ARCHIVED - Transcript
This page has been archived on the Web
Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please contact us to request a format other than those available.
Providing Content in Canada's Official Languages
Please note that the Official Languages Act requires that government publications be available in both official languages.
In order to meet some of the requirements under this Act, the Commission's transcripts will therefore be bilingual as to their covers, the listing of CRTC members and staff attending the hearings, and the table of contents.
However, the aforementioned publication is the recorded verbatim transcript and, as such, is transcribed in either of the official languages, depending on the language spoken by the participant at the hearing.
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS BEFORE
THE CANADIAN RADIO‑TELEVISION AND
TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
TRANSCRIPTION DES AUDIENCES AVANT
CONSEIL DE LA RADIODIFFUSION
ET DES TÉLÉCOMMUNICATIONS CANADIENNES
SUBJECT:
VARIOUS BROADCAST APPLICATIONS /
PLUSIEURS DEMANDES EN RADIODIFFUSION
HELD AT: TENUE À:
Delta Regina Delta Regina
1919 Saskatchewan Drive 1919, promenade Saskatchewan
Regina, Saskatchewan Regina, Saskatchewan
October 31, 2006 le 31 octobre 2006
Transcripts
In order to meet the requirements of the Official Languages
Act, transcripts of proceedings before the Commission will be
bilingual as to their covers, the listing of the CRTC members
and staff attending the public hearings, and the Table of
Contents.
However, the aforementioned publication is the recorded
verbatim transcript and, as such, is taped and transcribed in
either of the official languages, depending on the language
spoken by the participant at the public hearing.
Transcription
Afin de rencontrer les exigences de la Loi sur les langues
officielles, les procès‑verbaux pour le Conseil seront
bilingues en ce qui a trait à la page couverture, la liste des
membres et du personnel du CRTC participant à l'audience
publique ainsi que la table des matières.
Toutefois, la publication susmentionnée est un compte rendu
textuel des délibérations et, en tant que tel, est enregistrée
et transcrite dans l'une ou l'autre des deux langues
officielles, compte tenu de la langue utilisée par le
participant à l'audience publique.
Canadian Radio‑television and
Telecommunications Commission
Conseil de la radiodiffusion et des
télécommunications canadiennes
Transcript / Transcription
VARIOUS BROADCAST APPLICATIONS /
PLUSIEURS DEMANDES EN RADIODIFFUSION
BEFORE / DEVANT:
Barbara Cram Chairperson / Présidente
Michel Arpin Vice-Chair, Broadcasting / Vice‑président, radiodiffusion
Rita Cugini Commissioner / Conseillère
Ronald Williams Commissioner / Conseiller
Joan Pennefather Commissioner / Conseillère
ALSO PRESENT / AUSSI PRÉSENTS:
Chantal Boulet Secretary / Secrétaire
Leanne Bennett Legal Counsel /
Conseillère juridique
Lyne Cape Hearing Manager /
Gérante de l'audience
HELD AT: TENUE À:
Delta Regina Delta Regina
1919 Saskatchewan Drive 1919, promenade Saskatchewan
Regina, Saskatchewan Regina, Saskatchewan
October 31, 2006 le 31 octobre 2006
- iv -
TABLE DES MATIÈRES / TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE / PARA
MEDICINE HAT - PHASE I (cont'd)
PRESENTATION BY / PRÉSENTATION PAR:
Rogers Broadcasting Limited 345 / 1766
Pat Lough (OBCI) 414 / 2031
MEDICINE HAT - PHASE II (458)
PRESENTATION BY / PRÉSENTATION PAR:
Lighthouse Broadcasting Limited 458 / 2182
Golden West Broadcasting Ltd. 459 / 2193
Radio CJVR Ltd. 460 / 2200
Harvard Broadcasting Inc. 464 / 2212
Rogers Broadcasting Limited 464 / 2218
MEDICINE HAT - PHASE III (465)
PRESENTATION BY / PRÉSENTATION PAR:
Alex Mair 465 / 2226
Aboriginal Media Education Fund 478 / 2274
Carpet One Medicine Hat 486 / 2303
MEDICINE HAT - PHASE IV (501)
PRESENTATION BY / PRÉSENTATION PAR:
Rogers Broadcasting Limited 502 / 2380
Vista Radio Ltd. 504 / 2395
1182743 Alberta Limited 504 / 2399
Radio CJVR Ltd. 505 / 2406
Golden West Broadcasting Ltd. 508 / 2418
- v -
TABLE DES MATIÈRES / TABLE OF CONTENTS
PAGE / PARA
REGINA - PHASE I (510)
PRESENTATION BY / PRÉSENTATION PAR:
Newcap Inc. 510 / 2438
Standard Radio Inc. 564 / 2645
Touch Canada Broadcasting Inc. 621 / 2911
Radio CJVR Ltd. 683 / 3276
Regina, Saskatchewan / Regina (Saskatchewan)
‑‑‑ Upon commencing on Tuesday, October 31, 2006
at 0833 / L'audience débute le mardi 31 octobre
2006 à 0833
LISTNUM 95 \l 1 \s 17611761 THE CHAIRPERSON: Good morning on this Halloween.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11762 Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11763 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair. Good morning, everyone.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11764 We will now proceed with item 8 on the agenda, which is an application by Rogers Broadcasting Limited for a licence to operate an English‑language FM radio programming undertaking in Medicine Hat. The new station would operate on frequency 105.3 megahertz (channel 287C1) with an effective radiated power of 77,900 watts (non‑directional antenna/antenna height of 97.0 metres).
LISTNUM 95 \l 11765 Appearing for the applicant is Mr. Gary Miles, who will introduce his colleagues, after which you will have 20 minutes for your presentation. Please go ahead.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 11766 MR. MILES: Madam Chair, Members of the Commission, I am Gary Miles, CEO Radio, Rogers Broadcasting Limited. With me today, starting from my far left and your right, Leda MacLeod, business manager, radio, Ontario north; Alain Strati, vice‑president, regulatory affairs; Sarah Morton, operations manager, SONiCfm, and on my right, Kevin McKanna, executive vice‑president, radio, Alberta and Manitoba; Terry Voth, general manager, Lethbridge; and Angela Reimer, general sales manager, 660 News and the Fan 960 in Calgary.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11767 We are pleased to appear before you today to present our application for Rock 105, a rock music station for Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11768 By now, you've already heard from a number of applicants proposing to launch new radio stations in a number of different formats. For a market like Medicine Hat, we have proposed a broad‑based rock format to ensure we can effectively serve a wider range of musical interests and preferences.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11769 Content really is king, and our application for Rock 105 focuses on the need for strong, local programming. While that certainly includes traditional news, it is, by no means, limited to it. We've also proposed an innovative approach to local content focusing our efforts and resources on the establishment of a local production team, anticipating that they will develop and create segments that will inform and entertain listeners, whether on the air or on our website.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11770 Rock music fans are a bit of a different breed, and that's why it's critical that every aspect of our station reflects their attitude and their point of view. Whether it's the morning show, our news segments, or even the ads we sell, we want our listeners to know at all times that they are tuned to a rock station. If we don't, they will continue to go elsewhere accessing the growing array of audio options provided by satellite radio, iPods, and the Internet. In this kind of environment, we know that each segment and element on Rock 105 must appeal to the interests and programming style of rock music fans in Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11771 We believe the radio industry is at a crossroads. New media technologies are breathing down our necks and striving to provide consumers with a new and improved commercial free or customizable version of what radio has been doing for years. How will we respond? Well, either we can limit ourselves to being just another option in a widening landscape of music technologies, or we can reinvigorate our programming strategies and more precisely distinguish and differentiate radio as a local content option.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11772 At Rogers, we believe radio has to focus more on what audiences are searching for, entertainment and a stronger connection to their local radio station. With Rock 105, we think we've done that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11773 Along with the best rock music, our station will establish itself as an important source of local news, information, and entertainment, and as a vehicle for community support and involvement. Our unique approach to local programming starts with our newscasts. Local news, weather, traffic, and sports will form the basis of our news programming, and the 105‑second Reality Check will connect listeners to local news from the Medicine Hat perspective, but we'll try and do it a bit differently. Although we still call them newscasts, they're really not as conventional as you might think. The 105‑second reality check is more like a synopsis of news headlines and interesting stories. Targeting rock listeners, it will incorporate a rapid‑fire sound‑bite style using an engaging and humorous entertaining format, one we believe is more consistent with other programming elements and segments of our rock station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11774 Perhaps a quick listen will give you a better idea of exactly what we mean.
‑‑‑ Audio Clip / Clip audio
LISTNUM 95 \l 11775 MR. MILES: Rock 105 will also use other scheduled news segments: Our Rock News features will incorporate an open‑concept format, covering anything from local events to the latest industry trends and the hottest new artists. The Community Events Calendar and the Restaurant and Pub Crawl will provide details about events and activities in the Medicine Hat community, helping local organizations and businesses publicize their efforts to our listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11776 Sarah...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11777 MS MORTON: Thanks, Gary. Given our format and our audience, we also believe it's important not to place too great of an emphasis on traditional newscasts. Rock 105's approach to news and information has to mirror our music format and station attitude, and traditional news segments are not the only means of engaging listeners. The differentiating factor here is content, the ability to provide local, entertaining, and relevant content is the one thing that no other technology can do better than radio. Content starts with on‑air talent, but does not end there. It also extends to entertaining and interactive promotional activity and to on‑air feature development and production. That's why Rock 105 will focus on the development of news and information in a way that's accessible and entertaining. Rock audiences do want information, but they're less interested in traditional three or five‑minute newscasts. They want to be entertained while they're being informed.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11778 The success of TV programs such as the Rick Mercer Report or this Hour has 22 Minutes represents the impact this kind of approach can have. Although current topical and informative, these programs are really about entertaining their audiences. We want to develop a similar approach at Rock 105 with the Rock 105 Content Factory. Replacing the traditional exclusive focus on the news room, the Content Factory will translate local, national, and international news into interesting and entertaining programming segments for our listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11779 Here's a short parody song to provide you with but one example of the kind of programming approach and style we're envisioning. It's perhaps a bit light‑hearted, but you'll get the idea.
‑‑‑ Technical difficulties / Problèmes techniques
LISTNUM 95 \l 11780 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Don't hire him for sound production, eh?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11781 MR. STRATI: Sorry, my media player.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11782 MR. MILES: That's why he's not in the engineering department.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11783 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: How did you get your newscast to start at 7:30 and end at 7:03?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11784 MS MORTON: All right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11785 MR. MILES: 7:31, 7:32.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11786 MS MORTON: Maybe we'll hear the parody song later.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11787 The great thing about programming from the Content Factory is that it will be available only on radio, and it will serve to further differentiate radio from other options available to local listeners. We need more programming that tries to accomplish that, and we think the Rock 105 Content Factory is a step in the right direction.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11788 An entertaining radio show requires resources and more depth than one person at the mike can provide. Most stations address this by adding voices into their morning shows, a co‑host, someone doing sports, someone else on traffic and weather, a news person. Too often this translates into nothing but more talk and not necessarily into more compelling and entertaining content. We're starting to see that listeners don't necessarily want more people talking to them in the morning, they want people focusing more specifically on how to inform them in an entertaining way.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11789 Rather than adding new voices to a morning show, we would include additional producers. Where more support is needed, we would establish a team of people behind the host, contributing creative ideas, production segments, and voice‑over bits, people who have hosted their own shows or who can bring creative talent to their roles.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11790 Content Factory staff will be comprised of people with creative or comedy‑writing experience, producers, and former on‑air personalities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11791 Another under used source of content is the inclusion of listener input. At Rock 105, all of our announcers will incorporate listeners' calls into at least two breaks per hour. This listener interaction will provide local perspective and encourage a dialogue between listeners on the air.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11792 Our Impact 105 phone line will also provide our audience with the opportunity to leave messages and commentary on a variety of subjects. These messages will then be produced and scheduled as on‑air programming content, covering topics like the possibility of a strike at the Goodyear plant, the effect of Canadian foreign policy on soldiers and their families, or local reaction to the provincial candidates' debate. This interactivity will also be carried through to our Rock 105 website, generating an enhanced level of input and participation from our listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11793 If anything, the phenomenal success of websites such as YouTube and MySpace have shown us that media consumers also want to express themselves and be content creators. At Rock 105, we have to try and do the same, whether through listener calls, website chatter, or features such as DJ For A Night, we have to provide opportunities for the active participation of our listeners. More involvement and more access can only mean that Rock 105 will be more local in its orientation and more community‑based in its reflection.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11794 Kevin...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11795 MR. McKANNA: Thank you, Sarah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11796 In reflecting the needs and interests of our listeners, Rock 105 will also have access to other valuable resources within Rogers Radio.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11797 In April of this year, we launched 660 News in Calgary, our newest all‑news radio station. We have invested over $2.8 million, and we have hired more than 36 full‑time and part‑time staff, including local news reporters, a meteorologist, and dedicated reporters for our business and sports.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11798 Together with our stations in Lethbridge, Rock 105 will also have access to a strong regional news team in southern Alberta.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11799 A connection to our news content software system will provide local news producers with immediate access to stories and segments from other news departments. The Content Factory will then use and adapt these stories to reflect the interests and concerns of local listeners in Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11800 The key here is availability. All of these resources and all of this content will be made available to the Rock 105 Content Factory. The objective is not to replace local news and information, but, rather, to supplement it and provide the opportunity for the insertion of local context and perspective.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11801 It's really about enhancing the listener experience and differentiating our local content from what is available elsewhere. That's precisely why we also believe that new media will provide opportunities for us to broaden our relationship with listeners and establish more communities of interest. We are focusing on harnessing the brand power of our stations and extending it to deliver more local content and more services.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11802 A few months ago, we launched a VIP program for many of our station websites. Through new media, our listeners can now more actively participate and interact with our stations initiating a strong bond with our stations and our on‑air personalities. The VIP program has proven to be extremely successful in driving traffic to our stations and our websites. At CHEZ‑FM, our classic rock station in Ottawa, 20 percent of its listeners base has already registered as VIP members.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11803 Internet technology has become a part of daily life for most of us, but for the rock audience this is especially true. Rock listeners go to the Internet to source a wide variety of information, and they expect to be able to interact with their favourite radio station online. Rock 105's website will establish an online community, one where listeners can not only access music content and local information, but they'll also interact with our on‑air personalities. Blogs, commentaries, and community postings will allow listeners to connect with station personalities and with each other. We want to encourage more peer‑to‑peer contact between listeners and develop a community of interest that transcends music.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11804 More than ever, local is the key to our success. Today, local also means a strong new media presence on the Internet. At Rock 105, we'll establish an informative and entertaining new media platform to bring our local listeners even closer together.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11805 Terry...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11806 MR. VOTH: Thanks, Kevin.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11807 The Medicine Hat radio market is, itself, quite isolated, and local listeners have little access to out‑of‑market stations. With few competitors and formats, existing stations are programmed to respond to as broad a variety of musical tastes as possible; however, no station is dedicated to the rock format, and rock music fans have no choice but to listen to other stations, even though they don't consistently play the music they want to hear. Many would‑be listeners are, instead, turning to other options like satellite radio, iPods, and the Internet. In an increasingly open system, it becomes imperative that we provide a localized option to compete for the time and attention of local listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11808 Strong brands and local and long‑term programming investments will ensure that our stations can continue to deliver local programming that meet the expectations of our listeners and keeps them as consumers in our Canadian Broadcasting System.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11809 At Rogers Radio, we consistently seek out new and popular radio formats. JACKfm is a good example of our ability to develop a unique and distinctive format for Canadian radio. We also have extensive programming experience with the rock music format, having used it with great success in Lethbridge.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11810 For Rock 105, we've proposed a wide variety of music programs and features. Programming like the Six O'Clock Six Pack, the Top 30 Countdown, and thematic rock weekends will engage and entertain listeners providing a differentiated and localized music approach for Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11811 Rock stations are exciting places to work, exciting because each station still has the ability individually to make a tangible contribution in promoting and developing Canadian talent at the local level. We know, we operate rock stations in other markets, and each of them has made a significant contribution to the development and promotion of new artists and local talent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11812 With no dedicated rock station in Medicine Hat, many would‑be rock listeners will continue to turn to the Internet in their search for new music or emerging artists. They currently have no option but to access other available sources for rock music. If they continue to do so, we lose an irreplaceable opportunity to promote Canadian music, an opportunity to showcase new artists and local talent to rock listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11813 Rock 105 will provide extensive promotional support and on‑air exposure for new artists and local talent. We, specifically, proposed a number of new music features, programs like the New Rock Nation, Dig Deep 105, and the Rock 105 Steel Cage Match.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11814 We have also committed to spending a total of $1 million to support Canadian talent with at least half of that supporting local and regional initiatives in Alberta.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11815 $500,000 to Radio Starmaker to support emerging Canadian music stars.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11816 $300,000 to the Alberta Recording Industry Association to develop southern Alberta talent with networking nights, local symposiums, and career consults in areas outside of Edmonton and Calgary.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11817 And $200,000 to the Medicine Hat College Conservatory of Music and Dance to provide additional resources and support for music development initiatives, scholarships and special projects.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11818 We believe the benefits package we have proposed will provide much needed resources for the continuing efforts of these organizations. Our proposal reflects our commitment to the community of Medicine Hat and our investment in the success of the rock format in southern Alberta.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11819 Gary?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11820 MR. MILES: Before I conclude, with your indulgence, we have the parody song ready to go.
