligible satellite services for distribution on a digital basis, Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2010-810, 2 November 2010
Addition of myZen.TV to the lists of eligible satellite services for distribution on a digital basis, Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2010-800, 28 October 2010
Addition of German Kino Plus to the lists of eligible satellite services for distribution on a digital basis, Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2010-799, 28 October 2010
Addition of Aastha Bhajan to the lists of eligible satellite services for distribution on a digital basis, Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2010-335, 1 June 2010
Addition of Benfica TV to the lists of eligible satellite services for distribution on a digital basis, Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2010-185, 26 March 2010
Appendix 2 to Broadcasting Regulatory Policy CRTC 2011-43
Following are the revised lists of eligible satellite services as of 31 December 2010. Only those services appearing on the most recent lists are authorized for distribution; those lists are available on the Commission’s website at www.crtc.gc.ca under “Broadcasting Sector” and may be obtained in hard copy on request.
Revised lists of eligible satellite services (as of 31 December 2010)
Appendix A
List of Part 2 Eligible Satellite Services
Section A
ACCESS
Saskatchewan Communications Network (SCN)
Télé-Québec (STQ)
The Ontario Educational Communications Authority (TVO)
The Ontario French-Language Educational Communications Authority (TFO)
Knowledge
”A” Atlantic
CFTU-TV Montréal (IND)
CBC English-language Television Service/CBC French-language Television Service
WHDH-TV Boston/WGRZ-TV Buffalo/WPTZ Burlington/WDIV Detroit/WICU-TV Erie/
KARE Minneapolis/KHQ-TV Spokane/KING-TV Seattle (NBC)
WGBH-TV Boston/WNED-TV Buffalo/WETK Burlington/WTVS Detroit/WQLN Erie/
KSPS-TV Spokane/KCTS-TV Seattle (PBS)
WBZ-TV Boston/WIVB-TV Buffalo/WCAX-TV Burlington/WSEE Erie/WTOL-TV Toledo/
WCCO-TV Minneapolis/KREM-TV Spokane/KIRO-TV Seattle/WWJ-TV Detroit (CBS)
WCVB-TV Boston/WKBW-TV Buffalo/WVNY Burlington/WXYZ-TV Detroit/
WJET-TV Erie/KSTP-TV Minneapolis/KXLY-TV Spokane/KOMO-TV Seattle (ABC)
WUTV Buffalo/WFFF-TV Burlington/WFTC Minneapolis/WUHF Rochester/
KAYU-TV Spokane/KCPQ Tacoma/ WFXT Boston (FOX)
The Arts and Entertainment Network (A&E)
BBC World
Black Entertainment Television (BET)
Cable News Network (CNN)
CNN Headline News (CNN-2)
Cable Satellite Public Affairs Network (C-Span)
Consumer News and Business Channel (CNBC)
Court TV
Deutsche Welle♦
The Filipino Channel♦
The Golf Channel
The Learning Channel
Radio-France outre-mer (RFO1)
The Silent Network (Kaleidoscope)
Speed Channel
Spike TV
TV Japan♦
TV Polonia♦
The Weather Channel (TWC)
WMNB-TV: Russian-American Broadcasting Company♦
Licensed pay audio programming undertaking(s)**
Section B
KSTW (IND) Tacoma/Seattle
KTLA Los Angeles
KWGN-TV Denver
WGN-TV Chicago
WPCH-TV Atlanta
WPIX New York City
WSBK-TV Boston
WUAB-TV (IND) Cleveland
WWOR-TV New York City
American Movie Classics
Comedy Central
Game Show Network
Lifetime Television
Playboy TV***
Turner Classic Movies
** A pay audio programming undertaking may not be used for linkage purposes for the distribution of any non-Canadian eligible satellite services.