‑‑‑ Audio Clip / Clip audio
LISTNUM 95 \l 11821 MR. MILES: In conclusion, with Rock 105, we are proposing to offer Medicine Hat listeners with their very own local destination for radio rock music. They deserve it. No other format provides as many dedicated listeners as rock. For decades, rock music fans have developed the unique connection with their music as a means of cultural expression and identity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11822 The introduction of Rock 105 will provide a fresh and unique perspective on local news and information, not only increasing the diversity of news and editorial opinion, but also establishing a unique approach to local programming, one that we believe is more consistent with the tastes and habits of rock music listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11823 Our application demonstrates our commitment to serve the community of Medicine Hat. Rock 105 will fill a void in this market and provide local listeners with a true dedicated voice for rock music.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11824 Our proposed initiatives totalling one million will assist local, regional, and national organizations in their efforts to promote and develop Canadian talent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11825 For all of these reasons, we believe the approval of our application would be in the public interest, and we look forward to any questions you may have.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11826 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11827 THE CHAIRPERSON: Commissioner Pennefather?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11828 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11829 Good morning, and thank you for your presentation. I will have some questions on programming and the music and spoken word, which the Content Factory will create, the talent development, and, obviously, your business plan.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11830 So although I won't sing the questions, we will start with music. You have said throughout your Brief, and I assume that that's maintained in the presentation this morning, that you will offer a broad‑based rock format including music from the 1960s through the early‑1990s with some more recent rock. And I believe in your deficiency May 19th, you focus on a rather large 25 to 54‑year‑old male skewed demographic. Is that still the case?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11831 MR. MILES: That is correct. The station will probably skew about 60 percent male, 40 percent female.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11832 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: 60/40? And what would the median age be?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11833 MR. MILES: 33.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11834 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: 33. So given that, if we could just probe a little bit more the rock music so we get a better sense of what it will sound like. Is your format more accurately described as mainstream AOR or classic rock, given your emphasis on the '70s, '80s, '90s?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11835 MR. MILES: I'm going to turn this question over to Terry. He operates this format in Lethbridge, sort of down the street and around the corner. We also, however, operate this in similar size markets in Ontario north, very successful. We have chosen a broad‑based rock format for a couple of reasons, one is it's ability to be a little more male than female, which fits in well in the competitive nature in Medicine Hat of the existing clients. Secondly, because of the nature of the in‑migration into the Province of Alberta, the median age is a lot younger than it is in the rest of the provinces. And, thirdly, because the broad‑based rock format allows the greatest opportunity to showcase new emerging Canadian talent and Canadian artists.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11836 So, Terry, perhaps you could start with a bit of the air balance that would be able to describe better the format composition.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11837 MR. VOTH: For sure, Gary.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11838 The other applications, I would say, are not as broad as we are. Truly, when we say a broad‑based rock format, I would say we definitely have that. When it comes to current music, we're talking about actually 35‑percent modern and adult rock, Canadian bands like Sloan, Three Days Grace, for example. 25 percent of our music would be what we call album rock or AOR, bands like the Tragically Hip, Van Halen; 25 percent true classic rock, which is the '60s and '70s referred to, Led Zeppelin, The Guess Who, Bachman‑Turner Overdrive, and 15 percent of our music would be the adult rock component, which is, for example, new songs by Tom Cochrane and Colin James.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11839 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Looking at it differently, could you break it down by decade, how much '60s, '70s, '80s, '90s?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11840 MR. VOTH: I could. I would say about 33 percent of the music will come from 2004 right up to current music. In terms of the '80s, we'd be looking at about 15 percent, '60s/'70s would be about 25 percent, and '90s, I believe, would be about 10 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11841 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And given the rather large age distribution, even though we're looking at a median age of 33, it's 25 to 54 skewing male. Do you intend to target? Do you intend to use different music in different day parts?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11842 MR. VOTH: We would be slightly day‑parted at nighttime because frankly during the night is more of an 18 to 34 population that is available for radio, so you skew a little bit harder, a little bit more modern, like you still play a lot of classic rock, a little bit of adult rock, but during the day time is when it's definitely ‑‑ you know, until ‑‑ from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m., say, is going to be the broadest 25 to 44 appeal.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11843 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: 25 to 34, so ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 11844 MR. VOTH: 25 to 54, pardon me.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11845 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Throughout the day, would you say you have a core demographic within that range?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11846 MR. VOTH: If we wanted to narrow it down further, it would be 25 to 44 with first emphasis on 35 to 44, second emphasis on 25 to 34.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11847 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So the emphasis is the 35 to 44 side of that, if I heard you correctly? Okay. Now, you've indicated that, I believe, in the August 16 deficiency that you ‑‑ that nearly a hundred percent of your programming will be locally produced, but that voice‑tracked or automated programming will account for up to 20 percent of the broadcast week. You've also indicated your intention to offer some syndicated programming. So how many hours on average per week do you plan to devote to syndicated programs? When would these air, and what would the impact be on your weekly local programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11848 MR. McKANNA: I'll answer that question. Voice tracking, 20 percent would be 26 hours. At this point, we haven't got any syndicated programming that we're looking at, but I'd like to give you the breakdown of the actual voice‑tracked hours as well. That would be evenings from 8 p.m. to midnight and weekends would be on Saturday from 9 p.m. to midnight and Sunday from 6 p.m. to 9 p.m., So there is the total of 26 hours of voice tracking.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11849 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: That's the voice tracking. What about syndicated? Do you plan to use any syndicated programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11850 MR. McKANNA: Not at this point, no.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11851 MR. MILES: If I may just interject for a second, we tend to view voice tracking a tad differently. We think it's a very important part of programming. And it's not as if ‑‑ that when voice tracking is on there's no one at the radio station, so the radio station really is ‑‑ has operators on during the period of time when voice tracking is on, but if you think about it, we've got, at the resources of Rogers, some very, very talented people who actually can provide stronger content and stronger association with the music at certain times of the day than we're able to recruit locally. That doesn't make the local people a bad thing. We take that opportunity to reinvest into things such as the Content Factory and more people behind the scenes doing different parts of radio. So we're trying more than ever before to swing away from the old traditional ways of doing radio, into utilizing resources so that we're able to compete with this influx of new media and provide new opportunities. So it's not a cost‑cutting issue, it's a matter of reallocating resources at the correct time.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11852 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you, Mr. Miles.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11853 We'll get back to obviously discussing this approach throughout the questioning, and I appreciate you adding it to each of the components of my questions because it will give us a better understanding. Just looking at my question from the other side so that I'm clear ‑‑ my colleagues like to start me off first thing in the morning, but I don't think I had my second cup of coffee yet. So in terms of the amount of voice track, in terms of the broadcast day, if we turned around the other way, the percentage of live programming would be?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11854 MR. McKANNA: 80 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11855 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: 80 percent? And would you be willing to accept a COL in that regard should we so decide?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11856 MR. McKANNA: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11857 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11858 Now, let's look at the spoken word programming, and if you would allow, I would like, first, to clarify the spoken word programming content as closely as we can in terms of hours. We'll get to the approach after that where we can expand a little bit on the components of the Content Factory, but just so we review what's on record to date, in the May 19th deficiency response you indicated you would devote 17 percent of the broadcast week to spoken word, which translates into 21 hours and 25 minutes. And, again, in the same deficiency letter at answer 3, you said there will be news, weather, sports within the 105‑second Reality Check, of which we heard a sample. So we have ‑‑ we're up now to a total of 56 minutes a week of spoken word. We add to that ten minutes a week for rock news, so we're up to an hour and six minutes spoken word. We add to this an hour for what was called Restaurant and Pub Crawl and Community Events Calendar, and we're up to two hours and six minutes. Am I doing okay here? So this would be what one might conclude would be more traditional, if I may be allowed to use that word, spoken word, if ‑‑ would you agree?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11859 MR. MILES: So far, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11860 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Yes. So we're back to our 17 percent, which leaves us ‑‑ we were up to two hours and six minutes or 17 percent of 126 hours. That leaves us with 19 hours of what we might call unstructured spoken word. Are we then on the same wave length?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11861 MR. MILES: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11862 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So is this the spoken word that will be woven through the programming throughout the broadcast days, this part of your programming approach?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11863 MR. MILES: Kevin is going to give you the exact breakdown, and we have it so that we can file it at the end of the hearing, but one of the things that ‑‑ I'm sure we made the mistake on that one is that when we were talking about the amount of spoken word, we also had our commercial content in there, so now it starts to get more into line with the normal pattern of jock talk as well as the ability to take what we're doing in the Content Factory ‑‑ we've wrestled with this for some time because we've had a couple of appearances before you in which we've tried to explain the different kind of programming, so we put it more into very specific time periods and assigned time to it, although that's not necessarily the way it would be. It's just that in order to make sure that we were able to be clear on the amount of programming that we had and the content in it is that we've actually identified specific time periods for it, and that will form the basis of the explanation that Kevin is going to give you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11864 MR. McKANNA: So, correct, it is 19 hours, and that breaks out as newscasts at two hours and 15 minutes. The Content Factory is two hours and 30 minutes, music features, one hour and 20 minutes, so that's a total of six. Jock talk in the morning show, four hours, at 12 minutes an hour, four hours, five days. That's your four hours. Midday and afternoon are both four hours with the same breakout. Evening is 1.5 hours, and weekends is 2.5 hours for a total of 12, and we also include public service announcements for a total of one hour for the week, so there's 19 hours.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11865 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So you will be tabling that breakdown with us?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11866 MR. McKANNA: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11867 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: That's very helpful because it's a little different from what I was left with reading the deficiency to date. So we're looking at the percentage ‑‑ 17 is not quite accurate. It's actually ‑‑ let's talk about 19 hours of spoken word, which you've broken down as you've just described, so I'll work with that. Now, within that, we have news for how many hours?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11868 MR. McKANNA: Two hours and 15 minutes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11869 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So, again, it's pretty ‑‑ in that sense, that's close with ‑‑ to the application as we've seen it to this point. Let's talk a little bit now about the approach and the news, the two hours. Will it be a newscast, weather, sports? How often will it happen? Will it be closer to the traditional approach? You said here in your presentation today ‑‑ the reason I'm asking is replacing, you say, the traditional exclusive focus on the newsroom. Now, does that mean you will not have newscasts at specific hours during the day? What do those words mean, in fact?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11870 MR. MILES: Perhaps I could frame this in terms of the thrust of our presentation, with your permission, and then we will answer your specific questions. Sarah will tell you a little bit about how the Content Factory will work and how those things ‑‑ and then we do have specific times that the newscasts will call including what comprises of the Content Factory. But our approach is that if we were to apply for this licence five years ago, I'd rather suspect that we would have had lengthy newscasts, and they would have been at the top of the hour and the bottom of the hour because, frankly, that's the way radio run ‑‑ was run at those days, and we still operate some radio stations in some markets, not in this format that way. So we look upon that today as those were the good old days, and I suspect when we're before you in the next two years we'll look upon our idea and our concept that we're trying to put forward here as those were the good old days. So what we're trying to do is to capture our audience's attention in ways that are not tradition because they don't listen to radio and to music in the old traditional ways any more. We really are trying to figure out if this is the right approach. It may well not be. It may well be that the right approach to serving communities like this is with extensive newscasts. As I say, we operate some radio stations in similar sized markets, not in a rock format, in which we do a lot of this extensive news programming. So we're trying to make sure that when they can hear the same music from a lot of different sources, what's going to keep them tuned to a local radio station in Medicine Hat and understand it, and we think it's content and entertaining that reflects the nature of what's happening in the community and in the province that they will not be able to get anywhere else.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11871 We actually have some stats from satellite radio listening in some of our research that, perhaps, later on we can bring up, but it's ‑‑ it's a bit frightening from a local radio broadcaster. Anyway, let's start with what the Content Factory is made up of, if you don't mind.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11872 And, Sarah?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11873 MS MORTON: Sure.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11874 We'll have six programming people at Rock 105, three of those will be on‑air, and three of them will be off‑air. They'll be dedicated people to the Content Factory led by the program director. These people will provide the news, they'll create the traditional newscasts that you'll hear in the morning show and in the afternoon show, but in addition to that what they'll do is take the news and information and create it into entertaining content for our listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11875 You are hearing us talk a lot about content today, and, you know, there's a buzz phrase in the industry right now, content is king, and it really is the differentiating factor for radio right now. You know, we ‑‑ we are fighting ‑‑ fighting it out with new technologies in a market like Medicine Hat where there is no rock station providing music to the rock audience, those people are sourcing their music in other ways: They're going to the Internet, they're using their iPods, and those are sources for music that are not currently providing them with news and information.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11876 So as a rock station coming into a market like that, you have to find ways to ‑‑ to entertain and keep your audience with you. They're used to sourcing their information outside of their music sources.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11877 And so what it does is create an opportunity for us to take news and information, repackage it, make ‑‑ create entertaining content, and then find ways to inform our listeners further with those new technologies. So that bears the opportunity to take our listeners to the website, offer them further information on the website, and through the new technology.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11878 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Could I just ask you to ‑‑ let's try to be a little precise on ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 11879 MR. MILES: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11880 MS MORTON: Mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11881 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: ‑‑ some of the components of Content Factory.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11882 MS MORTON: Sure.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11883 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And I'll use your presentation. You mentioned six staff. Are these journalists?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11884 MS MORTON: The ‑‑ those are six programming staff, so three will be on‑air, you know ‑‑ they'll be on‑air talent, and the three content ‑‑ dedicated Content Factory staff will have a news background that, you know, is certainly an important part of what they would bring to the table, but we're also looking for people who ‑‑ who can come at that news from a creative way, so people with writing and production backgrounds as well.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11885 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So this is in your presentation today when you talked about additional producers ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 11886 MS MORTON: Mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11887 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: ‑‑ a team of people behind the host? These are, essentially, writers, comedy writers, people who can do the interpretation ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 11888 MS MORTON: That's right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11889 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: ‑‑ and do the kind of parody work that you presented to us; is that correct?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11890 MS MORTON: That's right, mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11891 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: You also have another element called Listener Input. You will incorporate listener calls into at least two breaks per hour. Is this also part of the Content Factory created by the same writers?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11892 MS MORTON: It is a source of content definitely, and those listener calls will be produced and expanded upon and be a source of ‑‑ a source for the Content Factory. I think, additionally, though, it's a way of using listeners to provide news and information and ‑‑ and local context and perspective on new stories of the day.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11893 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Is this the same thing as our impact ‑‑ your Impact 105 phone line messages produced and scheduled as on air‑programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11894 MS MORTON: Mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11895 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Is it the same thing?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11896 MS MORTON: Well, no, those are two different things. The listener line is a place where listeners can call and leave messages and perspectives, that information would be taken by the Content Factory and ‑‑ and used as material there. The calls that our on‑air announcers would be encouraged to take throughout their programs would be where the local context in perspective ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 11897 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: How would you go about choosing which calls to use?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11898 MS MORTON: That is up to the on‑air host at the time. You know, when ‑‑ I'll maybe use an example from Edmonton because this is something that we do at SONiC in Edmonton. We encourage all of our on‑air staff to take listener calls and to ask listeners for their input. And what we've found is that when you give listeners the opportunity to give an opinion and ask them to call with traffic reports and comments on ‑‑ on public works and a whole variety of things, they respond to you, and they start to call on a regular basis and give you all kinds of information. You know, I think listeners are used to being programmed to, rather than being asked to contribute to programming. And when you ask them to contribute, they do.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11899 MR. MILES: What we found as we moved more and more into this new media is that we have a brand and we have a personality, and, traditionally, they were on a radio, and you listened to them through various media, various outlets, and it was sort of a no connection. Now, with the ability of use the web and loyalty program and bring them back in, we have them go out, and then they start to come back in. And they start to form parts of the programming, and so the answer to your question about who would sort of decide what call to take, well, actually the announcer that's live on the air that starts to understand what the pattern is of what's going on, taking stuff out of the parody song that we had, taking stuff from the news. It's incorporated into their topical talk patterns as they go throughout the day, and then they start to bring this back on. In one of the instances in some of our stations, we actually have the listeners program a half hour of the music, and so how ‑‑ you get talking to them, and they come back in, and they select it. We tell them it's going to be on at such and such a time on Thursday, they tell all their friends, they get involved on the thing. It's getting them back involved into the process so that it's just not a matter of tuning into channel 2653, if you can ever find it on a satellite radio, and bringing down that particular format and just listening to it. It's an involvement process.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11900 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: I think what will be helpful is when we see, also, the ‑‑ if you table with us the spoken word and the way it will be presented throughout the broadcast day. While I don't want to sound like too much of a traditionalist, it is difficult to get a picture here of what the listeners will have in terms of spoken word. If the spoken word you're describing could occur during a morning program, I've listened to them in Toronto on Rogers where there's the banter going on, and there's a fair degree of comedy interspersed with some music, it would then look like more of a typical station, if you will. So if we could get a sense of that from what you're going to table, that would be very helpful. And with this kind of phone‑in and also the use of opinions and listener input, I assume, obviously, that Rogers will maintain the codes that are ‑‑ the regulatory codes related to on‑air content?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11901 MR. MILES: We will and quite prepared to commit to that. In fact, you know, part of the Content Factory will be somebody who, in a more traditional sense would have been the news editor, just so that there is this sense of understanding, and so if something drastic and serious is happening, we're not going to be making light‑hearted comments on it, it will be more traditional. And our scheduling does call for that on the radio station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11902 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Now, there's a couple of questions that come to mind when I listen to the approach you're taking. One is that perhaps the approach ‑‑ and some of the two examples you gave us might tend to lead us to think that the approach you're talking about is more associated with other formats with youth, with younger listeners. You're skewing to not only 25 to 54, but the 35 to 44 component of that, if we recall our previous discussion. So why do you think that this approach will work with an audience of adult listeners?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11903 MR. MILES: Well, I think that everybody actually wants to be a little younger than they currently are, and that's number one. Number two, the phenomena that we're seeing in our research that we're ‑‑ I, for one, would do that. The research that we're seeing as we roll throughout Alberta is that with the tremendous migration inward into the province, there's now a new influx of 25‑34s that hasn't been before, so you are correct in a more traditional form this would skew a little bit older, but we are actually finding out now that the market composition in large and non‑metro markets as well is more evenly split, 25‑34, 35‑44, 45‑54. And the rock idiom transcends all of those things, and you've heard from Terry our composition, and so a great ‑‑ a broad‑based rock format has the ability to bring all these people together into one area, and the market can sustain this one because there currently is no rock radio station, and we'll have the ability to capture them in this area. And we will be serious when it's time for serious news, but people want to be entertained.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11904 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: No, I do understand the approach. It was a question of trying to get clarification as you know throughout today and yesterday on your core audience. Just on that point as well, some of the programming approach you've described, if I could put it this way, could be listened to anywhere. Now, how local will this Content Factory be for the listeners in Medicine Hat, and how do you accomplish that localism?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11905 MS MORTON: Local will be a priority, definitely, for the Content Factory. You know, listeners are interested first and foremost in what's going on in their world and how it affects them, and that means local news. So local ‑‑ local news and information will comprise 75 percent of what the Content Factory does. And, you know, also looking for ways to tie in national stories on a local level and being able to relate to the audience in that way.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11906 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: I believe you have mentioned the 75 percent local in previous correspondence. Would you accept that as a condition of licence if we so decide, 75 percent local content?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11907 MS MORTON: We would, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11908 MR. MILES: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11909 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: There's one other question I had just reading, again, your presentation this morning and the website, and clearly ‑‑ you've laid out quite clearly how you see the website incorporated into the Content Factory. Would the local content ‑‑ we're discussing the on‑air content, correct? And it will be 75 percent local?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11910 MR. MILES: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11911 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: It's ‑‑ in reading this, one might be concerned that the online community would be the local component as opposed to the on‑air component, so we just wanted to be clear on that point.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11912 MR. MILES: Perhaps the best way to explain that would be to give you some examples of things we're currently doing and how it ties in. I'm going to start with Sarah, then I'll go to Kevin, and then to Terry. Each one will have a specific example. But, again, without sounding too repetitive on this one, what we're attempting to establish is the brand and the format going out to the listener and having them come back in so that they get totally committed to the radio station so that there is a framework around the 17 rock songs or the five modern songs or this kind of thing that they can get anywhere else. And we're doing that in different ways, and Sarah, perhaps, one example, and then followed by Kevin and Terry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11913 MS MORTON: Sure. I think it's important to understand that ‑‑ in particular, like, our rock audience, you really can't separate the radio station from the website any more. The two reflect one another on an ongoing basis. At SONiC in Edmonton, each of our announcers have a blog page that they update regularly with personal experiences and observations, and listeners can leave comments on those pages, and it becomes an ongoing commentary and discussion between the announcers and listeners, between listeners, as well, on those pages. You know, we also include things that we're doing on the air on the website, so any ‑‑ any artist performances in our performance studios are placed on the web site, interviews with artists. So you hear them on the air, but, additionally, you can go to the website to download them, here the pod cast of them. We also conduct regular surveys with our listeners on the website, allowing listeners programming input with the radio station and feeling like they are a part of it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11914 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11915 We'll move on to Canadian talent development, and I'm looking at your deficiency response dated May 19th where we asked for a cost breakdown associated with the funds earmarked for the Conservatory of Music and Dance. And aside from asserting that the funds would go directly to musicians and artists attending the institution, you indicated that the conservatory will have control over the funds earmarked to them, but that Rogers will provide input into the overall development of these initiatives. So I'd like to explore this a little more with you. How will the funds be allocated to the conservatory? That is, will this be in the form of multiple scholarships, for instance? How will it work?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11916 MR. STRATI: Well, in ‑‑ we've talked to ‑‑ for example, talked to Lyle Revic(ph) from the conservatory, and we've talked about different initiatives that are involved in different projects they're working on. For example, they do have an academy program that is sort of the higher end to bring in people in the ‑‑ students who are in both music and dance categories, but who have sort of already developed expertise and very strong interest in this area. So there are some scholarships that are currently available that are made locally, but some of them are part ‑‑ sort of part scholarships. They're not full scholarships. So certainly, scholarships or the increase of scholarships for students is one area. There are also some that we had discussed about some symposiums and some special projects where you could look at either someone who is coming in locally as an artist, who would then have an opportunity, not only if they're at, for example, the Esplanade in Medicine Hat, there would be a performance. There could also be an opportunity to tie in with the college and the conservatory where they could come and meet the students and talk about their experiences. That's another area we talked about. And another one is instruments. I mean, they have an instrument rental program at the conservatory, and you could look to augment that and also to provide even for the purchasing of instruments. So it's a bit of those three areas in terms scholarships, some special projects, and the instruments. So those are the three elements we've talked about.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11917 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So you have had discussions with the conservatory on the distribution and allocation of the funds?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11918 MR. STRATI: Yes, absolutely.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11919 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And have you any written agreement as to the allocation of the funds?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11920 MR. STRATI: No written agreement, but certainly we could ‑‑ I'd be ‑‑ we could discuss it further and have sort of some further specificity in terms of the breakout, but it was ‑‑ you know, we had talked roughly in terms of one‑third for each of the different elements, you know, that would be a guide ‑‑ a guide in terms of how the allocations had be ‑‑ preferable if one year there was a special project that they could allocate those resources towards a special project, rather than others, but certainly we could provide that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11921 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So one‑third ‑‑ could you just give me that again?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11922 MR. STRATI: Sure. The one‑third disseminated to scholarships, one‑third to special projects, and one‑third to the instruments.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11923 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: To the instruments?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11924 MR. STRATI: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11925 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And just in terms of your ‑‑ us being able to be sure that the funds actually do go where you had described them as going as therefore being appropriate contributions under CTD, could you advise us on what you have in place to ensure that the funds do go to this project?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11926 MR. STRATI: Sure. And that's part of the ‑‑ absolutely. That's part of the mention of consultation. It's not that we will be consulted on the actual decisions that are made by the conservatory. I think they would be more sort of the decider, if you will, in terms of where they see the money or working with the scholarships. Our role would be to ensure, like you've mentioned, that just to get a good sense that the money is allocated and spent in a way that is appropriate for regulatory purposes and for meeting our conditions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11927 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: With respect to that, would you care to comment on the possibility of a condition of licence to the effect that you would have in place an agreement that there was some feedback to you on the allocation of the funds?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11928 MR. STRATI: Absolutely.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11929 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay. We'll go on to the business plan and economic analysis component, and I have a question on your revenue projections. We note that your revenue projections are lower than most of the other applicants for the Medicine Hat market. Do you think you may have underestimated the potential radio advertising revenue available to a new station?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11930 MR. MILES: Well, we are ‑‑ I'm going to actually have Leda discuss the formula that we used to come up with it, but just as a general observation, it's enticing to be from outside of Alberta and think that the streets are paved with oil as it were, and in some of the markets it actually is true. The ‑‑ we operate radio station a similar format, more competition in a market just up the street, and we haven't particularly seen this massive influx of wealth descending into the streets of Lethbridge. I think that we find that it gets a little less as it goes down. There's no arguing about the retail sales ability. Radio station sales are based on competitive natures of people, and, you know, this market is still 55, 60,000. In order for radio sales to be really good, it needs four car dealers, not two. That's sort of the general way that it goes. So we're ‑‑ we think that it's going to be a little longer and a little tougher slug. The competitor that's in there, Pattison, is a great radio broadcaster. He bought great radio stations. These stations, the old CHAT, Medicine Hat, boy, there's lots of heritage and lots of relationship with the advertisers and the operator television station. So this is not going to be an immediate form of let's get the revenue on the radio station. We think we've been conservative, and we based, frankly, on our experience 90 clicks away.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11931 Leda, perhaps you can just outline the formula that we used.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11932 MS MacLEOD: Basically we looked at ‑‑ we estimated what the market would be based on our experience in Lethbridge and in other markets of similar size across the country, and we applied our formulas based on what we felt our revenue share ‑‑ achievable revenue share would be. We always believe in trying to do our best, but we will not overpromise and underdeliver. So we believe this is a true ‑‑ a true estimate of what we can do.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11933 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Now, I have your ‑‑ this is the appendix that you've included with Appendix B in terms of the comparison with Lethbridge. Looking at this market, what are your comments on the possibility of Medicine Hat markets supporting more than one new station at this time?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11934 MR. MILES: I think that it could support a mainstream station and a what we'll call a niche format or a smaller market format ability. I think that ‑‑ and, again, I come back to it. The good one radio stations in this market place. The marketplace while it's growing, it still listened to one of the northern Alberta marketplace. The entire oil and gas industry is not quite the immense bubble that it was a little while ago. And we planned this radio station and looked forward to two to five to seven years. We've been down this road before. We've seen the ups, and we've seen the downs. We love to operate radio stations when things are going up, but I'll tell you, it's a little tougher when it goes down.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11935 So, Angela, you've been in the marketplace, and you've had a discussion with some of the merchants. What's your general opinion of the retail sales?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11936 MS REIMER: Well, having gone down to the market and spoke to some of the business community and the Chamber, there is, obviously, a lot of the business community spends some money in the local radio landscape there. There is others, however, that obviously doesn't fulfill their needs, so they're going to other media avenues such as print or billboard or even television there.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11937 There is an opportunity ‑‑ obviously, there is a big hole as the other applicants and ourselves are going for a rock station with a male skew. So there is money there to be had from existing clients, from new clients to radio for a rock‑based station, male‑skewed station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11938 It's a strong economy, but it goes up and down with the oil and gas and particularly gas in this market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11939 At this point, speaking to some of them ‑‑ well, I was there when the gas was down a bit, they were seeing immediate changes because of that, immediate impact in terms of expenditure in their market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11940 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11941 My last question ‑‑ we've asked this question to other applicants as well. If we go back to the beginning and we agreed that you have a very broad‑based rock format, what would be the impact on your proposal if the Commission were to licence another player with one of the ones which has a similar format or the adult standard modern nostalgia format where the listeners are 45 plus? But what would be the impact on your business plan if we were to licence one of the applicants with a similar formula, particularly since you're the broad base of rock that you are?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11942 MR. MILES: Well, first of all, we wouldn't ‑‑ we would not change our format. The other formats that had been suggested the closest that came was a more modern alternative rock‑based ‑‑ broad‑based format. So we would keep it the same. We've operated these formats against competition in the markets, and over the longer period of time, they stand the test of time. So that's number one. Number two, we have made our projections with one station being in the market and another specialty station. The impact of somebody else with a variation of the rock theme would probably extend our financial records one more year out ‑‑ one, two, one‑and‑a‑half years out, so that breaking even would probably be in around year five or six as compared with, I think we suggested it we'd be slightly out of it by year three as we're going into year four, that's been our experience in the past. We've seen this thing. It takes about two years for a marketplace to finally get readjusted back into introduction of new formats, sometimes a little longer if many more formats are introduced into it because it's not just the impact on the retailers and the clients, it's also the impact on the other radio stations themselves and the competitor ‑‑ and the people who are in the market, and a couple of mainstream formats in the market this size will have a fairly dramatic impact, in our opinion, on the current incumbents.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11943 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you very much, Mr. Miles, and all your team for your kind responses to my questions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11944 Those are my questions, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11945 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11946 Vice‑Chair Arpin?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11947 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you very much, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11948 Let's keep talking about the business plan. And I note that in your projections that your national revenues are fairly low, and I know that you've got a lot of experience with national sales in the Rogers group. What are the assumptions for ‑‑ that you have taken into consideration to come up with fairly low national sales revenues, particularly in the earlier years of operation?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11949 MR. MILES: There are three things that we took into consideration: First, this is a unDPMed market, so, therefore, you can't really say that if I have a 22 share, I'm going to get a 22 share of the business. So that's number one. Secondly, this station, I don't care how good it is, and we have a great team, it's not going to garner that right at the very beginning. Station shares grow slowly, and national sales are accumed exactly to the amount of share of audience that you have. So it's going to slowly progress over the period of time.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11950 The other phenomena that, perhaps, is more disheartening, I believe, for non‑metro market radio stations is the ‑‑ there's a swing out of conventional television looking for new homes for advertising. Radio is picking up parts of that. But as the markets continue to grow in the metro markets, there is a reduction in national business that goes into non‑metro markets. It is a fact of life. It's compensated a little bit by regional businesses. So will we have a chance to bring some of our regional business in Alberta with all of our radio stations to this market, yes, we will, and that will make up for it. But in terms of the big national accounts, taking a look at markets of this size, unfortunately, they're tending to spend their money on the larger markets and buying spread and buying bigger markets where there's more bang for the dollar, and so that's why we forecasted the national not to be as robust as it would look until we're able to get some traction and get some ability into these kind of markets from our formats.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11951 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: And by a larger market, are you talking Vancouver, Toronto, Montreal, Calgary, or is it broader than that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11952 MR. MILES: The reality is that the old 80/20 rule really does exist and that 80 percent of the national business is done into the top ten markets across Canada, and it's as a factor of a number of licences in the markets, it's a factor of cost per point in those particular markets. So it is ‑‑ it is what's happening.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11953 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: I want to come back to Mrs. Morton, a discussion ‑‑ the discussions she had with Commissioner Pennefather, particularly regarding the number of on‑air staff. You mentioned that you will have a director of programming. Will he be ‑‑ will he also be part of the six people that you were talking that were ‑‑ will be handling programming, or is it a seventh person?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11954 MS MORTON: No, he would ‑‑ he is part of the six that we talked about.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11955 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: The six?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11956 MS MORTON: Yeah, the program director will also host one of the ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 11957 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: One of the programs?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11958 MS MORTON: One of the programs, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11959 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Now, you said ‑‑ well, obviously someone at some point in time said that they will be more formal news because you cannot always have lightened news, you need to have more formal news. Will you have a news team on top of the six people we've talked about?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11960 MR. MILES: Not on top of, but one of the team will be the news director responsible for the news content on the radio station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11961 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So what we're talking here, it's six people doing all the on‑air, the news, and the Content Factory?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11962 MR. MILES: That is correct. The answer to that is yes, and that leads to the next question is how can that happen, and how it can happen is that while technology is driving us crazy from time to time, it also is assisting in enabling us to do a lot of jobs faster and smarter and better than we've ever done before. You know, all of our newsrooms across Canada have hooked up with the burley system, and this is the ability to gather in information and have it down in front of you, and with a couple of quick edits and things like that, you've got bits of a piece that you can put together. And the same thing is happening with the rest of the technology that we supply all of our radio stations with. So we're ‑‑ I think that, by and large, they're a little shorter on the bodies than they used to be 20 years ago, but there's more equipment and more facilities for them, and there's more programming IQ. I know we've stayed away from the synergy question, and we don't have any problems with the synergy question. That radio station in Medicine Hat will be a radio station in Medicine Hat, for Medicine Hat, run by Medicine Hat people. But the synergies these days come from the ability to take ideas and translate those ideas and put them in and have the local people adapt to them. The synergies these days are the ability for interconnectivity and instant interconnectivity. So before the morning show goes on the air, they already know what the stories are that are happening across Canada because it's on their own screen sitting in front of them. These content people can, at any time of the day, see what's developing and immediately switch and get an impact. So it sounds like it's cumbersome, but it really is very exciting, and it's a very exciting part of it. What we're trying to find out our way of doing it is then taking that and making sure it's also out on the web so that if you missed it there, you can pick up there, and you'll come back, and, oh, my God, I like that bit, so I've got to remember. I'm back in the market tomorrow, I'll tune in the people and see what the morning show has got, what the Content Factory has done. We think it's very exciting.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11963 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: You have a rock station in Lethbridge. Do you have a Content Factory also in Lethbridge?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11964 MR. MILES: Terry, I'll let you answer that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11965 We actually do have a bit of a Content Factory. We haven't formalized it to this nature, but give us a couple of examples, Terry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11966 MR. VOTH: Sure, no problem. The one that comes to mind ‑‑ and, actually, to respond to one of the Commissioner's comments about the age of appeal and so on and so forth, a recent example that we have ‑‑ the Content Factory, by the way, in Lethbridge, while not formal, is, in effect, myself as a program director, not just the general manager of Rock 106, working with the morning team, with our morning host, our morning co‑host, who is also a news person.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11967 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So they're missing you this morning?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11968 MR. VOTH: I haven't talked to them yet. And, actually, our evening fellow who also does production, and he has great ideas, and he brings a different take to it. So I like to kind of bring these minds together informally, and we'll look at things. Can we react as fast as the Content Factory would? Not at this point because we don't have that focus that I would say ‑‑ I agree with Gary, it's very exciting. For example, you know, you take ‑‑ not that long ago, there was this issue of automated garbage containers, which seems pretty mundane stuff, but the fact is, your garbage service is changing, and you don't know when it's changing, when they're going to pick it up. Before it's a staggered route, how much is this going to cost you and stuff, well, so our morning team sees this, and I see this, and we go, okay, it's ‑‑ your garbage container has got a lid and typical stuff, it's got handles on it, what's the big deal about that? Well, when you start thinking about it and getting behind the story, and this is what your Content Factory people would be focused on doing, is you find a few interesting things. One is the city has spent a whole bunch of money sending out these glossy, expensive pamphlets to say your new garbage containers are coming. It's kind of like the new phone books are coming, the new phone books are coming. Secondly, the most interesting thing I thought was they're conducting seminars on how to use your garbage can, so we're kind of looking at this and going, you can't not get into that, and the difference between, you know, the typical news approach ‑‑ I think the typical news approach would say your garbage containers are coming out Monday, and here's where they're coming, and here's the zone, and here's how much they're going to cost you. That's great. But your Content Factory people are going to look, as I like to say it, to the left side of the road where everybody else is looking at the right, and they're looking at the left side and going, hmm, there's some interesting possibilities here. So they're talking about something that your constituents, your listeners, adults included, are all interested in, but they're taking that side to get just a little more of their attention. And, certainly, what happened when we took this story on and started talking about it is, of course, people were calling. And they started talking about how the city is spending money, and why do we need these new cans, and why am I not getting them, and why is my neighbour getting one? And it was ‑‑ it was great. It turned into an entertaining news story.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11969 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11970 Will you have synergies between Lethbridge and Medicine Hat if you were to be granted, and what kind of synergies in terms of both programming and business?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11971 MR. MILES: The synergies we bring are really best practices. The synergies we bring are different ways and innovative ways that have worked in other markets, and we give them to the people in that local market. So it's more a behind the scenes synergy as compared with we do this program, we're going to put it over there and do that. We don't do that. It is more the programming and sales and marketing IQ synergies that we have throughout the company that we continue to exploit.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11972 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: The two clips we heard this morning, obviously, were not produced in Medicine Hat, and they were of high quality. Were they produced in Lethbridge?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11973 MR. MILES: No, they were produced in Edmonton.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11974 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: They were produced in Edmonton? And could we expect the same level of quality in Medicine Hat?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11975 MR. MILES: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11976 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: It's a much smaller market, much smaller base of talent, and ‑‑ but you're ‑‑ you're feeling that you have the ability to find the people and obviously the technology so that you can ‑‑ you're going to ‑‑ I understand SONiC hasn't been on air for about a year, a year and a half, but technology goes so fast that you may contemplate sending the equipment from Edmonton to Medicine Hat and buy new equipment for Edmonton?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11977 MR. MILES: I'm going to mark that down, and I think the people in Edmonton will be marking it down. What we do ‑‑ no, and that's what we're very proud of is that we have operations in different sized markets, and we're always on the lookout for talent, and we create talent, and we bring them in. And it's this process of moving talent through the operations that is the thing that I'm most proud of, the ability to bring in new people. We started a morning show out in Canmore, they're now up in North Bay. When the current morning show in North Bay left, the world had come to an end, no one was ever going to replace these people. The sales people were running around pulling out their hair, everyone was aghast.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11978 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: But not working for you people, eh?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11979 MR. MILES: That's right. You know, this new morning show has taken over. So to answer your question about the talent, what we do is we take people who are apprenticing in our bigger stations and put them into this. So the idea of the context and the enthusiasm is the same, and we're able to produce the same kind of on‑air experience.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11980 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Well, Madam Chair, those were my questions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11981 THE CHAIRPERSON: Commissioner Cugini?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11982 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11983 Mr. Miles, I was struck this morning by something you said in your oral presentation, and it's, "Whether it's the morning show or news segments or even the ads we sell, we want our listeners to know, at all times, that they are tuned to a rock station." And your audio clips obviously gave us a very good sense of what your radio station will sound like, and I also assume it means Madonna will not be on your play list any time soon, but that's not my question. So I was struck about, "even the ads we sell." I wonder if you could explain to us a little bit what you mean by that. Is it ‑‑ you know, will you be redoing the creative for some of the advertisers, or will you be selecting the advertisers themselves that you will sell time to on this radio station, just what do you mean by, "even the ads we sell."
LISTNUM 95 \l 11984 MR. MILES: One of the programs that we've engaged in in the last four years has been to cement a relationship with the advertisers. My view of the future is there will be fewer advertisers, they will have bigger budgets, and the relationship issue will be the same, but it won't be a relationship as we had in the old days, which was the hale fellow, well meant, a cigar, let's go to the game. Well, maybe part of that's ‑‑ it's a relationship that's a marketing relationship. And we take clients away on four‑day seminars in which we bring in people who are versed in marketing, versed in succession duties. They're typically owner/managers, versed in HR, versed in technical things. They're the people who get up at six in the morning to figure out where the dry route's going to be, going and opening up the store, go deliver the stuff, sell it. They do this kind of stuff, and we've been modestly successful, and I say that hesitantly because I think we've been very successful in growing these people's businesses. So we tend to grow them from that. Part of the things that we talk about at that is that if you're running the Ford dealership, you should be on an adult contemporary station because there are cars that are suitable for that particular audience, and you should be there, and it should be a different kind of approach. If you're going to be selling trucks and SV units on a rock station, it's a different kind of approach. We have our creative people sit in on these sessions, and they start to develop with these owner/managers, which is typically what the business community in Medicine Hat is going to be made up with, of how to actually make sure that that message that's attracted to that radio station does the most effective views. So that's what it's going to be like.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11985 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Thank you. Thank you very much for that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11986 Madam Chair, that's all.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11987 THE CHAIRPERSON: Round two, Commissioner Pennefather.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11988 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: My apologies, Madam Chair, I am back.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11989 I just wanted to follow‑up very briefly on your conversation with Vice‑Chair Arpin. We did discuss that 75 percent of the spoken word would be local, and we agreed that you would agree to a condition of licence. I just wanted to be assured that that 75 percent would also apply to the news component, be it straight on news or be it Content Factory‑created news, that it would be 75 percent local?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11990 MR. MILES: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11991 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11992 THE CHAIRPERSON: I'm sorry, we can't let you go yet. I needed ‑‑ I need some sort of help with a few things. You referred to out of the 19 hours that two hours was going to be Content Factory. And I know that is square peg/round hole or vice versa, but the Content Factory also does the parody songs. Does that sort of include the parody songs?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11993 MR. McKANNA: Yes it does, two hours and 30 minutes, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11994 THE CHAIRPERSON: And, Mr. Strati, you were talking about one‑third of the money going to Medicine Hat College for the instrument rental program?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11995 MR. STRATI: Well, currently there's a rental program. It could also be a rental/purchase program is what we talked about with Mr. Revic.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11996 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So you would, what, subsidize the rent?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11997 MR. STRATI: Yes, that's correct. Subsidize the rental or the purchase of instruments for students at the conservatory involved in the various programs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 11998 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And, Mr. Miles, you talked about providing us with a chart similar to the ones we have been receiving on spoken word. When would you be providing that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 11999 MR. MILES: As soon as we're finished this part. We have it all prepared. Right after we're finish our session. We'll provide it for you today.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12000 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, okay, good enough, mmhmm. And voice tracking, I'm ‑‑ my colleague, Commissioner Pennefather, had a COL from you that you'd be live‑to‑air 80 percent, and that is 80 percent of the broadcast week?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12001 MR. MILES: Correct. I think that's 101 hours or something along that line.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12002 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes. And do you still intend ‑‑ as you said in your supplementary ‑‑ or in your answer to deficiencies of August 16th, do you still intend to ‑‑ at question 2 on page 2 there's a reference here to voice tracking perhaps weekday midday periods.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12003 MR. MILES: We had put that in when we had a schedule that we had looked at, and then when we got around into actually doing it, we just shifted that midday down into the evening part. There is no more, but to answer the question specifically, it's live to air from six in the morning to eight at night, and then operators on from eight until midnight.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12004 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes. And guess I'm ‑‑ there's two issues that come to mind. On page 10 of your submission today, I had little bells going off in my head, and I know I'm a regulator, and I'm not a creative person as you are, but you talk about the audience providing the opportunity to leave messages and commentary, and then they can be produced and scheduled as on‑air programming content. And you have the example of a strike at Goodyear, the effect of the Canadian foreign policy on soldiers, et cetera. What about same‑sex marriage and those tough ones, and how are we going to ensure ‑‑ like you say, you have one ‑‑ I guess as the news director person or somebody because there's a balance issue surely and code adherence issue clearly.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12005 MR. MILES: It is the biggest concern of us in all of our operations. Part of the Content Factory will be the news director, and this person will be ‑‑ again, we'll probably take them from Kevin, 660 News, out of that newsroom so that there is a true news sense. You can't not understand about the news. The other one, remember, would be the program director of the radio station, charged with the responsibility and the fiduciary responsibility of the programming content, and we'll well‑versed in that. We spend a great deal of time in our training programs to ensure that everybody understands about this. So while I can only give you my assurance, I will tell you that there won't be any difference between this operation and the way our other operations are ran for responsibility and adherence to the broadcasting guidelines.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12006 THE CHAIRPERSON: And my final thoughts are ‑‑ and you said, you know, it would impact your ‑‑ it would delay your cash ‑‑ your cash‑even date by a year or two if somebody else in a mainstream format were put in. I guess I concern myself about ‑‑ this Content Factory concept is a bit of a flyer for you. You know, a bit of a new thing for you, and I can see how exciting and interesting it is, but what happens if it doesn't work after two years and we have somebody in the market who may have a COL for a hundred‑percent, you know, voice to ‑‑ live to air, and because of your format and your concept, you're at 80 percent, and so you would change to a format that's ‑‑ that is more mainstream in terms of, I'm going to say less ‑‑ you're less ‑‑ I mean, you have a creative idea here, but you go back to the more traditional, and you'd have an advantage, wouldn't you?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12007 MR. MILES: Yes, we would. That is true. That's not where we see the future of radio broadcasting. Again, maybe five years ago we ‑‑ this would have been a whole different ‑‑ well, it would have been a different kind of application. What we tend to do at Rogers in programming and in sales is we tend to take markets, and we sort of condense our ideas of bits and pieces. So the Content Factory is formalized into Medicine Hat. We think this is a concept that's got legs. We have lots of other sized markets of which this is an incubation period for this thing. We'll take it, and we'll run with it. I very much doubt that we'll ever go backwards. We'll try and move forward, and we'll try to expand it, and we'll roll it out if it works. If it does not work, there will be something else that will go in that won't be back into the traditional things. We believe we can't go back there, it's gone. That kind of broadcasting is gone. We've got to figure out what this new one is. We've got to be part of where this ‑‑ where it's going to. And so I don't know whether that answers your question or not, but that's just the vision that we have at Rogers of looking forward. The new platforms, how can we get that brand and content out there, and how can we get that listener back engaged in the radio station because if we don't, they're gone. They're gone.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12008 We ‑‑ you know, we've got some research, and pardon me for taking time, but I think it's important for the Commission to hear this. We've gone into markets now in the last four months with research, as we do continually. For the first time, we're adding the question on, do you listen to satellite radio, and if so, how often? So here are the results. Three months ago we were in Ottawa. Four percent of the people in Ottawa listen to satellite radio once a week or more often. So that's cume. Of that 50 percent, two percent are fans. In Calgary, a month and a half ago, six percent of the Calgary market listens to satellite radio, three percent or half of them are fans. In Grande Prairie, eight percent listen to satellite radio, four percent are fans, and more particularly, up to 15 percent of certain narrow demographics were listening to satellite radio. It's here, and we've got to figure out how it is that we can operate our radio stations against just one competitor, but it's the kind of research that we're now doing, and as a result of that research, the iPod listening and all this other stuff, that's why we're trying to do new programming concepts.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12009 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12010 For the record, my nephew listens to satellite, but he listens to BBC News. I don't know what 21 year olds are about anyway.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12011 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12012 Legal counsel?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12013 MR. MILES: You have brought him up well.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12014 MS BENNETT: Thanks. I just have one small point of clarification. With respect to the condition of licence that 75 percent of the news content would be local, would that be on a daily or a weekly basis?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12015 MR. MILES: Weekly.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12016 MS BENNETT: Thanks.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12017 THE CHAIRPERSON: Last night I had this tape going through my head, two hours ‑‑ two minutes, two minutes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12018 Mr. Miles, you have two minutes. Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12019 MR. MILES: Is this where I get a chance to say that it's a pleasure to be back in Regina where it all started for me? I have to bring that in somewhere.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12020 We have proposed the best rock format for this market given its size and its current competitive nature. This is a broad‑based format equal across the demos, and it's more male skewed than female.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12021 We know how to do this format in this size market; our experience is in Ontario north and Lethbridge. In Lethbridge ‑‑ and we have been in this market since 1989 in Alberta. We understand the province.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12022 We have explored and proposed possible solutions to the new competitive landscape including brand and content extension to the web. The Content Factory is designed to do this.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12023 The incumbent broadcaster, Pattison, is a good, strong broadcaster with two mainstream formats and a television station. He's got heritage and market momentum.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12024 This is going to be a tougher grind than everybody expects, and we're here for the long haul.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12025 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12026 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12027 Madam Secretary...? Oh, I'm being asked to give everybody a five‑minute break.