*** Playboy TV is only authorized for distribution at the specific request of a subscriber. Distributors are not permitted to package Playboy TV in such a way that subscribers are obligated to purchase Playboy TV in order to purchase any other programming service. Distributors are required to take measures to fully block the reception of both the audio and video portions of Playboy TV to subscribers that request it not be receivable in their home (in either unscrambled or scrambled analog form).
Authorization for the services in Sections A and B is subject to the following:
-
Licensees receiving any U.S. PBS signal(s) over the air at the local head end may distribute one additional PBS signal pursuant to this List. All other licensees may distribute a maximum of two PBS services pursuant to this List.
-
Licensees receiving U.S. commercial network signals over the air at the local head end may not distribute additional U.S. commercial network signals pursuant to this List. Other licensees may not distribute the signal of more than one affiliate of the same commercial U.S. network pursuant to this List.
♦ Denotes a service in a language other than English or French added before 16 December 2004.
Section C
List of Part 2 Eligible Satellite Services for Digital Distribution Only
Aaj Tak Channel
Aastha Bhajan
Al Arabiya News Channel
Al Jazeera*♦
Al Jazeera English
Ariana Television
ART Movies♦
ATV Home Channel (America)
Azteca 13 International
Baby TV
BabyFirstTV
Beijing TV
Benfica TV
Big Ten Network
Bloomberg Television
Bridges TV
BVN-TV♦
Canal 52 MX
Canal de las Estrellas Latinoamérica
Canal SUR♦
Caracol Television International
CaribVision
CBS College Sports Network
CCTV-4
CCTV Entertainment Channel
Channel-i
Channel One Russia Worldwide TV
Channel [V] Taiwan
China Yellow River Television Station
CineLatino♦
CNN International
Cubavision Internacional
Dandana TV
De Pelicula Channel
Dragon TV
El Gourmet.com
Eternal Word Television Network
ET-Global Channel
ETV Bangla
Eurochannel
EuroNews
Eurosportnews
Fox Business Network
Fox News
France 24 (English)
France 24 (French)
Future Television Channel
GEO TV
German Kino Plus
German TV♦
GMA Life TV
GMA Pinoy TV
Grandes Documentales de TVE♦
HDNet
Headlines Today Channel
HTV
Horizon Channel
Hunan Satellite TV
Indus Music
Indus Vision
ITVN
Jiangsu International TV Channel
KTO
LBC America
LUXE.TV
MBC Channel (America)
Mezzo
Military Channel
MSNBC
Muslim Television Ahmadiyya♦
myZen.TV
NASA Television
NDTV GOOD TIMES
Network TEN (Australia)
NEW SAT
New Tang Dynasty Television (NTDTV)
NFL Network
NTV Bangla
Oxygen Network
Paris-Première
Phoenix InfoNews Channel
Phoenix North American Chinese Channel (PNACC)
Planète
Planète Thalassa
Polsat 2 International
Premiere Futebole Clube (PFC)
ProSiebenSat.1 Welt
PTV-Prime USA
Radio Television Portugal International (RTPi)
RAI International 2
Ritmoson Latino Channel
Romanian Television International (RTVI)♦
RTR-Planeta TV
RTV
RTV Palma♦
Russia Today
Sahara One
The Satellite Channel of Southern Television Guandong
Sony Entertainment Television Asia (SET Asia)
Sony Max
Southeast TV Station
Star Chinese Channel
Star Chinese Movies 2
Star India Gold
Star India News Channel
Star India One Channel
Star India Plus
Sun TV
Supercanal Caribe
TELEFE Internacional
TL Novelas Channel
TRACE TV
TV3 Republic of Ireland
TV3 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV4 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV Asia
TV Chile
TVColombia
TVE Internacional
TV Globo Internacional
TV Land
Utilisima♦
Vijay Channel
* On the condition that the licensee has a condition of licence governing the distribution of Al Jazeera.
Authorization for the services in Section C is subject to the following:
-
Providers of these foreign services must have obtained and must remain in possession of all necessary rights for the distribution of their programming in Canada.