‑‑‑ Upon recessing at 1002 / Suspension à 1002
‑‑‑ Upon resuming at 1011 / Reprise à 1011
LISTNUM 95 \l 12028 THE CHAIRPERSON: Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12029 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12030 We will now proceed with the last application for the Medicine Hat market, which is item 9 on the agenda. It's an application by Mr. Pat Lough, on behalf of a corporation to be incorporated, for a licence to operate an English‑language FM commercial radio programming undertaking in Medicine Hat. The new station would operate on frequency 102.1 megahertz (channel 271C) with an effective radiated power of 100,000 watts (non‑directional antenna/antenna height of 214.5 metres). Appearing for the applicant is Mr. Pat Lough who will introduce his colleagues, and you will then have 20 minutes for your presentation. Mr. Lough?
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12031 MR. LOUGH: Good morning, Madam Chair, Commissioners, CRTC staff. My name is Pat Lough, president of Rock 102, and today with me is my wife, my business partner, Dulaine Lough.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12032 It is with great enthusiasm and excitement, a lot of nervousness, that we are appearing before you today to present our application for Rock 102 to serve Medicine Hat. We want to express our appreciation to the Commission for allowing us the opportunity to take part in this public process.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12033 Our application represents my lifelong dream to enter into the radio industry. We believe that Rock 102 addresses all of the requirements set out by the Commission for the licensing of a new radio station, and we believe that Rock 102 has exceeded the CAB's Canadian talent development initiatives for a small market such as Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12034 This being our first time before you, the Commission, we would like to take a moment to introduce ourselves as the applicant. I was raised in Medicine Hat during the '70s and '80s. During this time period, members of my family were actively involved in music groups throughout the city, such as the Crescent Heights High School Concert Band, Crescent Heights High School Jazz Band, Medicine Hat Police Youth Band, Medicine Hat Musical Arts Theater, Medicine Hat City Concert Band, various garage bands, and church‑related music groups.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12035 It was in Medicine Hat during the '80s that I became interested in sound and emerging technologies and, subsequently, radio broadcasting. After 20 years in Medicine Hat, I moved to Calgary to pursue studies in electronics at the Southern Alberta Institute of Technology. I graduated from SAIT with a diploma in computer engineering technology, and following that, I worked 14 years in various technical roles with Nortel Networks.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12036 For the last three‑and‑a‑half years, Dulaine and I have owned and operated a small specialty store in Calgary. Our vision and hard work has turned a struggling retail shop in the inner city into a stable and profitable business employing 12 people. Dulaine has operated the day‑to‑day operations of our store since we bought it, and I focus on the business operations. Dulaine has successfully taken the store from barely making ends meet to making a consistent year‑over‑year profit of 30 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12037 I opted to leave Nortel in 2005 to finally pursue my dreams in radio broadcasting, as radio has been a vision of mine for over 15 years. And I believe that with the present circumstances right now in Medicine Hat, I am hoping to make my dream become a reality.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12038 The licensing of Rock 102 will allow me and my young family an opportunity to return back to Medicine Hat and invest into this community that once invested into me.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12039 MRS. LOUGH: Madam Chair, Commissioners, CRTC Staff, Rock 102 is the only applicant that will be 100 percent locally owned and operated. Our application represents a new entrant into the Canadian broadcast System, and it effectively represents the small business owner in Medicine Hat. Letters received in support of our application and results from our marketing survey indicated that residents would much prefer their new radio station to be local and to have ownership in the community.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12040 Today, 100 percent of Medicine Hat's mainstream media is owned by the Vancouver‑based Pattison Broadcasting. Being locally owned and being part of the community, we will have much greater visibility in the community that we are licensed to serve. Greater visibility and involvement will allow us to be better equipped to respond to the needs of Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12041 When we were doing our research, we were shocked to find out how much foreign ownership there is in the Alberta radio market. In 2004, companies based outside of Alberta owned 80 percent of our province's radio stations. We believe that this imbalance has been created largely by recent transactions where very profitable out‑of‑province broadcasters have consumed smaller independent stations for market dominance.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12042 Alberta's radio stations are highly consolidated with 64 commercial stations, as reported in 2004, controlled by 15 ownership groups. Of the 15 ownership groups, only six hold a single broadcasting licence, which means that the other nine owners hold on average 6.4 radio licences each.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12043 The licensing of Rock 102 will give some ownership of Alberta's public airwaves back to Albertans. There is no doubt that Rock 102 will offer diversity, not only in Medicine Hat, but also in a highly consolidated Alberta radio market and in the Canadian Broadcasting System.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12044 Medicine Hat, now a market of 62,000 people, experienced an incredible growth rate of 9.1 percent from 1996 to 2001 with a 25 to 64 age group growing 27 percent. It is the males within this age range that we will be focusing on as our target demographic.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12045 With the cost of living in larger centres like Calgary and Edmonton skyrocketing beyond belief, smaller communities like Medicine Hat, have the most to gain. Medicine Hat is experiencing economic growth at a healthy, sustainable rate. Major retailers with significant budgets are also seeing the economic advantage of being located in Medicine Hat. Major employers such as Encana, Petro Canada, Canadian Fertilizers, Home Depot, and Wal‑Mart have all realized the benefit of doing business in Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12046 The average 2004 PBIT for Alberta's FM stations is 35.2 percent. We believe that Medicine Hat is extremely healthy and that the Medicine Hat market raises the Alberta PBIT significantly upwards. The interests of all the major broadcasters in this room is a good indication that everyone believes that Medicine Hat is a profitable market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12047 Our application is about diversity. The 60‑percent classic rock format will be of particular interest to 25 to 54‑year‑old males and the 30‑percent classic hits format will likely attract more female listeners than it would if we played classic rock alone. Our proposed Alberta Rocks, Totally Canadian, and an alternative rock program will make up the balance of our genre of music programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12048 Because we believe in Canadian artists, we have committed to a full 40 percent of Canadian content.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12049 As a new entrant to radio broadcasting, during our first year we have proposed a live breakfast show running from 6 a.m. to 9 p.m., a live afternoon drive from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. and live evening program from 7 to 10 p.m., totalling nine hours a day of live‑to‑air programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12050 Totally Canadian will be a daily one‑hour program focusing entirely on Canadian artists and will be placed in the prime listening hour of 6 p.m.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12051 Canada Rocks and Alberta Rocks will have us deviate slightly from our classic rock and classic hits formats, as we will be highlighting all Canadian and Alberta talent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12052 Our potential audience clearly indicated that they wanted variety, so we feel that exposure to Canadian and Alberta talent in different genres of music will offer diversity and will be appreciated by our audiences.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12053 Diversity of ownership and a diversity of voices are very important in the Canadian Broadcast System and are vital in smaller communities. The Rock 102 application was submitted with the intention of giving new radio personalities a start in the radio industry. We have planned to make use of new technologies, such as voice tracking, to help new broadcast personalities become comfortable with broadcasting. Such technologies will help new broadcasters perfect their image before going live on the air. With time and experience, new personalities will move to a live role. Voice tracking will also allow us the greatest diversity with our on‑air personnel, as we will be able to attract personalities who may want to be on air, but due to circumstances, may not be able to.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12054 We also want to emphasize that it is important to us, as the owners, that Rock 102 will not be a station that is purposely offensive.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12055 As stated in our deficiency letter dated June 30th, 2006, we will commit to 15 percent spoken‑word programming, totalling 19 hours per week. Our spoken word component will include the normal DJ commentaries and reflection, along with Rock 102 presents a music calendar highlighting upcoming concerts in the area, a community calendar highlighting local community and non‑profit events. In the winter, a ski report, crime stoppers reports, the stock market and business reports, agriculture reports, public service announcements, and various charity initiatives.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12056 We have committed to a total of five hours and 15 minutes of news per week as a minimum of news. The breakdown is as follows: For 55 minutes of news a day, Monday to Friday, 20 minutes of news Saturday, and 20 minutes of news Sunday. Now, I do believe in what you've got, it says 40, and that was a mistake, and we ask you to change that and apologize for the inconvenience. It will be 20 minutes of news on Saturdays and Sundays.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12057 The commitments we have made are minimums and will be increased as the need arises.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12058 MR. LOUGH: Our CTD initiatives are substantial for a new entrant into the broadcasting system. We have proposed direct expenditures of 37,800 ‑‑ sorry. Yeah, we have proposed direct expenditures of 37,800 and indirect expenditures of 319,550 over the seven‑year licence. Although our CTD initiatives do not have the same dollar value as other applicants, who hold multiple licences, we are confident that our initiatives not only exceed the requirements identified by the CAB, but they are also focused on the community that we'll be serving.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12059 We believe that there are many ways that a station can support Canadian artists, most notably through airplay, SOCAN fees, and CTD commitments.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12060 Based on the CAB suggestion for CTD in a small market like Medicine Hat, we pledged a commitment of $400 to FACTOR. In addition to the CAB suggestion, we opted to invest an additional $5,000 minimum into the direct and indirect ‑‑ into the direct and an additional 45,650 per year in the indirect CTD initiatives.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12061 Our pledge to invest 1,500 for an Artists in Residency Program is a grassroots initiative. The Artists in Residency Program would bring well‑known and accomplished musicians, conductors, or composers to Medicine Hat to perform workshops with local schools. Under the direction of Mr. Bill Wahl, the Artists in Residency Program will bring artists, conductors or composers who have an interest in working with students.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12062 The local band teachers will identify students that may benefit from direct interaction with the artist, conductor, or composer. Students will be given the sheet music in advance so that they can effectively prepare for the workshop. When the artist, conductor, or composer puts on their workshop, they will have the opportunity to share what inspired them when they wrote their composition. They can share some of the life challenges as a musician, and they can share how they overcame some of the life challenges and share industry contacts and trades.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12063 The Artists in Residency Program doesn't have to be the same every year. One year it could have a senior high band ‑‑ senior high school band focus, the next year it could have an orchestra focus, and the next year, it could even have an elementary school focus.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12064 Terri Clark, a well known country musician, was a personality artist that Mr. Wahl was able to bring into his high school band to discuss some of her challenges before making it big in country music. Another Albertan who has had a very long and successful music career and who is willing to share his life experiences is Tommy Banks. In the case of a conductor or a composer coming to perform at a workshop, the Artists in Residency Program will give them an opportunity to also put on a public performance involving the students from their workshop. If marketed, the Artists in Residency Program could attract corporate sponsors and funding from the Alberta Foundation for the Arts.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12065 Whatever the shape the Artists in Residency Program ultimately takes on, we will ensure that the contribution is in compliance with Appendix 1 of CRTC 1990‑111. If we don't receive positive feedback in regards to the Artists in Residency Program, we're willing to redirect the funds to ARIA to be spent in other areas ‑‑ to being spent in other initiatives in the Medicine Hat area.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12066 Originally intended for the Classic Rock Music Event, we pledged $2,000 towards a public concert featuring a local group as a warm‑up band.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12067 When we were challenged by CIRPA to consider giving monies to the area, we found that area would keep the money in the Medicine Hat area and would gladly help us achieve this objective to promote local Alberta talent. We were responsive to CIRPA's request and submitted a letter from ARIA on our response to ‑‑ on our response to their letter of intervention.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12068 Support for a newly founded Medicine Hat Folk Music Festival, we have committed $1,500 to help develop this initiative. The Medicine Hat Folk Music Society was started in ‑‑ I better stick to my script. Monies pledged to the Medicine Hat Folk Music Society will be in compliance also, with the Appendix 1 of CRTC 1990‑111, with a leaning towards the songwriting competition, but our early discussions were involving some administration costs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12069 Approval of Rock 102 will offer diversity in the Medicine Hat market and will offer diversity to the highly consolidated profitable Alberta radio market, which has a lot of foreign ownership.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12070 In efforts to grow the broadcasting community, Rock 102 has proposed to donate equipment that we have acquired over the years to help the Medicine Hat College develop a student‑run station. We talked about the student‑run initiative in our Brief, and this initiative will not only give the college students a voice in the community, but it will give college students valuable on‑air experience to potential DJs that could benefit the local stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12071 Should the Commission approve our licence, we will be a fresh, new broadcaster in Alberta's strong and vibrant radio market. As a first‑time broadcaster, we've made very significant commitments and have exceeded the CRTC's requirement in developing Canadian talent in Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12072 Additionally, we have shown strong support for artists, both provincially and federally, through station‑oriented music programs, which have been strategically placed in prime listening periods.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12073 Rock 102 will offer a new listening voice or a new listening choice, a new advertising choice, a new and accessible ownership group, a new and local approach to CTD initiatives, a strong community involvement.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12074 We have had a significant amount of support from potential listeners and advertisers in Medicine Hat. Many of our 128 letters express support for a locally owned station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12075 We want to thank you for your time hearing our application and are glad to answer any questions you may have.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12076 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12077 Commissioner Williams?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12078 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Good morning, Mr. And Mrs. Lough, and welcome to this hearing.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12079 Clearly a very entrepreneurial couple. What type of store do you operate in Calgary?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12080 MRS. LOUGH: It's a paint‑your‑own pottery store as well as doing some glass using. So it's crafty and very ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12081 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Creative.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12082 MRS. LOUGH: ‑‑ artistic and creative, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12083 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yes. If you were successful in your application for a licence, would you sell ‑‑ sell the store and relocate to Medicine Hat, or ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12084 MRS. LOUGH: Yes, we would. I have been asked that question by people that know me and know that I love my job, but what I love about it is the creativity and the people aspect of the job, and I can get that in Medicine Hat, so I'd be glad to relocate there.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12085 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Do either of you have any previous broadcasting experience or were associated with any broadcasting entity?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12086 MR. LOUGH: Neither of us do have a broadcasting background. I believe the success of our station will be in our people. I believe there's a tremendous amount of talent in Medicine Hat. People that can't find a place on the two stations owned by Pattison, I believe if there's competition, then there will be more avenues for people to ‑‑ you know, to be on the air, to have an involvement in broadcasting.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12087 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Could you help me with a bit of ‑‑ help me gain a better understanding of your business experience in, say, other businesses or other enterprises that you've worked on, either from a start‑up perspective or even a mature business?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12088 MR. LOUGH: So during my high school years and during my college time in ‑‑ well, high school years and my year at the Medicine Hat College, I was very entrepreneurial. I learned sound reinforcement at a young age, that made me attractive to some local bands, that made me attractive to church groups. There was really nobody in Medicine Hat doing audio‑visual stuff. We could have ‑‑ I could have stayed in Medicine Hat and pursued that component of it. I was actually challenged ‑‑ or challenged, I was asked by a new audio company that came to Medicine Hat in about 1998 ‑‑ I was kind of asked by him why I never stayed, and, you know, I felt at the time that I've spent 20 years in Medicine Hat, that ‑‑ that it's time to experience the bigger city, and it's definitely time to return back. So in Medicine Hat, we did audio‑visual ‑‑ or I did sound, and when I moved to Calgary, that expanded to audio‑visual. I did a lot of tape ‑‑ tape sales, CD sales, all in the audio‑visual world. We had the opportunity in 2003 to buy the studio, which we saw as another complimentary component of a communication‑type environment.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12089 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. I'm going to go through ‑‑ your presentation is ‑‑ that has been put together, your application is very thorough and very well done and carefully thought out, so I still have a few questions, and we'll work our way through them together.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12090 I note that your proposed Rock 102 is ‑‑ or that Rock 102 is proposing a classic hits, classic rock blended format that will feature a predominance of classic hits music in the morning and early afternoon, switching to a predominance of classic rock music in the late afternoon and evening. I also note that you're proposing to offer a limited amount of new alternative rock as part of your evening programming to appeal to the 18 to 34‑year‑old male segment of the population. In your Supplementary Brief, you state that you want to introduce this type of split format in order to offer greater musical diversity to Medicine Hat listeners until such time as a new station is licensed by the Commission to serve ‑‑ serve this market. Now, we've looked at the sample music lists provided in your Supplementary Brief, but would like you to describe for us, again, the type of classic music mix that you would provide as part of your blended format proposal and who you are targeting with this morning and mid‑afternoon classic hits programming. I ask because the classic hits format seems to be evolving, somewhat, into two types of sound, a softer AC top 40 music blend skewed towards female listeners and the more traditional male‑oriented and harder sounding rock‑oriented classic hits music mix. So can you tell me a bit about what you plan to be offering in this proposed station?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12091 MR. LOUGH: All right. So we ‑‑ we propose to start the day with a classic hits format. Again, we felt that was very attractive to bring in a female audience, recognizing though that CHAT and MY 96 are catered towards the female audience. Because it was very clear that Medicine Hat wanted something different, we wanted to be relatively broad to be attractive to various audiences. So we're proposing to start the day with a classic hits format, which would definitely be attractive to females, as well as males. And we progress ‑‑ as we progress through the day, we're going to take on a harder format. Basically, at 12:00/1:00, you'll know that if classic hits aren't really your thing, you might want to go back to MY 96. We have no problem with sharing an audience. We think that there's a lot of radio jumpers in the industry. As we progress through the day, we're going to take on a harder and harder sound. We're not looking for a heavy, heavy sound. We do see that the evening presents an opportunity to focus on a little bit more alternative rock though, which may propose a little bit more of the harder sound, but that will be blended with the traditional classic rock. Saturdays, we're looking at a ‑‑ we'll do a program that will definitely focus on the '60s/'70s classic rock, the pure classic rock, more in a similar association to Q107 out of Calgary. So our classic hits, we'll probably ‑‑ to brand, it would be similar in nature to JACKfm, a very popular format across the Country, and our classic rock format will take on more of a sound like Q107. There's a Q in Toronto as well, I can't remember the name, but take on more of the classic sound.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12092 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Day parting ‑‑ in the radio industry's experience, day parting different music formats to serve different audiences sometimes works in smaller markets with limited tuning choices; however, sometimes this programming approach also serves to alienate audiences because neither group is ultimately satisfied with the split format approach. Why do you feel your female‑oriented classic music mix and your male‑oriented classic rock mix will work so well in the Medicine Hat market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12093 MR. LOUGH: We've heard a lot of people say that they're just tired of the repetition that they experience in Medicine Hat. If you're not into country, your choice is MY 96, unless you have satellite and cable FM and such, but, typically, as you're driving through your car ‑‑ and, historically, looking at the traditional radio broadcasters, that's what's been in the market. I had a blank on what your question was, sorry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12094 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: That's okay. You can come back to it late if it comes to you. In your Supplementary Brief, you said you would keep the slit format until such time as the Commission licences another commercial station to serve Medicine Hat. What would happen if the Commission would decide to licence more than one commercial station at the end of this hearing? Would you keep a split format, or would you go with one format full‑time, and, if so, what would be your preferred format?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12095 MR. LOUGH: I guess as we made our application originally, we felt Medicine Hat was definitely a strong market. We felt there was ‑‑ after I made the application, I felt that there was potential in Medicine Hat for two stations, given the number of applicants that had responded. Also, comparing to Lethbridge, a market that has four mainstream stations, now Paul Larsen ‑‑ a fifth one coming online, plus a Christian station, plus university stations, CBC, CKUA, plus three television stations. So there was a good inclination that Medicine Hat could very well receive more than one licence. We proposed our application based on the split format recognizing that if there is another applicant, we have identified our formats right there. We will gladly refocus ‑‑ draw our attention to probably the classic rock. That's where we saw the most support was for classic rock. I mean, classic ‑‑ classic hits, there was a strong support for that as well. If another format is licensed similar to ours, like in the classic hits and us being the classic rock, we have no problem focusing on the classic rock.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12096 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: In your executive summary, you indicated that the proposed station will be of great interest to the 25 to 54‑year‑old male audience, but you further state that the alternative rock you're proposing will attract younger males, 18 to 34. Can you tell me what demographic will make up your core target audience under your current proposal?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12097 MR. LOUGH: I think the core target audience consistently will be around 39. We recognize the alternative rock is ‑‑ is focused on a Saturday night program and a little bit throughout the week in the evenings. Alternative rock doesn't have to have that garage sound and just ‑‑ it doesn't have to be labelled as alternative rock, I guess. We recognize ‑‑ we recognize, like, groups like Nickelback does fall under the alternative category, but it's also getting a lot of airplay on stations like MY 96 and such. So we recognize that it does fall under category. There's also sounds that that category has traditionally ‑‑ I guess, sounds that the alternative rock has been labelled as that we probably won't go to that extreme, except, perhaps, on the Saturday nights when we recognize that that's when we will have that audience.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12098 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: And the group of people that are interested in that music are typically about 39 years old?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12099 MR. LOUGH: On a Saturday night, no, that average will probably drop down to about 24.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12100 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12101 MR. LOUGH: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12102 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Your proposed classic hits/classic rock music format will feature a broad range of musical genres and styles. Other applicants are proposing to serve a similar target audience with somewhat similar music formats, including another classic hits/classic rocks blend, rock, full‑time classic rock, and full‑time classic hits. Could you please comment and describe how your proposed format differs, if at all, from these other format proposals, and would you also explain to us why you feel your format is better than, say, an adult standard modern nostalgia or even broad‑based AC music format in that it would be the better choice to serve the current Medicine Hat market. So I guess tell us how you differ, and why are you the best choice?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12103 MR. LOUGH: I guess right from the very beginning of this application, we made it known that we were looking at a split format. We've had a few surprises yesterday where there have been some applicants that ‑‑ that the formats are, you know, different than what the original, I guess, thought was. So right from the beginning we felt that that was ‑‑ that would be appropriate, two formats to incorporate. That attracted the bulk of Medicine Hat's audience.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12104 We had a survey that definitely revealed that classic rock was the first one ‑‑ actually, you guys have a copy of the survey. That the classic rock was the preferred format, classic hits was a close second. Why our format over like a nostalgic, such as one of the applicants, I believe that the nostalgic format is a good format. It could compliment ours actually quite well in terms of offering diversity in the market, but also offering different audiences and different advertisers. So I believe that the format such as that could compliment ours, which is complimenting the MY 96 and the CHAT format. I guess another reason why I feel like I could endorse that particular application is because I don't see it as competition to us at all. The other format is classic rock/classic hits. The reality is very ‑‑ a number of applicants have proposed very similar formats, so can I say that ours is better than theirs per se? Well, we're offering classic hits, they're offering classic hits. We're offering classic rock, they're offering classic rock. So if you're looking at that music format, I think all the applicants here are equivalent on that level.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12105 I guess the other very key factor is we're proposing a local station and by local people in the community. Other applicants are proposing to have an ownership in a different market, perhaps Toronto. I mean, Pattison right now, based out of Vancouver or Kamloops, I'm not sure, is ‑‑ owns the market. They ‑‑ as an ownership group, they're not in the market that often. Dwayne Dietrich, manager of CHAT and MY 96 does an excellent job. I have no question about that, but I think there's a lot to be said when the ownership is in the market. I think Bill ‑‑ Bill Yule, who owned the CHAT for years and owned MY 96 before he sold out to Pattison, was very active in the community. I think the local ownership is what Medicine Hat wants, and I think that there is a big benefit.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12106 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Tell me a bit about the benefit of the local ownership in the community. That's ‑‑ I'm interested in how you ‑‑ what you think about that. What are the benefits?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12107 MR. LOUGH: I think the simple fact that when you're part of the community and when you've lived in the community, you kind of know. You kind of know who you can go to to find stories and who you can rely on in terms of support for, you know, say a concert or something like that. I guess you know the connections. You know where you can go that if you need something ‑‑ and no doubt that radio is an avenue ‑‑ is a venue where people go to when they need something. Charitable groups will go to a radio station and say, hey, we're starving for this. Can you help us get the support we need? And I think if you have to call up Toronto or call up Vancouver to get that permission, then I think that community involvement is often gone, it's lost.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12108 Sometimes there's timing issues. If I was to mention about the fires in Kelowna in 2003 ‑‑ as I've talked to people out there, I've heard complaints that, you know, the major broadcasters in that market that don't live there took a while, and I guess ‑‑ took a while to respond effectively. I think that when there's a local ownership, the issues are more personal. You're willing to get involved. You might not have that business focus, that focus on the bottom line every time. I think you just see issues, and you want your community to be better so ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12109 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Do you have anything you'd like to add, Mrs. Lough?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12110 MRS. LOUGH: I would just like to say that I think being part of the community, with Pat having grown up there, they're not just ‑‑ Canada Day isn't just an event, it's part of his history, it's part of our history as a family. There are events and parts of Medicine Hat that we know because we've got history there, and I think that's a benefit because we know the history, we know the people. It's kind of a joke between us that we can't go anywhere in the world, practically ‑‑ I mean, Hawaii and Las Vegas and wherever. I think everywhere we've gone, we run into people from Medicine Hat that Pat knows. And I think that will benefit our ownership because, for example, if there was something going on in a school, it's not just a news item, it's something that's happening with our children, and that will matter to us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12111 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12112 I note you are proposing to offer a minimum of 56 hours of local programming per week. You state that this would give you the flexibility to pick up a national syndicated program such as a classic rock magazine. You also state in your 30th of June 2006 deficiency response that most, if not all, of our programming will be produced locally. Can you please reconcile these two statements?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12113 MR. LOUGH: Right. There are a variety of music magazines that are available to independent broadcasters, some of them are ‑‑ some of them are originated by, say, Standard Radio and such. We like the idea of being able to offer people in Medicine Hat something that they can hear in other markets, but we've also recognized that our application is local. We do intend to do the classic music program identified on Saturday as a local program. We just wanted to have the option to explore, I guess, other radio ‑‑ nationally available radio programs, and I guess we'd look at more of like a Sunday night ‑‑ a late Sunday night type program, possibly when the listenership is low, and that could be ‑‑ a nationally available program could attract listenership ‑‑ could raise our listenership in a typical low period.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12114 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: In your 30th of June deficiency response, you specify that your programming will be unique and reflective of Medicine Hat, which will result in the community being better served. Outside of your commitment to provide five hours and 25 minutes of news and related surveillance material each week, can you elaborate on the other types of local reflection programming that you will offer within your overall commitment to devote a minimum of 19 hours or 15 percent of the broadcast week to spoken word material?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12115 MR. LOUGH: In what I read today, we have committed to the five hours ‑‑ and in here I notice that we put five hours and 25 minutes. I guess that was a miscalculation. It was five and a ‑‑ five hours ‑‑ five and a quarter hours, which is ‑‑ right? Which ‑‑ no. Yeah, five hours and 15 minutes. So I apologize for that. That was in the response. I'll gladly take five hours and 25 minutes. I ‑‑ there's not a lot of difference there, I don't think.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12116 In what we read today, we proposed, like a ski report, snow conditions for out at Cypress Hills, for out near the Lethbridge ski hills. People tend to travel to the Pincher Creek area for skiing, so we've proposed a ‑‑ you know, a ski report, a community calendar where we'd be highlighting community events. That would be an avenue, a venue, where people can send in a fax, send in an e‑mail to our department and be able to get that on the air in a relatively expedient process. We've also proposed the music calendar where we will highlight visiting bands to Medicine Hat, highlighting them to Calgary, highlighting them to a reasonable distance within Medicine Hat. We highlighted crime stoppers. Crime stoppers is a fabulous initiative that ‑‑ people feel that ‑‑ I think people ‑‑ people have a genuine willingness and ability to get involved if they can. We're proposing to do an association with crime stoppers. That's not new. That's something that has existed in Medicine Hat. We have no problem having that as a duplicate of all the other stations. Like, we just feel that there's value ‑‑ there's value in something like crime stoppers. The stock market report, business report. Something like CIBC Wood Gundy would be who we would like to involve with that or TD Waterhouse. The agricultural report, public service announcements from various groups and various charity initiatives.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12117 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Would these programs, for the most part, be locally produced or acquired or syndicated or a combination?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12118 MR. LOUGH: You know, pretty much everything would be locally produced. I'm not sure if CIBC Wood Gundy has a radio personality in Medicine Hat. I know that there's a guy in Calgary that does it on the Calgary radio stations. We would hope ‑‑ it would be our desire to have someone local in Medicine Hat so that people can ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12119 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Try to find a local broker, for example, and ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12120 MR. LOUGH: Exactly. One of our support letters was from a financial company, I'm drawing a blank on the name of them. Do you know what, they've supported us. They would be one that we'd probably look at going to first, and say, you know, this is what we want to do. Is this something that your company would be interested in doing? Something like the public service announcements, you know, Canadian Blood Bank, well, that's produced elsewhere. That would be something that we would just acquire and make available. Crime stoppers, that would be a local initiative.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12121 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: You state that your station will provide a local service that would cater to what you described as the underserved male demographic group in Medicine Hat. However, as indicated in your local programming schedule, your Supplementary Brief page 14, your programming will be voice tracked Monday to Friday between 9 ‑‑ 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. and from 6 p.m. to 7 p.m. during one of your feature programs called Totally Canadian, and from 10 p.m. to midnight accounting for 45 hours of weekday programming, as well, with the exception of four hours of live programming on Saturdays and on Sundays between 8 a.m. and noon. You would also offer 28 hours of voice tracked programming over the weekends. Would you elaborate on the rationale behind this program decision to rely so heavily on voice tracked programming and how you feel it may or may not impact on your ability to provide a quality service to your Medicine Hat audience?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12122 MR. LOUGH: Right. We see voice tracking as a component that will allow new broadcasters to get onto the radio. I'm not a personality. That's ‑‑ I'm not going to be a voice on the station, that's not my area of comfortness. And we recognize that there are other people that are like that, but have that genuine desire to, you know, perfect something. So we see voice tracking as an option where a new broadcaster or a college student can get on the radio, and, yeah, it might take them three tries, but then they can have something that represents them well. We also see voice tracking as an option to allow us a larger pool of talent that ‑‑ radio has a lot of part‑time positions, so we see voice tracking as an opportunity to have an individual who may work for another company but have a genuine interest in getting into radio, have them slotted at whatever, 10:00 or 9:00 until 12:00 or whatever, in a period where, yeah, they're actually at work, but ‑‑ but they want to pursue this career path, I guess, at some point. And it might be immediate, it might be a job sharing type thing that they want to do kind of indefinitely.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12123 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Could you tell us how much of the five hours and 15 or 25 minutes of news would be station produced?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12124 MR. LOUGH: My immediate reaction is it's all station‑produced because this is our only station, but we do recognize that there are the Broadcast News services where smaller markets tend to rely on the Broadcast News to get the national stories. I guess other forms of news would be CTV News Net, CNN. We can observe, we can scan, we can monitor these other news services and still do a local ‑‑ do everything totally local.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12125 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Localized, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12126 MR. LOUGH: So we are proposing 100 percent of our ‑‑ 100 percent of our news production will be local. I guess, you know, if we want to follow the commentaries of, say, our Prime Minister making a comment in Ottawa, we want to play that snip‑it, well, I guess that's not local, is it, unless I have a reporter actually in Ottawa. You know, so I guess that's an area that I have a fairly good understanding of. All of our production will be local, but, obviously, there will be sound bytes that are from other markets.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12127 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Mmhmm. Do you believe that your new staff would be sufficient to produce not only this amount of news but also newscasts of a high quality?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12128 MR. LOUGH: I think everybody in our station in the first year is going to wear multiple hats. If we are looking at a station manager doing some researching ‑‑ some research, I should say, for the news department, and then they say, hey, you know what, these are the top stories of the day. You guys now refine, and you guys, you know, make it appropriate for today and, you know, cut and add and do whatever you need to do. I think there ‑‑ in a ‑‑ in a very entrepreneurial‑type station, everybody wears multiple hats.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12129 MRS. LOUGH: If I might add, I ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12130 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Of course.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12131 MRS. LOUGH: ‑‑ I don't think that we are that naive to think that there won't be a growth curve. We know that we are new, and we know that we will learn somewhat, but it's our intention, obviously, in our own community to not embarrass ourselves and to really come out of the chute being incredibly professional and then grow from there.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12132 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: You've indicated that Rock 102 will employ the equivalent of two full‑time news reporters and that you plan to utilize a college student on the weekend to help with the newscasts. Could you tell us who will be responsible for managing the content of your news programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12133 MR. LOUGH: So the management ‑‑ the overall management would be responsible by the news director and, ultimately, by the station manager.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12134 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: I note you've provided no information on your staffing plans in the area of general programming. Could you provide us with the type of resources you will allocate to production and on‑air broadcasting?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12135 MR. LOUGH: I have it somewhere. So we've proposed five DJs, two news reporters, which will result in a total of seven on‑air personalities, four technical people, and within technical, I'm including the scheduler, technical and then two creative people, so I kind of lump that as four technical people, and then two administration people, one ‑‑ one of those being the manager.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12136 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. In your application, you indicate that $1,500 will be allocated to the development of the Medicine Hat Folk Festival. How will this funding be used by the Folk Festival to support Canadian talent? Will it be used to underwrite Canadian performers appearing at the festival, or used to underwrite administrative and/or infrastructure costs?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12137 MR. LOUGH: Our initial discussion with the folk music group was to take on ‑‑ to offer them some funding to underwrite or to help the administration side of it. We would like to give them, I guess, enough latitude that, you know what, should they have success on one particular concert and should they feel that's not really necessary, if they wanted to offer that as a scholarship as part of their songwriting competition or whatever, we'd like to give them that latitude. We will offer them the Appendix 1(a), which will very specifically say this is what's allowed and this isn't what's allowed. If they're in compliance with that, we will sign the cheque and hand that off to them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12138 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Should the Commission decide that some of these costs do not qualify as direct contributions to the development of Canadian talent, would you be prepared to redirect these costs to an eligible initiative as set out in the just mentioned Appendix 1?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12139 MR. LOUGH: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12140 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. In your response to deficiency questions, dated 30th of June, you make reference to a survey that you conducted. Did you conduct or commission a study that would support a demand in the Medicine Hat market for your proposed station, and, if so, could you provide us a copy of this study?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12141 MR. LOUGH: So in what you received today, there was a copy of the survey.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12142 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay, all right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12143 MR. LOUGH: We did the survey kind of involving two particular avenues: One being a web survey where we got the information out to people saying, you know what, if you want to have an impact on a new radio station that potentially could be licensed from Medicine Hat, please hit this website and take the survey, so that's the bulk of that survey. We also wanted to offer people that ‑‑ you know, surprisingly, some people don't have access to the Internet. We also wanted to offer people a toll free number where they could call in and kind of ‑‑ and take a similar survey. So the surveys weren't exactly the same. We've identified all the questions in the survey. The telephone survey was a scaled‑down version. I think there were eight questions in that. Through that service, we got a printout of how many people selected option 1 relating to this particular question.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12144 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. After examining the methodology used to project audience, we note that you have not taken into account varying levels of interest in the proposed musical format from various demographic groups. Instead, you've used projections of 15 plus population and multiplied these by a factor of 19.5 hours per week of radio listening to arrive at your projections. Do you think that failing to take into account varying degrees of interest in your proposed format from various demographic segments may have resulted in a possible overestimate of your projected audience?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12145 MR. LOUGH: I think Medicine Hat is tired of the repetition that they've experienced on MY 96.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12146 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: I'm sorry, I missed that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12147 MR. LOUGH: Sorry, I think Medicine Hat is very tired. From what we've seen in our letters of intervention, they're very tired of repetition of MY 96. So I think we're going to have a good sized audience, broad ‑‑ you know, broad in nature, 25 to 54, so I guess we didn't break down on the specific categories and do the calculations that way. I apologize for that. I think that's something I didn't really consider as I've gone through this process.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12148 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: We may have covered this to some extent earlier, but do you believe the Medicine Hat market could support more than one station at this time?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12149 MR. LOUGH: I believe the Medicine Hat market is very strong. I believe that the Medicine Hat market could support two stations, and I think that's in addition to the power upgrade for CJLT, should you guys approve that. CJLT just has a very defined audience. I just don't see that as an issue. There are, I think, choices that would make ‑‑ choices in applications that would help the market absorb two new stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12150 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. How did you, as a family business group, decide that you wanted to enter this particular type of business? What attracted you to this business, what got your attention, and what ultimately made you decide that it was something that you wanted to pursue?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12151 MR. LOUGH: Getting involved in audio‑visual at a young age ‑‑ sorry, getting involved with sound at a young age got me involved with various bands in the Medicine Hat area. Moving to Calgary, we were involved with choirs, choirs and orchestras and stuff. So I've always had the desire to do sound. Throughout all of this, I've done a little bit of recording stuff, and it's just been very simple and kind of on the side and nothing that I really want to put my name on. But, you know, it's stuff that I have done kind of in a live environment. Radio is the next logical step for my interests. I've always wanted to get into radio. I see there's ‑‑ I don't know where to go with that. Radio has just always been a passion of mine ‑‑ always been a dream of mine to pursue.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12152 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: And, Mrs. Lough, from your perspective?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12153 MRS. LOUGH: I have had the fortunate pleasure of loving any job that I have had. I have a been a director of a pregnant ‑‑ or assistant director of a pregnancy care centre for years, and I loved it. I have worked in a church, and I loved it, and I love my job now. Pat, unfortunately, has not had the opportunity to love his job, and as a ‑‑ as his wife and as a family, I am certainly wanting to allow him the pleasure of loving his job and being passionate about it, and it's been clear to me and clear more every day that radio is what he loves. So I'm certainly willing, and we're willing, as a family, to make it a career choice.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12154 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. Thank you both very much for helping us gain a better understanding of your application.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12155 That concludes my questioning, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12156 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12157 Vice‑Chair Arpin...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12158 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you very much, Madam Cram.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12159 Which part of the radio are you more interested in, management, sales, programming? Which functions within the radio organization has ‑‑ seems to be more palatable to your taste?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12160 MR. LOUGH: I have a great interest, I think, in the management and the sales component of it. I like people, and I see the sales component of that being strengthened by that. I also think I have a good business sense. From the business sense, I ‑‑ from the business sense, I think I can do a good job managing that. We've managed the staff of 12 people through the studio. Staff like working for us, for my wife in particular, but I think we've got a very good business sense as a family, as a couple. I also have a good technical component, so I think I can recognize ‑‑ I'm not saying I want to be the one in there doing all the technical stuff because I think there are opportunities for others to ‑‑ to learn that and to develop. I've done that. That's been a phase of my life that I've enjoyed. I have that component behind me now, and I'd like to explore ‑‑ I have done some sales, and I see the sales and the management kind of going hand in hand for me.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12161 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Another more technical question that we've asked to all of the applicants that have appeared before us over the last day and a half is we've asked them if what was the median age of their ‑‑ of their listener, and with ‑‑ and if it skews more towards male or female. I think in your ‑‑ in the project, it will be skewing more towards male, but what will be the median age?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12162 MR. LOUGH: Yeah, I believe we indicated today that probably around 38, 39 is what we would see as the median age for our classic rock.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12163 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: For classic rock. For ‑‑ and for your ‑‑ taking into consideration the actual stations in the market then, obviously, the age ‑‑ the various demographic that you have in Medicine Hat, so you think 38, 39 will be your ‑‑ what you'd kind of be catering to?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12164 MR. LOUGH: Yes. We see MY 96 catering to a young audience. CHAT ‑‑ CHAT is not just ‑‑ CHAT is for country people, so to say that, you know, you're old, you're going to listen to CHAT, but, no, that's not true. So we see our median age of 38, 39 as probably ideal. We will attract people that don't want to listen to CHAT. We will attract people that ‑‑ we'll attract older people that don't want to listen to CHAT, I guess, is what I'm saying. Just because you're older, doesn't mean that you like country.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12165 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: No, yeah. Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12166 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Lough.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12167 You now have two minutes to give us your why we should licence you in preference to the others.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12168 MR. LOUGH: All right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12169 Madam Chair, we sincerely want to thank you for giving us the opportunity to present our application today. Radio, as I hope has been clear, has been a passion of mine for a number of years. In fact, my wife reminded me just last night that on our very first date, she was asked the question by me what she thought of radio.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12170 The reality is, we will never be in a position to buy a station such as many of the other applicants ‑‑ actually, all of the other applicants in this room have done within the last couple of years. We recognize that we must get our start by finding the very best talent and pursue a start‑up station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12171 When I saw the CRTC had a call ‑‑ had opened a call for my hometown of Medicine Hat, I realized that there is no better opportunity for me to pursue a passion ‑‑ for me to pursue my passion than in my hometown. Seeing many applications similar to ours and receiving 128 letters of support with good leadership, it is clear that our station will do well. Our confidence is strengthened by the fact that ATB, Alberta Treasury Branch, has applauded our application and felt that it's one of the best business plans that they've seen.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12172 There is no doubt that Medicine Hat needs another radio station, and there's no doubt that the majority of the people want a format to be a rock‑based one. We believe that there's a tremendous amount of talent in Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12173 We ask you, the Commission, to grant us the opportunity to get into broadcasting by approving our application. We've done the very best that we can with the limited resources in making our application attractive and competitive. We pledge more than what the ‑‑ we pledge more than what is required for Canadian content, we pledge more than what is required for CTD, and we will get back to my hometown to ensure that the station is truly local and best served.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12174 We appear here today not requesting licence number 46, not requesting licence number 25, but we're requesting licence number 1.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12175 Thank you for your time and consideration.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12176 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Lough, Mrs. Lough.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12177 We'll now take a 15‑minute break, meaning we get back here at 11:25, and we will then be proceeding with phase II.
‑‑‑ Upon recessing at 1111 / Suspension à 1111
‑‑‑ Upon resuming at 1125 / Reprise à 1125
LISTNUM 95 \l 12178 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12179 THE CHAIRPERSON: Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12180 THE SECRETARY: We've now reached Phase II of the process in which applicants appear in the same order to intervene on competing applications, if they wish. For the record, Newcap Inc. has indicated that they will not appear, as well as numbered company 1182743 Alberta Limited and Vista Radio.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12181 I would now call on Lighthouse Broadcasting Limited to come forward. Mr. Raible, you have ten minutes for your presentation.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12182 MR. RAIBLE: Good morning. I just wanted to intervene in response to Newcap's application. I noticed yesterday ‑‑ oh, I'm sorry, should I continue?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12183 THE CHAIRPERSON: Are you replying to something that Newcap asserted against you?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12184 MR. RAIBLE: That they said yesterday about the market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12185 THE CHAIRPERSON: About the market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12186 MR. RAIBLE: They made a comment about the booming market in Medicine Hat, and we just wanted to respond to that being that we live and work in Medicine Hat and that the market isn't quite as booming as they would say. It isn't quite as booming as it says. It is ‑‑ can be very volatile in Medicine Hat. That was the nature of our intervention. Would that be okay?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12187 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12188 MR. RAIBLE: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12189 So, again, just in reference to a continual booming economy in Medicine Hat, agriculture and oil and gas are very volatile, as we've experienced with the BSE that occurred a couple years ago in Medicine Hat. And as far as the oil and gas, since August of this year, capital expenditures by gas companies in Medicine Hat for the remainder of 2006 have been cancelled. B&J Services, a gas company in Medicine Hat didn't move one truck for an entire week in early October. The economy is not booming currently, it is flat. Based on this information and the fact that we currently live and work in Medicine Hat, we believe the market could only reasonably maintain one new station in addition to the power increase of Lighthouse Broadcasting.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12190 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12191 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12192 THE SECRETARY: I would now call on Golden West Broadcasting Limited to come over forward for their Phase II process.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12193 MR. HILDEBRAND: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12194 I only have one comment and that relates to the CJVR application on the 35 to 40‑percent music question, so that's really the only comment I have.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12195 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12196 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Which comment?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12197 MR. HILDEBRAND: Well, that, I mean, they should basically stay with what they had applied for.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12198 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12199 THE SECRETARY: The next applicant to appear would be Radio CJVR Limited.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12200 MR. SINGER: Good morning, Madam Chair, Commissioners. I don't know if this is the place to answer this question. There was a question posed by Commissioner Arpin to me yesterday re the CBC. I do have some information on that. If it's appropriate at this time, I'd like to ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12201 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, go ahead.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12202 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Yes, it is.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12203 MR. SINGER: ‑‑ comment on that. Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12204 In response to the point raised yesterday, we had D.M. Allen(ph), our consulting engineering firm contact the CBC, and if I could just read a quick letter that was sent to us yesterday, perhaps it would shed some light to the response to that. "Please accept this letter as indication that the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation is prepared to enter into negotiations with multiple licences for the shared use of CBC's broadcasting facilities serving Medicine Hat, Alberta. Specifically, if multiple licences are successful in obtaining licensing from Industry Canada and the Canadian Radio Television and Telecommunications Commission for operation of FM broadcasting undertakings to serve Medicine Hat, CBC will be happy to discuss the feasibility of sharing our facilities at the above‑noted location on an equal footing. Subject to the successful completion of technical and financial considerations, CBC will coordinate the necessary upgrades at the Medicine Hat facility to accommodate the broadcasts of new FM undertakings from this location. Site sharing with CBC is conditional on approval of the frequency analysis, a structural analysis of the tower, an analysis of RF exposure levels in accordance with Safety Code 6, and agreement on all terms that shall be outlined in formal licence agreements to be negotiated between the licencees and CBC. Licence fees payable shall be negotiated based on final details of the site‑sharing proposals. All costs associated with the licencees presence, on‑site equipment, electrical transmission, mechanics, et cetera, will be the responsibility of the successful licencees. If you require additional information, please feel free to call. It will be our pleasure to help CJVR and/or other successful licence applicants fulfill their broadcast requirements. Sincerely, Jason Coleman, Business Manager West, CBC Radio Canada Transmission."