-
Providers of these foreign services must not hold, nor try to obtain, nor exercise, preferential or exclusive programming rights in relation to the distribution of programming in Canada.
♦ Denotes a service in a language other than English or French added before 16 December 2004.
Appendix B
List of Part 3 Eligible Satellite Services
ACCESS
Saskatchewan Communications Network (SCN)
Télé-Québec (STQ)
The Ontario Educational Communications Authority (TVO)
The Ontario French-Language Educational Communications Authority (TFO)
Knowledge
”A” Atlantic
Aboriginal Peoples Television Network (APTN)
CBC English-language Television Service/CBC French-language Television Service
The programming service of any licensed television programming undertaking
WHDH-TV Boston/WGRZ-TV Buffalo/WPTZ Burlington/WDIV Detroit/WICU-TV Erie/
KARE Minneapolis/KHQ-TV Spokane/KING-TV Seattle (NBC)
WGBH-TV Boston/WNED-TV Buffalo/WETK Burlington/WTVS Detroit/WQLN Erie/
KSPS-TV Spokane/KCTS-TV Seattle (PBS)
WBZ-TV Boston/WIVB-TV Buffalo/WCAX-TV Burlington/WSEE Erie/WTOL-TV Toledo/
WCCO-TV Minneapolis/KREM-TV Spokane/KIRO-TV Seattle/WWJ-TV Detroit (CBS)
WCVB-TV Boston/WKBW-TV Buffalo/WVNY Burlington/ WXYZ-TV Detroit/WJET-TV Erie/
KSTP-TV Minneapolis/KXLY-TV Spokane/KOMO-TV Seattle (ABC)
WUTV Buffalo/WFFF-TV Burlington/WFTC Minneapolis/ WUHF Rochester/
KAYU-TV Spokane/KCPQ Tacoma/WFXT Boston (FOX)
KSTW Tacoma/Seattle (IND)
WUAB-TV Cleveland (IND)
KTLA Los Angeles
KWGN-TV Denver
WGN-TV Chicago
WPCH-TV Atlanta
WPIX New York City
WSBK-TV Boston
WWOR-TV New York City
American Movie Classics
ART America♦
The Arts and Entertainment Network (A&E)
BBC World
Black Entertainment Television (BET)
Cable News Network (CNN)
CNN Headline News (CNN-2)
Cable Satellite Public Affairs Network (C-Span)
Comedy Central
Consumer News and Business Channel (CNBC)
Court TV
Deutsche Welle♦
The Filipino Channel♦
Game Show Network
The Golf Channel
The Learning Channel
Lifetime Television
Playboy TV**
Radio-France outre-mer (RFO1)
The Silent Network (Kaleidoscope)
Speed Channel
Spike TV
Turner Classic Movies
TV Japan♦
TV Polonia♦
The Weather Channel (TWC)
WMNB-TV: Russian-American Broadcasting Company♦
Licensed pay audio programming undertaking(s)
** Playboy TV is only authorized for distribution at the specific request of a subscriber. Distributors are not permitted to package Playboy TV in such a way that subscribers are obligated to purchase Playboy TV in order to purchase any other programming service. Distributors are required to take measures to fully block the reception of both the audio and video portions of Playboy TV to subscribers that request it not be receivable in their home (in either unscrambled or scrambled analog form).
Authorization for the services in the List of Part 3 Eligible Satellite Services is subject to the following:
-
In the case of out-of-province educational services, there should be no objection on the part of the originating service.
-
In the case of licensed television programming undertakings offering TVA or CTV programming, a licensee also distributing the signal of a local TVA or CTV affiliate shall delete the duplicate programming from the services offered pursuant to this List or substitute the local service(s) when the programming is identical.
-
Licensees receiving any U.S. PBS signal(s) over the air at the local head end may distribute one additional PBS signal pursuant to this List. All other licensees may distribute a maximum of two PBS services pursuant to this List.