LISTNUM 95 \l 12205 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: That's partly in answer to the question that I asked because my question was, will the CBC allow ‑‑ because an argument has been made here throughout the hearing that if we were to licence two new applicants with ‑‑ in the same format, then the first one on air will have ‑‑ will pick its own format, the other one will have to find something else. And my question was, since you are ‑‑ most of you are all going on the CBC tower, will the CBC allow one broadcaster to be on air first, or will they say to everybody, no, you'll do it in the ‑‑ all at once, or are we going to ‑‑ because they will have to turn off their transmitter for a couple of nights, so they probably won't be ready to turn ‑‑ to turn their transmitters and all the other tenants off air for more than once. So that's why I asked the question, will the CBC allow any of the applicants, if we ‑‑ or the new licencees, if there are more than one, to first launch and much before ‑‑ ahead of the second one. So that answer doesn't allude to that, but my expectation, I will ‑‑ and I'm talking of ‑‑ like, for myself is that since they will have to put down their transmitters a few days over a couple of weeks and that more than likely they will say to everybody, we're going ‑‑ make a single plan, and we'll get installed at the same time. So the pick in the ‑‑ who is going to pick the format first will ‑‑ has to be something that you will have to deal with before going on air.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12206 MR. SINGER: That is correct, and I guess, Mr. Commissioner, that is our point of view, that we will have to deal with whatever situation, and we will be prepared to do that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12207 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Okay, fine, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12208 MR. SINGER: That's all I have, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12209 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Singer.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12210 Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12211 THE SECRETARY: I would now call on Harvard Broadcasting Limited to come forward.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12212 MR. COWIE: Thank you, Madam Chair, this is unchartered territory for us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12213 Harvard, historically, does not participate in this phase of the hearings, but in this case, we feel we must, and it ‑‑ we wish to refer to CJVR's attempt to change the Canadian content promise in their application, and just to solidify the fact that that's fundamentally important and should not be changed during a hearing process.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12214 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12215 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Cowie.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12216 Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12217 THE SECRETARY: And I would now call on Rogers Broadcasting Limited to come forward.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12218 MR. MILES: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12219 We, too, do not normally appear during this process, but in the presentation yesterday, we did hear one of the applicants to appear to increase their commitments from 35 to 40 percent at the hearing stage of the review process. This proposed Canadian content level is one of the key criteria of the application process. It may well have been an honest mistake, but I think we have to insist that the commitment stays at 35 percent on the basis that it was submitted in the broad‑based business plans and programming formats.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12220 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Miles.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12221 Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12222 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12223 I'd just like to indicate for the record that Pat Lough, on behalf of a corporation to be incorporated, will not be appearing in this phase, so this will complete Phase II of the process, and we are now ready to proceed to Phase III, which is the ‑‑ where parties appear in the order set out in the agenda to present their intervention.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12224 I would now call on the first appearing intervenor for CIRPA, Mr. Alexander Mair. I'm sorry for the pronunciation. When you're ready, you have ten minutes for your presentation. If you could please introduce yourself for the record.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12225 Thank you.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12226 MR. MAIR: Good morning, I'm Alexander Mair. I'm appearing on behalf of CIRPA. Excuse me if I cough during the presentation, but I'm just getting over a case of bronchitis, and the dry, hot air in the hotel has aggravated it quite a bit yesterday and this morning.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12227 Just background on myself, I'm representing more than 160 members of CIRPA from coast to coast. As well as being a director of CIRPA, I've also been a director of FACTOR, Radio Starmaker Fund, the Audio‑Video Licensing Agency, SOCAN, the Canadian Music Publishers Association, and the National Aboriginal Recording Industry Association. Earlier in my career, I was vice‑president of what is now called Universal Music Canada. I managed Gordon Lightfoot, and founded ATIC Records, which I sold in 1999. ATIC received 116 gold, platinum, and multi‑platinum albums from the U.S., the U.K., Holland, Japan, and Canada. I'm currently the publisher of Applaud, a controlled circulation trade paper celebrating the success of Canadian artists in the international forum.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12228 This is CIRPA's only appearance at these hearings, so our comments cover all the applications.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12229 We were surprised initially that with the Review of Radio held that there would be licences issued before the results of that review, so we are assuming that whatever the results of the review are, any licences issued today or out of today's hearings would be bound by the same new rules and regulations that would arise out of the Review of Radio held earlier this year.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12230 At the 1998 Review of Radio, the Commission, in its wisdom, raised the Cancon levels from 30 to 35 percent, the first increase in 28 years. The Commission also stated that they expected stations to voluntarily increase to 40 percent over the next five years. Almost every licence issued after 1998 was at the 40 percent level. We are not aware of any of these new stations having any problems with this level of Cancon.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12231 Broadcasters also promised increased diversity, which, sadly, has not happened. As CRIA's submission to the review indicated the top ten most played Canadian artists receive almost 50 percent of the Cancon airplay with Brian Adams being the most‑played artist in Canada. Brian Adams, Nickelback and the Tragically Hip collectively receive approximately a third of all Cancon airplay. The average Cancon record played in this country is about ten years old. What kind of signal does that send to younger Canadian artists who expect to be heard on the Canadian air waves, they have to wait ten years before they're going to be considered?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12232 At the recent Review of Radio, we proposed 45 percent Cancon level and 50 percent of that reserved airplay be allocated to independent labels. A review of the sound scan analysis of the top 200 CDs ‑‑ top 200 selling CDs in Canada last week showed 57 were by Canadian artists. Canadian artists held the number 1, number 2, number 3, number 9, and number 10 positions on the charts with two of them, Gregory Charles at number 1, and Sarah McLachlan being on independent labels.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12233 Of the 57 titles on the top 200 charts, 43 were on independent labels, more than two‑thirds of the best‑selling Canadian CDs of the week. Considering the influence of American media, music is our most successful cultural industry. In an analysis of sound scanned sales charts, when Canadian artists and indie labels are added to the independent distribution figures, Canadian artists and indie labels do almost 48 percent of the total CD business in Canada.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12234 We do acknowledge that some of the independently distributed product is not Cancon, but we're still major ‑‑ we're ‑‑ the independent sector with Canadian artists is bigger than any of the four multi‑nationals; however, many of the independent label artists suffer from lack of strong airplay, which hinders their success. The more successful a CD is in Canada, the easier it is to break even or profit on touring and to access international markets. Over 24,000 new Cancon tracks are issued each year, but airplay is too often reserved for the big internationally successful Canadian artists, often signed directly to major international labels. With Cancon levels being considered by most broadcasters as a ceiling, not a floor, we believe it is time for the Commission to recognize these realities and support our proposals through conditions of licence, not promises of performance.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12235 I was pleased yesterday when Elmer Hildebrand acknowledged that their station was at 45 percent voluntarily.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12236 I'd like to talk about Radio Starmaker and FACTOR. Throughout the last number of applications at this hearing and others, broadcasters have chosen to allocate most of their funding to Radio Starmaker. I remind the Commission that Starmaker came out of the 1998 hearings and was created to deal with the six‑percent surcharge on the sale of successful broadcast stations. It was not envisioned, at that time, to be any sort of larger animal than that. It was not expected to compete with FACTOR for funding from broadcasters or from government. Why most of the broadcasters are putting their money towards Starmaker is a question that has not been answered. We can only assume that part of it is their desire to put as much of it into Starmaker, as they control Starmaker, and much of the funding from Starmaker flows back into radio and television time buys, and, therefore, it also allows the radio stations to hang their names on ‑‑ tied in with the bigger Canadian stars who get Starmaker support. One of the broadcasters yesterday mentioned Nickelback is ‑‑ he was proud that they were supported by Starmaker; however, the recording that Starmaker supported was funded by FACTOR initially. This is a major, major concern to the independent sector.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12237 FACTOR turns down approximately 75 percent of all applicants due to lack of sufficient funds. Radio Starmaker has taken five years to get to the point that there is a sufficient demand for the funds available at Radio Starmaker. It has only been the last two Starmaker meetings that demand this exceeded supply of money, and that included Starmaker setting up all sorts of new programs in order to utilize the funds.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12238 Starving FACTOR will lead to a decline in the quality and quantity of Cancon releases and impede the growth of the Canadian Music Industry. Something that's important when ‑‑ during the hearings, we've talked about ARIA and SRIA, the provincial music industry association is getting support from broadcasters. Their main support comes from FACTOR. They need a healthy FACTOR in order for them to do their jobs regionally.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12239 CIRPA supports increased exposure of Canadian artists, particularly during prime time. We do not support the ghettoization as caused by beaver bins(ph) or other such programming during periods of low listenership. Cancon must be spread equally throughout the broadcast day and evening.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12240 CIRPA also believes running contests locally, in order to choose one act who may get airplay on a particular station is more of a station promotion that a CTD commitment. Obviously, only artists who perform music in the genre of the station running the contest have a chance of winning, so the contest is not open to all local artists, only those performing music in the appropriate genre. CTD funds are better spent to a provincial organization or a national organization such as FACTOR or CIRPA.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12241 The question of emerging artists is dear to our heart, and we believe the indie label carve out would lead to more emerging artists getting exposure.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12242 Although a gold record in Canada is a sign of marketplace acceptance, in reality, there is little profit at that level. In order to avoid discrimination against artists who have reached this level of success, we would define emerging artists as those who have earned a platinum record in Canada and a gold record or better in at least one major foreign market, such as U.K., U.S., Germany, or Japan. This definition would allow artists with a modicum of success to continue to access funding programs and airplay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12243 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12244 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Mair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12245 I'm not sure I understood your first point. You're assuming that the people whom we licence here at this hearing would automatically be under ‑‑ licensed under and conditioned subject to an as yet unpublished decision?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12246 MR. MAIR: Mmhmm. Is that not correct?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12247 THE CHAIRPERSON: How can that be possible when ‑‑ I mean, they're applying under the law. The policy is as it is today. And I'll give you an example. Let me give you an example. If we changed in the new decision our policy on CTD to say all of the money should go to radio stations in Nunavut, the Northwest Territories, and the Yukon, we would then unilaterally, without their knowledge, simply impose new CTDs on anybody we licensed under this?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12248 MR. MAIR: It's not so much CTD, but the most important is the Cancon levels. If, in your wisdom, when the decision of the Review of Radio comes out and you agreed with SOCAN at 50 percent or CIRPA at 45 percent and said effective January 1st, 2008, the Cancon level will be 45 percent, that would apply to all of the licensed broadcasters ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12249 THE CHAIRPERSON: I see.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12250 MR. MAIR: And I assume it would apply to the ones who are being licensed today, and I'd just like that confirmed or denied.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12251 THE CHAIRPERSON: Well, I can't give you a position of law, so maybe you can talk to your lawyers. You said since the radio policy almost all radio stations have been licensed at 40 percent. Now, I've been around since then, and I've got to say, my memory of that is not ‑‑ not in accordance with yours. Do you have any statistical basis for that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12252 MR. MAIR: The monitoring that has been done by CIRPA of the mainstream licensing has been at 40 percent. Obviously, ethnic broadcasting, Christian broadcasting, some other niche programming is at a lower level.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12253 THE CHAIRPERSON: So what percentage of the mainstreams have been licensed at 40 percent?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12254 MR. MAIR: From our understanding, all of them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12255 THE CHAIRPERSON: A hundred percent?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12256 MR. MAIR: Yes. Commissioner Arpin is disagreeing.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12257 THE CHAIRPERSON: I have to say, I mean, it would seem ‑‑yeah, the majority, but not all. I mean, I have to say in some ‑‑ I would think in some formats it would be virtually impossible, anyway.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12258 I hear what you are saying about Starmaker versus FACTOR, but with both of them, we, the Commission, have no control over where the money goes and of the governance, and really that's, I guess, not our issue.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12259 I did want to refer to the written position that CIRPA had filed, and do you have that at paragraph 5?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12260 MR. MAIR: Unfortunately, Air Canada lost my other bag, and I'm still waiting for it to arrive before I leave today.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12261 THE CHAIRPERSON: Join the club. Join the club. It says, "We are disturbed by the lack of commitment to funding for FACTOR as a total of the applicants overall Canadian talent development commitments. FACTOR is a proven success story whose funding greatly assists in the development of new artists and the marketing of existing ones, both for CIRPA's members and the industry as a whole." Would you be surprised that perhaps in Alberta and Saskatchewan there might be others who might be likewise disturbed as to the distribution of FACTOR money?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12262 MR. MAIR: It is quite possible.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12263 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah, and I'll tell you what the 2006 report showed. Out of the $12,560,000 allocated in the FACTOR report allocated by province ‑‑ they didn't allocate another 1.5 million because it was for other reasons, so they didn't allocate it by province. So out of the 12,560,000, Alberta, with 10 percent of the population, received 1.34 percent of the monies or $168,500. Saskatchewan, with 3.1 percent of the population, received .24 percent. In other words, $30,700. Ontario, with 38.9 percent of the population, received 58.9 percent of the FACTOR money or $7,403,000. Would you be surprised if in 2001 and 2 Alberta, with 9.9 percent of the population, received 2.8 percent of the funding. Saskatchewan, with 3.3 percent of the population, received 1.3 percent. There seems to be a very consistent pattern with FACTOR. Would you not agree that people applying in Alberta and Saskatchewan might be aware of that fact and might, in fact, want to be ensuring that they can benefit people in the areas from which they would be receiving revenue?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12264 MR. MAIR: In our submission, we supported funds being allocated to the provincial associations as being acceptable CTD commitments.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12265 THE CHAIRPERSON: And would that then reduce your support ‑‑ or FACTOR's support for ARIA and SRIA?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12266 MR. MAIR: No, not at all, but I ‑‑ on that, I ‑‑ I'm not ‑‑ obviously, I don't prepare FACTOR's reporting system, and FACTOR is not allowed to come to this. Because of the makeup of their Board, they cannot speak out publicly. A lot of artists signed to Toronto‑based record companies are from other parts of the country.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12267 THE CHAIRPERSON: Well, I don't know if ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12268 MR. MAIR: And that may ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12269 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ if you read the record ‑‑ if you read the record, the report, the allocation is based on applications from each province. That's how it goes, and I understand that completely. The real issue is whether or not there is sufficient effort being put to training people ‑‑ or monies to training people outside of Toronto as to how to make applications and what ‑‑ what is available.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12270 If you'll notice, the FACTOR report, the only place they had seminars was in Toronto.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12271 Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12272 THE SECRETARY: Madam Chair, we are now ready to proceed to the next appearing intervenor, and I would like to indicate, for the record, that Factory Optical Holdings will not be appearing as they were listed on the agenda.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12273 I would now call the next two appearing intervenors that are in support of Harvard Broadcasting, the American ‑‑ I'm sorry, Aboriginal Media Education Fund and Carpet One, Medicine Hat. If you would come forward to the presentation table.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12274 MS WATSON: Good morning, everyone, good morning Vice‑Chair, Commissioners, and Commission Staff. I'm Murielle Watson, and I'm the Executive Director of the Aboriginal Media Educational Fund known as AMEF. I was looking for an easy way to pronounce all this. I'm very pleased to appear before you to discuss this important initiative and how the support of broadcasters, like Harvard Broadcasting Inc., are critical to the success of this endeavour.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12275 First, let me begin by discussing the issues that underline the need for this program. The Aboriginal Broadcast Industry is relatively new and could possibly be described as being in its infancy. While the presence of Aboriginal peoples in front and behind the cameras and microphones has been a sporadic part of the Canadian Broadcast Industry since its creation, it is only within the past decade that we have begun to design and operate our own broadcasting services. In this regard, we are fairly new players in this industry and finally starting to establish an accepted and recognized presence in the field.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12276 Collectively, whether it is in the area of radio or television broadcasting, we are still very much in the process of learning the many aspects of the broadcast business. As such, we are developing new skill‑set, new practices, and new ways of doing business.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12277 Despite being in its second licence term, one of the biggest challenges that still remains for APTN is the sourcing of qualified and skilled staff for all positions. In discussion with other broadcasters, both within and outside the Aboriginal community, we have confirmed that this is a systemic issue, rather than one specific to Winnipeg where we are located or even one that is isolated to the medium of television. It is this reality, the fact that young Aboriginal persons are not even considering careers in broadcasting, that brought us to the conclusion that we must do something about it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12278 Closer examination revealed that Aboriginal persons, for the most part, are not aware of the career opportunities. For many of our youth, this industry is not accessible to them, or, if it is, they think it's beyond their reach, both institutionally and financially. The AMEF seeks to remedy all three of these impediments.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12279 The Aboriginal Media Educational Fund is a not‑for‑profit charitable organization, an initiative of the Aboriginal People's Television Network, but AMEF is an independent organization with a mandate to encourage, promote, and make possible the development of an Aboriginal pool of film, television, broadcast, and media professionals, and create opportunities for original programming and professional development, which will be recognized nationally and internationally.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12280 AMEF will develop a talent pool that can produce, distribute, market, and broadcast programming that will be relevant to today's Aboriginal culture, both nationally and internationally, and highlight the rich First Nations, Inuit, and Metis history. It will assist the target groups in finding training and professional development opportunities in all areas of the media industry from technical to directing, from on air, to management. This will be done through professional development, scholarships, tailored programs, and mentorships and will target the following groups: The first one will be encouraging the careers in all aspects of production and broadcasting for Aboriginal youth through various outreach opportunities, job fairs, presentations, and a very visible presence in schools and such venues where our youth can be reached and see the opportunities offered to them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12281 The second will be promoting and facilitating hands‑on experience for careers in production and broadcasting for recent Aboriginal graduates of media programs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12282 And the third being developing new skills for Aboriginal production professionals wanting to take the next step by entering into the international market. AMEF will also facilitate partnerships with international Indigenous production and broadcasting entities with the goal of forming alliances and partnerships, which will provide exporting opportunities and exchanges.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12283 I must, again, reiterate that AMEF will operate separately from APTN. While APTN has been instrumental in breathing life into the initiative, its role will be, largely, to provide support through a position on the Board and to help promote the fund to the communities they serve. It is the goal of the AMEF to develop talented Aboriginal media people who can work anywhere in Canada or abroad and in positions that span the entire breadth of the broadcasting industry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12284 AMEF will be run by a Board that at the moment has six members, five of which have been confirmed. In addition to this, we have assembled an advisory committee that spans the broadcast and film production industries. This group of talented and accomplished individuals will provide guidance on a range of issues including advice on raising funds, attracting partnerships with established professionals, and direction on career opportunities within media. The Board members will be instrumental in establishing a mentoring position within the companies they represent and expending the opportunities to companies beyond their own.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12285 Some of the advisory committee members will be well‑known to the Commission, and in combination, represent a broad section of the media in Canada. For example, Sandra MacDonald who was the former head of the CTF and the National Film Board, the Honourable Douglas Frith, who was a former Minister of Indian and Northern Affairs and now runs CMPDA, Mark Starowicz of the CBC and Tom Perlmutter of the National Film Board. And, in total, we anticipate having ten members within this advisory committee.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12286 AMEF represents the truest form of talent development amongst a group of people that are underrepresented in the broadcast system. We will neither attempt to prescribe areas of development, nor will we limit the training we will offer.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12287 If in a single year, all applicants for funding are interested in getting into radio, then we will seek to find opportunities for them. In this way, the fund cannot be seen to be supporting one medium or one avenue of development over another.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12288 Our goal is to raise 10 million to provide a secure funding base that will ensure the program's longevity if guaranteed.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12289 Awareness will not be achieved overnight, and so the fund must be well‑financed and supported to enable it to operate over the critical period of the first five years.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12290 As well, AMEF is committed to provide an annual report card about the Commission and the various broadcasting entities that will support it. This report card will clearly demonstrate the level of participation, types of training or professional development opportunities, as well as any other endeavour that will have been provided through the fund.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12291 AMEF intends to be very transparent in this regard with a view of ensuring that the entities that will fund this initiative will be able to see concrete results and not worry that they have sunk funds into a bottomless pit from which they see no results.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12292 It is through the support of broadcasters like Harvard Broadcasting that our goal to expend the opportunities and contributions of Aboriginal people within the broadcast system will be realized. Support for our community is not new to Harvard. Harvard was the first radio broadcaster to create a long ‑‑ yearlong mentoring program for Aboriginal news people, the first to incorporate an Aboriginal feature into a mainstream radio service, and the first to expend this program throughout its existing and proposed stations. Not only did Harvard commit to this mentoring program in Calgary, but also in Fort McMurray and Saskatoon. The funding they now offer AMEF is a natural extension of their ongoing community support and their commitment to help elevate the role for Aboriginal persons in the Canadian Broadcast System. Harvard Broadcasting's commitment in Medicine Hat marks the first contribution from a radio broadcaster, and we hope that we ‑‑ with the support of the CRTC, it will be one of the first of many.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12293 For people whose history is communicated orally and for communities that are enriched by the sharing of stories, the broadcasting industry would seem a natural vocation. It is this intuitive sense of appropriateness that makes the AMEF such a natural talented development opportunity. It is the need within the broadcasting system for trained personnel and the shortage of training and/or funding that make AMEF particularly relevant.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12294 The Commission has recognized the role of Aboriginal persons within the broadcasting system and given us the means to ‑‑ by which we can share our cultures and enrich our people, as well as allow Canadians to share into a unique world view and perspective.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12295 Now, we ask that the Commission recognize that hand in hand with having the way to communicate comes the need to develop the personnel that will bring our stories to life and make the most of the opportunities you have provided.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12296 Furthermore, AMEF will serve to develop a variety of skilled individuals and a multitude of disciplines related to the broadcast sector. As such, it's not meant to take anything away from other issue‑specific initiatives, but to become a broad‑based effort to boast their opportunities in many areas.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12297 AMEF is a very constructive beginning to developing this talent, and we ask that the Commission confirm its suitability as a recipient of Canadian Talent Development Funds, and further, that they recognize Harvard Broadcasting's exemplary initiatives in serving the communities in which they operate by awarding them a licence in Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12298 Thank you for your time and attention, and any questions, I'm here.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12299 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Ms Watson.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12300 You're Mr. Harvey?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12301 MR. HARVEY: Yes, I am.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12302 THE CHAIRPERSON: If you could proceed, and then we'll deal with questions at the end.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12303 MR. HARVEY: Thank you, Madam Chairman.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12304 Ladies and gentlemen, I would first of all like to apologize for not having a copy of my presentation. This isn't something that I do every day, but it is something that I feel strongly about today. So as I proceed, I would like to say thank you for accepting my request to appear before your hearing relative to Harvard's application for a licence to operate a new mainstream rock FM station in Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12305 I own a diverse small company with my brother in Assiniboia, Saskatchewan. The company is a third‑generation family business, rich in history. For the past 86 years, our family has been in the hardware, furniture, and floor covering business. We presently own and operate a Home Hardware store, a Carpet One store, and a furniture store, and we are 50‑percent shareholders in Ashdown's Furniture and Interiors in Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan, the previous businesses in Assiniboia, and since ‑‑ in 2001, we opened a large Carpet One flooring store in Medicine Hat, Alberta. This provides you with a little background on whom and why I am making a presentation today.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12306 In Medicine Hat, we feel there is a need for a new radio station. This is a fast‑paced, young, and progressive city, and there are only two commercial radio stations presently both owned by the Pattison Group.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12307 The format Harvard is proposing is lacking on the airwaves presently and would appeal to a younger male audience, an audience that is certainly present in Medicine Hat today.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12308 Licensing Harvard in Medicine Hat will bring a greater spirit of competition and free enterprise to the city. The local business environment would benefit from another advertising option and format. Listeners will have more choices. But the main reason I am here today supporting Harvard is because of their commitment to the communities in which they do business, in particular, their devotion to and support of charitable causes in the markets they serve. If licensed, Harvard will bring its commitment, community spirit, and charitable giving to Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12309 As a business owner, it is important to get results from our advertising, but it is extremely gratifying to be part of the charitable programs Harvard is involved in. Their commitment to every community they serve is overwhelming, and I have been involved in many projects in small town Assiniboia, Saskatchewan, that would not have come to fruition without the help of Harvard.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12310 In closing, I would like to summarize my position with regards to Harvard's application. I feel they would be a great business partner in Medicine Hat through their integrity and spirit of enterprise. I believe the radio public would benefit from this new format culturally and economically. More importantly, though, it will be to the benefit of the many charities within and around Medicine Hat that will reap the rewards of Harvard's corporate philanthropy as time goes on, a legacy that Harvard continues to promote.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12311 Thank you for your consideration.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12312 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Harvey. Please don't leave the table. There may be questions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12313 Commissioner Pennefather...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12314 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12315 Good afternoon. Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12316 I'm going to just ‑‑ I have a couple questions for you, Madam Watson. Thank you for your presentation because it filled in a few of the blanks on the ‑‑ what AMEF, the Aboriginal Media Educational Fund is all about. I went to the website, and I gather from the website and from your presentation, though, we're in early days, programs are not as yet functioning; is that correct?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12317 MS WATSON: Absolutely. What we're trying to do is we're trying to do as much research as possible, which we're near completing. I will be presenting to a Board meeting, which is taking place in the next couple of weeks. But what we wanted to do is make quite sure that everything was in place before we started running, so we have a list of all our potential contacts and mentors. We have a list of all the funding opportunities. We have been meeting with everyone in the private and public sector across Canada. We're putting together good ‑‑ what I believe will be a good governance mechanism, which will allow us to have complete transparency of ‑‑ you know, for everything we do including the members of the Board that are chosen. So this has taken a lot more time than I wanted because I'm the most impatient person when it comes to programming programs, and, of course, which brings me also to the fact that a lot of the ideas about the type of programming are also coming to fruition and will be presented shortly. But this took rather a long time because I wanted to make sure that we were actually looking at programs that will fulfill the needs of the community that we're trying to serve. There's no point in ‑‑ you know, I can come up with any number of programs. This is what I've been doing for the past many years across Canada, creating and developing training programs, but there are certain real needs, which are different from what I've been doing up to now, so it required a lot of meetings, a lot of talking to the ‑‑ to the people in the community that would be interested in these programs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12318 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay. Well, I'm sure you're aware of one of the reasons I'm asking the question, and amongst others, it's very important to have a good sense of where the fund is going and why. But at the very end, you do say, "AMEF is a constructive beginning to develop this talent. We ask the Commission to confirm its suitability as a recipient of CTD funds." So you also mention in your letter that you submitted ‑‑ provide direct funding allows to allocated funds to program and initiatives most urgently needed. So at this stage, can you help us by understanding, your understanding of how the programs, as you see them developing, would be under the current rules of CTD initiatives, appropriate allocation.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12319 MS WATSON: Well, essentially, what we're looking at is making ‑‑ interviewing the people where a need has been expressed by both the person and the market. And to give you an example, from the Writers Guild and from many of the producers, I have heard that writing skills are much required. So the first thing ‑‑ one of the things that I have done is I've approached the Writers Guild of Canada, and together, we will be putting together a program, which we will fund. They will develop with us to make sure that, you know, the proper requirements are met.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12320 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And these are writing skills in broadcasting?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12321 MS WATSON: These would be writing skills in broadcasting, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12322 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So there would be skill training and mentorship?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12323 MS WATSON: Absolutely. Mentorship I have always found is an extremely important element in any program. It is not enough to give a two‑day seminar or have a weeks ‑‑ you know, and then just let them go into the great wide world. You need to be able to make sure that you follow‑up. One of the great ways of following up and making sure that whatever they learn is put into practice is to go through the mentorship. There could be two mentorship processes. Depending on the level of the candidate, there could be placement with the broadcasters or on a set, and there could also be a mentor of which has been selected, which is near to what that particular participant wishes to attain, and where they could call on a regular basis and get advice.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12324 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay. One last question, and I don't know if you're able to answer this at this point. But from a governance point of view, can you foresee the possibility that broadcaster participating by means of a CTD contribution would be able the have a say in how the funds would be used?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12325 MS WATSON: Not with what I'm presently putting together, and I've had some great help with some people who have been spending a lot of time writing the rules.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12326 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay. So it would be, generally, seen as more of an overall contribution to the fund, and ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12327 MS WATSON: Absolutely.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12328 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: ‑‑ the fund would make the decisions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12329 MS WATSON: We make the decisions, absolutely. It is necessary, and I can assure you that nobody that will be contributing will be sitting on either the Board or the selection committee.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12330 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay, thank you. Nice to see you again.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12331 MS WATSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12332 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12333 THE CHAIRPERSON: Vice‑Chair Arpin?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12334 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: My first question is for you, Mrs. Watson. At ‑‑ in your oral presentation, from time to time, you're using the present tense, and other times you're using the future tense. Where are you? Are you now operating, are you structured?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12335 MS WATSON: Well, I am because I'm really in the present and in the future. I'm glad you noticed that. You know, presently we have had ‑‑ we've formed partnerships, and one of our recent placement was ‑‑ we paid for ten Aboriginal youth to be trained through the National Screen Institute. It was a 16‑week program in which they learned various skills, and where they will continue to be mentored. So that's in the present. The present is also a partnership with Ryerson, which are taking on a couple of our, you know, worthy candidates. But as with any new organization ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12336 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: There's a lot to be done.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12337 MS WATSON: ‑‑ you have to be present and future, so I'm continuing the future speaking to people, developing programs, and looking forward, in the next few months, to really being able to get going. I mean, we have a terrific idea and a great need.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12338 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12339 Mr. Harvey, I don't know if you were here yesterday or ‑‑ or surely you were here earlier this morning. A discussion we had throughout the two days is that ‑‑ has to do with the market of Medicine Hat and the ‑‑ is it a booming market? Is it a stable market? Is it ‑‑ I don't think anybody argued that it was in negative conditions, but some ‑‑ or we heard Mr. Raible earlier saying that, be cautious, Medicine Hat is not Lethbridge, is not ‑‑ surely not Fort McMurray or Grande Prairie. To the contrary yesterday, we heard some of the applicants saying that with all the economic development that is taking place, particularly in the southeast of Alberta, Medicine Hat is growing at a faster pace than, say, Lethbridge on one hand, and then so that the economy ‑‑ well, retail sales are ahead of pace. They ‑‑ surely, they are ahead of ‑‑ quite ‑‑ from an index point of view, quite above national average. You are a retail person in the Medicine Hat market. What is the actual conditions of that market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12340 MR. HARVEY: Thank you for your question. To give you ‑‑ I do business in two provinces, Saskatchewan is relatively, we would say, conservative and staid. In Medicine Hat, the business market is very vibrant. It's driven by oil and gas revenues to some degree. Unfortunately, to the demise of Saskatchewan, it's driven by retirement. It's driven by the Medicine Hat College. There's a lot of ‑‑ again, unfortunately, to the demise of Saskatchewan, a lot of young people moving in to Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12341 Medicine Hat is developing its own economy within its own city. It's certainly dependent on agriculture, it's dependent on gas, it's dependent on oil, but there is lots of manufacturing coming into the city. One cannot underestimate the economic activity of oil and gas, but I think Medicine Hat is maturing into a city, much the same as Lethbridge. The growth factor is phenomenal. The one thing that we see is just the maturing of the market becoming a full‑fledged city instead of a larger business centre.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12342 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: The ‑‑ some of the applicants yesterday were saying that the big boxes are getting ‑‑ are moving now to Medicine Hat. People used to go to Lethbridge to have a Wal‑Mart, and they ‑‑ and a Future ‑‑ but on ‑‑ the Wal‑Mart being ‑‑ and Best Buy, I will say, are what we call the big boxes. The ‑‑ now, you are in the carpet business. How do you see those big boxes coming in your market? Are you concerned that they're going to eat your lunch, or there's room for you and for them?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12343 MR. HARVEY: Well, there's room for both. We're a service‑driven industry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12344 I like to think that I come from pretty humble beginnings, and as my grandfather and my father were tenacious, we'll survive. There's no problem there. That, in itself, is an indication that, again, people that have ‑‑ well, definitely more resources available to them than I do are seeing that market as viable, and so trade and commerce ‑‑ I mean, we're riding a peak on our graph, but ‑‑ and it's certainly going to level out, and it's certainly going to probably go down, and that's where all my business planning is done on a flat line, relative to how we do it in Saskatchewan, and I ‑‑ I don't see any problem in that market. It can't consistently maintain the pace of growth right now. The city can't even keep up to it. They'll tell you that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12345 For me, the indication of larger companies coming in, the big boxes, the Costco is supposedly coming in the fall or early spring. All of those things are good indicators of a strong economic market, and I think that it can only be good.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12346 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you very much, Mr. Harvey. Those are my questions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12347 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Vice‑Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12348 I have just a few more questions of Ms Watson. You are looking for another Board member. Is that ‑‑ are you looking for a First Nations person?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12349 MS WATSON: (Off mic...) I always forget to do that. Yes, we're very careful in looking ‑‑ we have Metis, we have Inuit, we're looking at First Nations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12350 THE CHAIRPERSON: No, I'm talking about your Board Members.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12351 MS WATSON: Yes, and the sixth person will be ‑‑ that will become a fact in two weeks' time. The person has been approached and will be ‑‑ most probably be accepting.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12352 THE CHAIRPERSON: So you have Board members of Sandra McDonald ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12353 MS WATSON: Oh, no, no, that's the advisory committee. This is not the Board. The Board is made up exclusively of Aboriginal peoples.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12354 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, okay. So this is ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12355 MS WATSON: Yes, I'm sorry. The advisory committee is the greater ‑‑ they're the people that are going to give us all sorts of information, help us find funding ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12356 THE CHAIRPERSON: My mistake.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12357 MS WATSON: ‑‑ put us in the right direction ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12358 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12359 MS WATSON: ‑‑ and be a great source of mentorship.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12360 THE CHAIRPERSON: Now, and do I understand in terms of the present, AMEF has already disbursed monies and has already sent ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12361 MS WATSON: Yes, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12362 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ some worthy individuals to Ryerson and to NSI?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12363 MS WATSON: That's right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12364 THE CHAIRPERSON: And so you've already been raising money, under a different name or ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12365 MS WATSON: No. The first funding has come from APTN. They've put a certain amount of money aside, and that ‑‑ that was our first because we wanted to ‑‑ at the same time as being recognized by CRA, as a non‑profit charitable organization, we wanted to be able to straightaway start our work.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12366 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, seed money? Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12367 MS WATSON: Yes. So that's our seed money.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12368 THE CHAIRPERSON: And you want to raise $10 million?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12369 MS WATSON: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12370 THE CHAIRPERSON: And then you think you'll be self‑sustaining after that? Is that the concept?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12371 MS WATSON: Well, $10 million, you know, I look to the budget, is a good amount, but we will be continuing to look for funding from that and on. It doesn't mean that we will not start before we get our $10 million or that we will stop at $10 million.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12372 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, okay. And then you are also, is it setting up partners that will do the mentorship?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12373 MS WATSON: We're setting up partnerships where ‑‑ one of the things I've done in my former life as ‑‑ starting with the ‑‑ creating the national training program when I was with the Canadian Television Production Association, was look at the number of training programs that were in Canada, and you'd be horrified to find out that it's 200 a knot(ph) with a lot of people competing for the same amount of money and not knowing that, you know, some of the training is repeated a dozen odd times across the country, and, you know, one would serve but, anyways, that's ‑‑ that's an ongoing problem which many people are trying to resolve. So, therefore, one of the things I've done ‑‑ and I went back to my notes to see who was still in existence and have been getting in touch with the people I feel will best serve to deliver the programs that I'm looking at.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12374 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Harvey. Thank you, Ms Watson.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12375 Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12376 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12377 This completes Phase III of the process, and we will now proceed to Phase IV in which applicants can reply to all interventions submitted on their application. Applicants are invited to appear in reverse order as listed on the agenda, and for the record, Newcap Inc. will not be appearing in this phase. Therefore, I would ask Mr. Pat Lough, on behalf of a corporation to be incorporated, to come forward if he wishes to appear in this phase.
‑‑‑ Off microphone / Sans microphone
LISTNUM 95 \l 12378 THE SECRETARY: All right. Mr. Lough has declined.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12379 Then I will call on Rogers Broadcasting Limited to come forward.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12380 MR. MILES: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12381 I will be uncharacteristically brief.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12382 Thank you so much on behalf of my team for an expedient hearing, but very fair, and through you, Madam Chair, to the rest of the panel and to the staff for all of the assistance during this hearing process.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12383 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12384 THE CHAIRPERSON: The Vice‑Chair has a question for you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12385 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: And for all of those who will come. We heard CIRPA making some comments regarding the radio review and expecting that ‑‑ or those who will be licensed will agree to follow the rules that the Commission may come up with out of the radio review. Do you have any comments to make to ‑‑ to what Mr. Mair said earlier today?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12386 MR. MILES: Yes, I do. I thought that he was unfair and uncharacteristically negative toward the applicants in the general process of funding for the Canadian talent thing. Look it, we have always looked forward to a relationship in the industry that we have established through the CAB and the hearing process and the radio regulation process, and that is a process that I think will continue, and we shouldn't try and destroy any of that kind of relationship that we've got going, and we do look forward to the material coming out of the radio review. We've all been part and parcel of the process.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12387 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So you will be ‑‑ if say that the Commission, in its wisdom, choose the SOCAN approach and make it 51 percent Canadian content, you will adhere to that 51 percent Canadian content, even if today, at this hearing, your application wasn't predicated on that level?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12388 MR. MILES: Reluctantly, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12389 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12390 THE SECRETARY: I would now call on the next applicant, Harvard Broadcasting Limited.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12391 MR. COWIE: Thank you very much, Madam Chair and Members of the Commission, Commission Staff. We just wish to thank you very much for a very efficient and helpful hearing for us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12392 I hope I don't have to answer that question, Mr. Vice‑Chair, I thought Mr. Miles did a good job of that. But there are two sayings, one is that Lord Beaverbrook said, "The world is full of unrealized fears," and on the other hand, the others, "Que sera sera."
LISTNUM 95 \l 12393 So thank you very much.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12394 THE SECRETARY: The next applicant to appear would be Vista Radio Limited.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12395 MS MICALLEF: We don't have anything to add either, other than to thank the Commission for, again, allowing us to be ‑‑ to appear in front of you, and we have really nothing to add to either what Mr. Miles said or Mr. Cowie. They were both very articulate.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12396 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12397 THE SECRETARY: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12398 We'd now call on numbered company 1182743 Alberta Limited to come forward, please.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12399 MR. LARSEN: Again, just thank you, Madam Chair, Commissioners, and staff for the expedited hearing. We'd reiterate again no reply to the CIRPA intervention, but we'd like to just point out that we did a written response to the CIRPA written intervention, so thank you very much.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12400 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Mr. Larsen, your reply ‑‑
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12401 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Yes, obviously the argument that Mr. Mair made this morning regarding the radio review was not in the CIRPA submission on one hand or was not ‑‑ surely not articulated the way he articulated it, and so your reply didn't cover that, so what are your views?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12402 MR. LARSEN: Right. As a new broadcaster, obviously, we would abide by the rules that are set by the CRTC. I would agree with what Mr. Miles said that we believe there's a fair structure in place, and whatever the rules will be, will be, and we will follow them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12403 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12404 MR. LARSEN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12405 HEARING SECRETARY: The next applicant would be Radio CJVR Ltd., if they would come forward.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12406 MR. SINGER: Thank you, Madam Chair, Commissioners, and CRTC staff.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12407 I would just like to comment on the interventions stated here this afternoon regarding our admission of 40 percent Cancon in our oral presentation. We apologize that our inclusion of that 40‑percent Cancon commitment in yesterday's presentation has caused concern to our fellow applicants and to the CRTC.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12408 As noted yesterday, we regret that the 40‑percent figure was not included in our Supplementary Brief filed earlier. In preparing that application, we felt it was a given that CJVR would commit to 40‑percent Cancon just as we do at our two FM stations in Melfort and Whitecourt. This level, I can assure you, and assure our applicants, our fellow applicants, was not based on what our competing applicants have placed in their applications. The level was based on what we, as a strong promoter of Canadian talent, commit to at our radio stations. The only reason we added that into our oral presentation yesterday, regrettably, was to parallel that level with our other significant Canadian talent development benefits that we are very, very proud of. We've been recognized for this commitment of promoting local Canadian talent, and when we put this application, we said, why would we stop here?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12409 Finally, I wish to say that CJVR is very respectful of the CRTC public process and the fair manner in which all applications are treated and assessed. It was never our intention to work around that process. Having said that, to be fair to our competing applicants, with the commission's indulgence, CJVR will go on record to state that a 35‑percent commitment to Cancon level should go on the record in our Medicine Hat application if this Commission so chooses; however, should with be monitored at any given time, given this licence, I can assure you, you will find that we are playing at least 40 percent Cancon.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12410 And in closing, I just wanted to say thank you for a very fair hearing. Thank you for pointing out our omission, and we will strive to keep that in mind as we move forward.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12411 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Singer. Any ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12412 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Any comments on Mr. Mair's presentation this morning ‑‑ this afternoon, I should say, regarding the radio review?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12413 MR. SINGER: I think my fellow applicants that have appeared before me pretty well summed up my feeling on that. Thank you for the opportunity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12414 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12415 MR. SINGER: Great.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12416 THE CHAIRPERSON: Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12417 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair. Golden West Broadcasting Limited is the next applicant.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12418 MR. HILDEBRAND: Thank you one last time. Thank you for running an expeditious process. I think you have gone through a lot of applications with great dispatch, and I think everyone in the room appreciates that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12419 I have a small comment to make on the CIRPA presentation. Notwithstanding the compliment that he gave our organization for, you know, exceeding Cancon regulations, I find it presumptuous for an organization like that to come and try and run our business. I think until such a time as we are invited to participate in making their business plans, they should, you know, keep their distance.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12420 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12421 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Any further comments regarding the radio review?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12422 MR. HILDEBRAND: Yeah, again, I think the Commission will be fair in their radio review, and, from our perspective, we'll be able to live with whatever the review comes down with.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12423 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12424 MR. HILDEBRAND: Thanks.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12425 THE SECRETARY: I will now call on the last applicant, Lighthouse Broadcasting Limited. Do you wish to appear? I see they're not present.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12426 Madam Chair, this completes the list of applicants and therefore phase IV of this process.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12427 I do have two announcements to make on the record. We have been provided a document by Rogers Broadcasting, which is a breakdown of their music and spoken word as they had committed to do so. This document will be placed on the applicant's file on the public examination file, and it can be viewed in the exam room.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12428 We also have been provided with ‑‑ Radio CJVR Limited, there's a table showing their spoken word content, as they had committed to do so, and that also will be placed on their application filed.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12429 Madam Chair, this completes the consideration of item 1 to 9 on the agenda.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12430 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12431 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Madam Secretary.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12432 We will adjourn ‑‑ by my clock on my wall, it's 20 to 1. I think we will actually even go for until ‑‑ what do we say, an hour and a half? 2:00. So you can even take an afternoon nap. We will be proceeding to volume 3 and Regina, the pearl of the prairies, of course, at 2:00.