-
Licensees receiving U.S. commercial network signals over the air at the local head end may not distribute additional U.S. commercial network signals pursuant to this List. Other licensees may not distribute the signal of more than one affiliate of the same commercial U.S. network pursuant to this List.
♦ Denotes a service in a language other than English or French added before 16 December 2004.
List of Part 3 Eligible Satellite Services for Digital Distribution Only
Aaj Tak Channel
Aastha Bhajan
Al Arabiya News Channel
Al Jazeera*♦
Al Jazeera English
Ariana Television
ART Movies♦
ATV Home Channel (America)
Azteca 13 International
Baby TV
BabyFirstTV
Beijing TV
Benfica TV
Big Ten Network
Bloomberg Television
Bridges TV
BVN-TV♦
Canal 52 MX
Canal de las Estrellas Latinoamérica
Canal SUR♦
Caracol Television International
CaribVision
CBS College Sports Network
CCTV-4
CCTV Entertainment Channel
Channel-i
Channel One Russia Worldwide TV
Channel [V] Taiwan
China Yellow River Television Station
CineLatino♦
CNN International
Cubavision Internacional
Dandana TV
De Pelicula Channel
Dragon TV
El Gourmet.com
Eternal Word Television Network
ET-Global Channel
ETV Bangla
Eurochannel
EuroNews
Eurosportnews
Fox Business Network
Fox News
France 24 (English)
France 24 (French)
Future Television Channel
GEO TV
German Kino Plus
German TV♦
GMA Life TV
GMA Pinoy TV
Grandes Documentales de TVE♦
HDNet
Headlines Today Channel
Horizon Channel
HTV
Hunan Satellite TV
Indus Music
Indus Vision
ITVN
Jiangsu International TV Channel
KTO
LBC America
LUXE.TV
MBC Channel (America)
Mezzo
Military Channel
MSNBC
Muslim Television Ahmadiyya♦
myZen.TV
NASA Television
NDTV GOOD TIMES
Network TEN (Australia)
NEW SAT
New Tang Dynasty Television (NTDTV)
NFL Network
NTV Bangla
Oxygen Network
Paris-Première
Phoenix InfoNews Channel
Phoenix North American Chinese Channel (PNACC)
Planète
Planète Thalassa
Polsat 2 International
Premiere Futebole Clube (PFC)
ProSiebenSat.1 Welt
PTV-Prime USA
Radio Television Portugal International (RTPi)
RAI International 2
Ritmoson Latino Channel
Romanian Television International (RTVI)♦
RTR-Planeta TV
RTV
RTV Palma♦
Russia Today
Sahara One
The Satellite Channel of Southern Television Guandong
Sony Entertainment Television Asia (SET Asia)
Sony Max
Southeast TV Station
Star Chinese Channel
Star Chinese Movies 2
Star India Gold
Star India News Channel
Star India One Channel
Star India Plus
Sun TV
Supercanal Caribe
TELEFE Internacional
TL Novelas Channel
TRACE TV
TV3 Republic of Ireland
TV3 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV4 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV Asia
TV Chile
TVColombia
TVE Internacional
TV Globo Internacional
TV Land
Utilisima♦
Vijay Channel
* On the condition that the licensee has a condition of licence governing the distribution of Al Jazeera.
Authorization for the services eligible for digital distribution only is subject to the following:
-
Providers of these foreign services must have obtained and must remain in possession of all necessary rights for the distribution of their programming in Canada.
-
Providers of these foreign services must not hold, nor try to obtain, nor exercise, preferential or exclusive programming rights in relation to the distribution of programming in Canada.
♦ Denotes a service in a language other than English or French added before 16 December 2004.
Appendix C
List of DTH Eligible Satellite Services
Section A
ART America♦
The Arts and Entertainment Network (A&E)
BBC World
Black Entertainment Television (BET)
Cable News Network (CNN)
CNN Headline News (CNN-2)
Cable Satellite Public Affairs Network (C-Span)
Consumer News and Business Channel (CNBC)
Court TV
Deutsche Welle♦
The Filipino Channel♦
The Golf Channel
The Learning Channel
The Silent Network (Kaleidoscope)
Speed Channel
Spike TV
TV Japan♦
TV Polonia♦
The Weather Channel (TWC)
WMNB-TV: Russian-American Broadcasting Company♦
Radio France outre-mer (RFO1)
Section B
KSTW (IND) Tacoma/Seattle*
KTLA Los Angeles*
KWGN-TV Denver*
WGN-TV Chicago*
WPCH-TV Atlanta*
WPIX New York City*
WSBK-TV Boston*
WWOR-TV New York City*
American Movie Classics
Comedy Central
Game Show Network
Lifetime Television
Playboy TV**
Turner Classic Movies
* U.S. Superstation
** Playboy TV is only authorized for distribution at the specific request of a subscriber. Distributors are not permitted to package Playboy TV in such a way that subscribers are obligated to purchase Playboy TV in order to purchase any other programming service.
♦ Denotes a service in a language other than English or French added before 16 December 2004.
Section C
Aaj Tak Channel
Aastha Bhajan
Al Arabiya News Channel
Al Jazeera*♦
Al Jazeera English
Ariana Television
ART Movies♦
ATV Home Channel (America)
Azteca 13 International
Baby TV
BabyFirstTV
Beijing TV
Benfica TV
Big Ten Network
Bloomberg Television
Bridges TV
BVN-TV♦
Canal 52 MX
Canal de las Estrellas Latinoamérica
Canal SUR♦
Caracol Television International
CaribVision
CBS College Sports Network
CCTV-4
CCTV Entertainment Channel
Channel-i
Channel One Russia Worldwide TV
Channel [V] Taiwan
China Yellow River Television Station
CineLatino♦
CNN International
Cubavision Internacional
Dandana TV
De Pelicula Channel
Dragon TV
El Gourmet.com
Eternal Word Television Network
ET-Global Channel
ETV Bangla
Eurochannel
EuroNews
Eurosportnews
Fox Business Network
Fox News
France 24 (English)
France 24 (French)
Future Television Channel
GEO TV
German Kino Plus
German TV♦
GMA Life TV
GMA Pinoy TV
Grandes Documentales de TVE♦
HDNet
Headlines Today Channel
Horizon Channel
HTV
Hunan Satellite TV
Indus Music
Indus Vision
ITVN
Jiangsu International TV Channel
KTO
LBC America
LUXE.TV
MBC Channel (America)
Mezzo
Military Channel
MSNBC
Muslim Television Ahmadiyya♦
myZen.TV
NASA Television
NDTV GOOD TIMES
Network TEN (Australia)
NEW SAT
New Tang Dynasty Television (NTDTV)
NFL Network
NTV Bangla
Oxygen Network
Paris-Première
Phoenix InfoNews Channel
Phoenix North American Chinese Channel (PNACC)
Planète
Planète Thalassa
Polsat 2 International
Premiere Futebole Clube (PFC)
ProSiebenSat.1 Welt
PTV-Prime USA
Radio Television Portugal International (RTPi)
RAI International 2
Ritmoson Latino Channel
Romanian Television International (RTVI)♦
RTR-Planeta TV
RTV
RTV Palma♦
Russia Today
Sahara One
The Satellite Channel of Southern Television Guandong
Sony Entertainment Television Asia (SET Asia)
Sony Max
Southeast TV Station
Star Chinese Channel
Star Chinese Movies 2
Star India Gold
Star India News Channel
Star India One Channel
Star India Plus
Sun TV
Supercanal Caribe
TELEFE Internacional
TL Novelas Channel
TRACE TV
TV3 Republic of Ireland
TV3 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV4 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV Asia
TV Chile
TVColombia
TVE Internacional
TV Globo internacional
TV Land
Utilisima♦
Vijay Channel
* On the condition that the licensee has a condition of licence governing the distribution of Al Jazeera.