‑‑‑ Upon recessing at 1239 / Suspension à 1239
‑‑‑ Upon resuming at 1400 / Reprise à 1400
LISTNUM 95 \l 12433 THE CHAIRPERSON: Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12434 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12435 We are now ready to proceed with the applications from the Regina market starting with item 10 on the agenda, which is an application by Newcap Inc. for a licence to operate an English‑language commercial FM radio programming undertaking in Regina. The new station would operate on frequency 90.3 megahertz (channel 212C1) with an effective radiated power of 100,000 watts (non‑directional antenna/antenna height of 148.5 metres).
LISTNUM 95 \l 12436 Appearing for the applicant is Mr. Rob Steele, who will introduce his colleagues. Mr. Steele, you'll have 20 minutes for your presentation.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12437 Go ahead.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12438 MR. STEELE: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12439 Well, good afternoon, Madam Chair, Members of the Commission, the Commission Staff. I'm Rob Steele, the President and Chief Executive Officer of Newcap Radio, and before we begin our presentation, I'd like to reintroduce our team. Seated in the front row to my immediate right is David Murray, Chief Operating Officer for Newcap Radio, beside Dave is Glenda Spenrath, assisted GM of Newcap's Alberta Radio Group East, based in Lloydminster. Glenda was born and raised in Saskatchewan, and, as you may know, Lloydminster serves much of western Saskatchewan. And as such, Glenda has good knowledge of the economic picture in the province. To her right is Mark Maheu, Executive Vice‑President and Chief Strategist for Newcap Radio. Next to Mark is Sue Stevenson, News Director of our southern Alberta group of stations, including KG Country and Z99, Red Deer. And on the far right is Brad Boechler, our VP of sales. Brad was born in Melfort, raised in Regina, and worked in radio in the city and throughout the province for many years.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12440 This is the second of our three appearances, and this application represents our first proposal to bring our brand of radio to Saskatchewan, and I'd like to ask Glenda to speak to the economic conditions here in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12441 Glenda...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12442 MS SPENRATH: As we did our research on Saskatchewan, we realized that Regina is one of Canada's best kept secrets. Let me tell you about some of the reasons why we are excited about Regina. While it seemed there was an exodus in the late‑1990s, the population is now growing in Saskatchewan. FP Demographics projects that the population will increase to over a million people by 2011. Regina actually counters the provincial trend with modest population growth over the past ten years.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12443 In terms of income, there's continued growth in household incomes, a primary indicator that consumers have the money to spend on goods and services. And, of course, this means a growth in retail sales. FP Markets projects that income in the city will increase by nine percent from 2006 to 2008 and by 22 percent by 2011. In fact, Regina's 2006 personal income is two percent ahead of the Canadian average and 14 to 16 percent ahead of the provincial average.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12444 In terms of housing starts, Stats Canada reports that Regina and Saskatoon are leading all other metro markets in Canada in the new housing pricing index, other than Edmonton and Calgary. CMHC indicates that single‑family housing starts are strong in both Saskatoon and Regina because that is where employment and wages are growing.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12445 A good indicator of the economic activity in the province is the government's announcement last Friday that they were able to cut the provincial sales tax by two percent. The government indicated that revenues from the energy sector enabled them to maintain their economic position while cutting the sales tax.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12446 I would like, now, to ask Brad Boechler to speak about what this means for retail sales and radio revenues.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12447 Brad...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12448 MR. BOECHLER: Thanks, Glenda. The economy in Saskatchewan is quietly turning around, and this is good news for radio. More people making better wages and buying homes means more spending on consumer goods.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12449 FP Markets projects retail sales to grow in Regina at about the same rate as income. The $2.1 billion in retail sales in 2006 are projected to increase by nine percent by 2008 and by a total of 23 percent by 2011. This should have a substantial and positive impact on radio revenues.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12450 While we do not have access to the actual financial returns for this market as there are only two private radio broadcasters, we can look at the trends in the province and expect that Regina should outperform the province given its better economics and consistent employment rates in both the public and private sectors.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12451 According to the Commission's radio financial summary for 2005, radio revenues had an average annual growth rate of nine percent between 2001 and 2005. Properly stimulated, radio revenues will continue to increase at the same rate as retail sales, and, as you know, new radio entrance into a market normally caused radio revenues to increase even more rapidly.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12452 We believe that Regina is an underserved market in terms of the number of radio stations available to its residents. For a few examples, Moncton, New Brunswick, whose CMA is less than three‑fifths that of Regina, is home to six commercial FM stations and two community stations that aggressively compete for revenues in that market. Added to that, two Christian stations and as well four CBC stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12453 If we consider only commercial radio stations, there is one radio station for every 20,000 people in Moncton compared to Regina's one radio station for every 34,000 people.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12454 Saint John, New Brunswick, a city whose population is 110,000, has six commercial radio stations of which five are on the FM band, or one for every 18,000 people.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12455 Brandon, Manitoba has a population one‑fifth that of Regina's but has four commercial radio stations, about one for every 10,000 people.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12456 Belleville, Ontario, has a census agglomeration, a population of approximately 90,000 people, less than half of Regina, but is home to five local commercial radio stations or one radio station per 18,000 residents.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12457 We believe that Regina residents have a right to the range of radio choice that the market can support, and it can definitely support more radio.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12458 In my meetings with Regina business leaders, I basically heard the same thing repeated over and over: another choice in radio service and advertising options would be beneficial for their business.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12459 Now, to speak to you about our choice of formats, here is Mark Maheu.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12460 MR. MAHEU: Thanks, Brad. Newcap Radio conducted a complete and comprehensive research study of the Regina market to determine what opportunities might exist for a new FM radio service. Our research was conducted with Regina residents aged 18 to 64, and we examined nine different format options.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12461 Our findings showed that the preferred format option for Regina listeners was classic hits followed by classic rock and then '60s and '70s oldies.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12462 Next, we looked at the percentage of format void, which is simply the percentage of people who say they would listen often to a format but cannot associate any radio station in the city with it. The percentage of format void indicates how big an opportunity there is for a new format.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12463 In Regina, the top format void is for '60s and '70s oldies at 16 percent, followed by classic hits at 11 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12464 Now, since CRTC regulations do not allow for a true oldies format because it is predominantly hit songs from the '60s and '70s, Newcap proposes an oldies‑based classic hits format for Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12465 45 percent of the music will be the great oldies hits from the mid‑'60s through the '70s from artists like The Supremes, The Four Tops, CCR, the Beach Boys, The Guess Who, and Bachman‑Turner Overdrive.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12466 55 percent of the station sound will draw from the traditional classic hits repertoire from the '80s and '90s and now from artists like Bryan Adams, Phil Collins, Madonna, and John Mellencamp.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12467 Now, according to the research, the demographic this format would appeal to is adults 35 to 64 with real strength with adults 45 to 64. This strong, positive interest skews slightly to men at 55 percent, women at 45 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12468 Newcap is also proposing to create and broadcast several fun, informative, and interesting music features to compliment the music on the radio station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12469 Week nights at seven, we will feature That '70s Show featuring music from artists like Abba, Gordon Lightfoot, Joni Mitchell, The Bee Gees, Chicago, all the artists that defined a decade.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12470 Sundays at noon, we'll put the emphasis on The Roots of Rock'n'Roll. The show will pay homage to the music that created the rock genre, with blues, rock'n'roll, and vintage rock classics from artists as diverse as BB King, Elvis Presley, Hank Williams, Elmore James, and John Mayall.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12471 And Sunday nights at six, we'll air The Classic Album Story. Each week, we'll tell the story of one of the best classic albums from the past 40 years, playing tracks, and discussing the albums with listeners and guests.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12472 We know from our experience that the oldies‑based and classic hits listeners love the music of the past, but they live in the here and now. Adults 35‑64 also have an expectation of credible, frequent news and information from radio. As part of our proposal for Regina, we have addressed this need by putting forth an extensive schedule of spoken word programming and news. And to tell you a bit more, here is Sue Stevenson.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12473 MS STEVENSON: Thanks, Mark. As we noted in our previous presentation and as you will hear in our current presentation, we believe there is a need for an even greater emphasis on local news and information in an era where niche formats, specializing in almost everything you can imagine, are available to all of us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12474 At Newcap, we are proud of the way we make every one of our stations a local station. We don't do it the same way in every place, rather we tailor our approach to what the particular circumstances of the community are. So, for example, in Saint John's, Newfoundland, our heritage news and talk station VOCM is pretty well solid news and information all day, and our news director there, Gerry Phelan, recently won a national RTNDA award. You also heard the other day about our success in Red Deer.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12475 As in Medicine Hat and Saskatoon, we propose to provide a minimum of five hours and 45 minutes per week of news of which 75 percent will be local. Our five‑minute newscasts on the hour, in morning drive, at noon, and in the afternoon seven days a week will be supplemented by shorter newscasts on the half hour in morning drive.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12476 With the increase in our news commitments in our letter of August 14th, we have also increased the number of news staff to four full‑time and one part‑time.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12477 The audience for this station will start at 35 years of age with a real core being in the 45‑plus age group, and we intend to reach out to them with spoken word features that will address their needs. Clearly, investments and health become more important as we mature. We want to know that we will have enough money to indulge our tastes and good enough health to enjoy the possibilities open to us, to travel, to help our children and their children, and to indulge in the fine things in life.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12478 In addition to our five hours and 45 minutes of news, we will broadcast a number of program features.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12479 There is Inside Regina. Three times a day, we will profile someone who is making a difference in Regina, a business leader, a volunteer, or perhaps a Roughriders booster.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12480 Live Tonight will focus on arts and entertainment activities around the city with plays, gallery openings, concerts, and other events. We won't merely billboard these events, but interview those involved in presenting them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12481 In 2004, Regina was named the cultural capital of Canada. Live Tonight will be one way to reflect the cultural activities that help win that title.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12482 Another program is Your Town. It will bring a focus to the civic events that are going on to make Regina a better place. Charity auctions, not‑for‑profit events, and other information that particularly focuses on the not‑for‑profit community.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12483 As the provincial capital, Regina benefits from provincial institutions that bring arts and cultural events year round. It has a wide range of festivals throughout the year, whether it's Mosaic, Bazart at the Norman Mackenzie Art Gallery, Pile of Bones Sunday in Wascana Park, and, of course, Buffalo Days, or one of the many summer music and other celebrations. We will cover all these events thoroughly.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12484 During our Medicine Hat presentation, we talked about the mobile studios. Our Regina mobile studio will allow us to not only promote the events, but to be on‑site with interviews with organizers and participants.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12485 And now to speak about Canadian talent development and to sum up, here is Mark Maheu.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12486 MR. MAHEU: We propose to spend just over $1.5 million on Canadian talent development in Regina if we are a successful applicant.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12487 Each year, we will devote $215,000 to three initiatives. Two of the beneficiaries will be Saskatchewan organizations, the third, a national organization.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12488 The national organization will be the Radio Starmaker Fund. The Commission is quite familiar with the Starmaker Fund, which resulted from a Commission request that the industry develop a fund that would focus on marketing and promotion of emerging Canadian artists. We would request that the fund direct our annual $90,000 contribution to Regina artists first, and any excess to Saskatchewan artists.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12489 Our first local initiative is to grant to the University of Regina Department of Music, $40,000 each year. Now, half of that is going to be directed to scholarships for music students, while the remaining funds will be used to support music festivals and competitions. We hope to help the music community develop by supporting new, young artists as they learn their trade and have an opportunity to perform before critical, but supportive audiences.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12490 The second of our Saskatchewan initiatives is an annual grant to Sask Music of $85,000. Sask Music is also known as SRIA, the Saskatchewan Recording Industry Association. And in their intervention supporting our applications, Sask Music pointed out, "The kinds of educational and export initiatives that they support." They further indicate that they need additional funds to more fully underwrite their initiatives for both new and emerging artists.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12491 Madam Chair, Members of the Commission, we passionately believe that for our industry to continue to flourish, we have to continue to provide high quality and diverse radio services to Canadians. We need more radio with more local services providing a wide range of programming, capitalizing on the over‑the‑air radio's greatest strength, its local connection. New services expand listening, provide choice in music and editorial content and grow radio's overall share of the advertising pie.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12492 We believe that in Regina they are ready for new radio for all the economic reasons that Glenda and Brad outlined just moments ago.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12493 Harvard and Rawlco radio provide excellent radio service to this city, no question about it. Our argument is not based upon making up for deficiencies in their service, but in a world where listeners have many alternative sources for music, listeners are not willing to settle for their second choice when it comes to a local radio station. What they want is great local radio that engages them, speaks to their tastes, and informs them about what's going on, whether it's around the corner or around the world. New radio choices will also cause the existing broadcasters to hone their focus by providing and superserving their core audiences while a new radio station would superserve a new constituency.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12494 If the market can support it, and we believe it can, the outcome is more choice for the listener, additional editorial voices, more targeted audiences for advertisers, and more money for Canadian talent development. It's a win for everyone.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12495 We believe that we have provided a new radio station proposal that will be a hit with Regina listeners. Newcap has a strong commitment to building for the long term, and that would be the case here in Regina. A strong business plan, based on our expertise in bringing new formats to the market in exciting ways. We're going to provide a new format that's presently not available in Regina. A strong, local programming proposal with more than adequate programming spending to meet our proposal's needs, and a contribution to the development of Canadian talent worth over $1.5 million.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12496 Thank you very much for your time and attention. We'd be happy to answer any questions you might have.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12497 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12498 Commissioner Pennefather...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12499 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12500 Good afternoon. I'm going to go through some questions on programming, and we'll start this time with the spoken word. Thank you for your chart, again, which this time has hours and minutes, I noticed, so we're confused some more ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12501 MR. MAHEU: We're quick learners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12502 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you. And I was all set to do to the other and show off.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12503 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: In your presentation, you actually are on my very first question. Your presentation on page 10, Ms Stevenson, said you will increase the number of news staff considering the fact that this ‑‑ the 81 news packages now, and are five hours and 45 minutes is an increase. You are then increasing the number of news staff to four full‑time and one part‑time; is that correct?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12504 MR. MAHEU: That is correct, 4.5, four and a half.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12505 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: It was originally two journalist announcers and one news director ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12506 MR. MAHEU: Right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12507 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: ‑‑ so my question is, with this increase in expenses, would you submit a revised 4.1 financial summary to reflect that change? Would that not cause a change? I know you submitted a revised in terms of CTD, but would it not require a revised 4.1 financial statement?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12508 MR. MAHEU: It probably does need to be revised, but it's not a material revision, is it, Dave?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12509 MR. MURRAY: No, actually the salaries in programming in 4.1 were actually already there ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12510 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12511 MR. MURRAY: ‑‑ it's just we hadn't had the correct number in the Brief.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12512 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12513 We discussed previously the rationale behind the increase in news packages in what we outline as scheduled news here versus non‑news. I don't mean versus in a bad sense, but just as a different ‑‑ our 75 percent local content is in your news packages. Will this cover only the pure news portion or does it also refer to surveillance material, sports, weather, and news combined, the 75 percent local content?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12514 MR. MAHEU: Madam Commissioner, if I understand what you're saying, you're asking if the 75 percent local content applies to just the news, weather, and sports, the scheduled portion?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12515 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12516 MR. MAHEU: Yes, the same as the previous application where, again, 75 percent on average. If you took it out over the course of a week or whatever then you find that 75 percent of the content in those scheduled newscasts would be ‑‑ would be local.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12517 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: 75 percent of the 5.45?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12518 MR. MAHEU: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12519 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And what about the non‑news, would it also be 75 percent local?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12520 MR. MAHEU: It actually might be a little higher than that because those non‑news spoken word items, whether it's some of the features that we plan to run or the spoken word from our on‑air personalities, virtually, all of that would be what we would consider local.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12521 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Does the scheduled news, five hours, 45 minutes, include ‑‑ yes, it does, I'm answering my own question, the sports and the weather and so on are all there?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12522 MR. MAHEU: Yes, it does.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12523 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Now, one other point that we discussed, I believe, previously as well, was many newscasts are often repeated with only minor adjustments in content and delivery to provide updates and sustain audience interests. By increasing your weekly newscasts, do you envision an increase in original content or an increase in repetition of the same content?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12524 MR. MAHEU: It's a good question. We kind of talked about that a little bit as it related to our Medicine Hat proposal. I think I'll let Sue reiterate our approach on multiple newscasts and keeping them fresh.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12525 MS STEVENSON: All right, thank you very much.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12526 With our newscasts, we are always trying to keep things fresh. We strive not to have the same newscast or the same content from, say, 7:30 a.m. to 8 a.m. because, frankly, that just gets boring to listeners. We'll touch on the top news stories, but beyond that, we want to offer different local stories in different newscasts. And, generally, we'll ‑‑ we almost day part it. If we have a story that's running in the morning run, say, from 5:30 to nine, well, you're not going to hear that story throughout the rest of the day. So we're always striving to have different and new local stories and to really mix things up so it's not the same newscast over and over again.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12527 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: We also were left a little wanting last time in a discussion on your point that you increased the news packages, which is the scheduled news list, 5.45 hours, in relation to changing times and to the different sources of entertainment and information that the public now has, and we asked why you wouldn't, then, increase the non‑news component. Can you talk about that a little bit? Why in increasing the news and information or spoken word you increased the scheduled news and not the non‑news, the ‑‑ for example, the community update and the public affairs reports. In terms of your overall approach to ‑‑ I think you mentioned it that conventional terrestrial radio needs to look at things a little differently now. Can you speak to that point?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12528 MR. MAHEU: Sure. When we put our proposal together and even as it is being presented to you here today, a couple of things. The proposals that we're putting forth on the regularly scheduled news along with the non‑scheduled spoken word, we look at these as kind of a floor as minimums that we're certainly prepared to commit to and do. The marketplace will dictate, in many cases, what needs to be done to be successful. We see this as kind of a framework for the beginning of our success in building something in the marketplace. In a number of features in the Inside Regina reports and Live Tonight in Your Town, when we originally put our proposal together in a competitive environment like Regina, with six other competing radio stations, we felt that that would be enough to get started at least to be able to ‑‑ begin to position ourselves in the community of doing things a little bit differently and having content on the air that could generate an audience and hence, a listenership. So we look at them as really minimum amounts going forward that is going to be necessary, but the marketplace and the competitive environment will also dictate how much of that we're ‑‑ how much more we're going to need to do, if we're going to need to do more, to be successful.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12529 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Will the same ‑‑ I believe now we're at the news staff, four full‑time, one part‑time. Will the same news staff be working on the scheduled news as the non‑news component?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12530 MR. MAHEU: Sue...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12531 MS STEVENSON: For the most part. The news people will handle some of these specialty programs as well, but I have talked about the mobile studio, and that's where a programming end could come in and help. A mobile studio, it's more than just a ‑‑ say, a community cruiser. We have dedicated broadcast systems in the cruisers that are able to go out into the community and interview people and send that realtime back to the stations. So that's one component that would lap over. And the ‑‑ for instance, the Live Tonight, that would be produced by a news team. Your Town and the community events, that would be something that would be done in concert with programming. So it's kind of a hybrid situation.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12532 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: We ‑‑ also ‑‑ here do you also have the listener poll as part of your proposal?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12533 MS STEVENSON: That would be included, generally, right in the newscasts, so it would be, you know, part of that local content during the newscasts.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12534 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And could you tell me ‑‑ tell us a little bit more about it, how it would work? We called it the Hat Line in Medicine Hat because it's called the Hat, Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12535 MS STEVENSON: That's right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12536 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: My colleague made sure I understood that, and ‑‑ but what it specifically ‑‑ we're talking about a different market now.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12537 MS STEVENSON: Right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12538 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Could you tell me if it's exactly the same or is there some different approach?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12539 MS STEVENSON: It would, basically, be the same. Of course, the name wouldn't be the same, but basically, you know, we would ask our listeners to call in on topics of the day that are of interest to the community. One day it might be a very serious topic, the next it could be a little more light, but it's ‑‑ as I mentioned yesterday, it's a way to engage our listeners and take the pulse of the community.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12540 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And this would become part of programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12541 MS STEVENSON: It could be. You know, we would initiate it in the news, but it's definitely a spillover topic that the announcers could also talk about.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12542 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: But it isn't the listeners being on air themselves?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12543 MS STEVENSON: We would have listeners on air. We would have a line to take their comments, and we would take those comments and put them on air.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12544 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And who would be responsible for, if you will, monitoring the comments for deciding what goes on air?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12545 MS STEVENSON: Well, that would ‑‑ that would have to be the news team. Of course, the news director is not there all the time, so it would be the news team who is doing that and making sure nothing inappropriate gets on the air.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12546 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And I'm looking at, now, the August 14th deficiency response, you indicated here that nearly a hundred percent of your programming will be locally produced, with the exception of some syndicated programming. Could you tell us what parts of your proposed feature programming would be syndicated, including the types of programming and when they would be presented.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12547 MR. MAHEU: It's our goal to have the radio station be as local and as live as possible. And that's why we committed to the amount of live programming that we have. We wanted to give you a sense of the type of music programming that we would be putting on