Authorization for the services listed in Section C is subject to the following:
-
Providers of these foreign services must have obtained and must remain in possession of all necessary rights for the distribution of their programming in Canada.
-
Providers of these foreign services must not hold, nor try to obtain, nor exercise, preferential or exclusive programming rights in relation to the distribution of programming in Canada.
♦ Denotes a service in a language other than English or French added before 16 December 2004.
Appendix D
List of Part 2, Part 3, and DTH Eligible Satellite Services for Digital Distribution
Aaj Tak Channel
Aastha Bhajan
Al Arabiya News Channel
Al Jazeera*♦
Al Jazeera English
Ariana Television
ART Movies♦
ATV Home Channel (America)
Azteca 13 International
Baby TV
BabyFirstTV
Beijing TV
Benfica TV
Big Ten Network
Bloomberg Television
Bridges TV
BVN-TV♦
Canal 52 MX
Canal de las Estrellas Latinoamérica
Canal SUR♦
Caracol Television International
CaribVision
CBS College Sports Network
CCTV-4
CCTV Entertainment Channel
Channel-i
Channel One Russia Worldwide TV
Channel [V] Taiwan
China Yellow River Television Station
CineLatino♦
CNN International
Cubavision Internacional
Dandana TV
De Pelicula Channel
Dragon TV
El Gourmet.com
Eternal Word Television Network
ET-Global Channel
ETV Bangla
Eurochannel
EuroNews
Eurosportnews
Fox Business Network
Fox News
France 24 (English)
France 24 (French)
Future Television Channel
GEO TV
German Kino Plus
German TV♦
GMA Life TV
GMA Pinoy TV
Grandes Documentales de TVE♦
HDNet
Headlines Today Channel
Horizon Channel
HTV
Hunan Satellite TV
Indus Music
Indus Vision
ITVN
Jiangsu International TV Channel
KTO
LBC America
LUXE.TV
MBC Channel (America)
Mezzo
Military Channel
MSNBC
Muslim Television Ahmadiyya♦
myZen.TV
NASA Television
NDTV GOOD TIMES
Network TEN (Australia)
NEW SAT
New Tang Dynasty Television (NTDTV)
NFL Network
NTV Bangla
Oxygen Network
Paris-Première
Phoenix InfoNews Channel
Phoenix North American Chinese Channel (PNACC)
Planète
Planète Thalassa
Polsat 2 International
Premiere Futebole Clube (PFC)
ProSiebenSat.1 Welt
PTV-Prime USA
Radio Television Portugal International (RTPi)
RAI International 2
Ritmoson Latino Channel
Romanian Television International (RTVI)♦
RTR-Planeta TV
RTV
RTV Palma♦
Russia Today
Sahara One
The Satellite Channel of Southern Television Guandong
Sony Entertainment Television Asia (SET Asia)
Sony Max
Southeast TV Station
Star Chinese Channel
Star Chinese Movies 2
Star India Gold
Star India News Channel
Star India One Channel
Star India Plus
Sun TV
Supercanal Caribe
TELEFE Internacional
TL Novelas Channel
TRACE TV
TV3 Republic of Ireland
TV3 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV4 Television Network (New Zealand)
TV Asia
TV Chile
TVColombia
TVE Internacional
TV Globo Internacional
TV Land
Utilisima♦
Vijay Channel
* On the condition that the licensee has a condition of licence governing the distribution of Al Jazeera
Authorization for the above-noted services is subject to the following:
-
Providers of these foreign services must have obtained and must remain in possession of all necessary rights for the distribution of their programming in Canada.
-
Providers of these foreign services must not hold, nor try to obtain, nor exercise, preferential or exclusive programming rights in relation to the distribution of programming in Canada.
♦ Denotes a service in a language other than English or French added before 16 December 2004.
- Date modified: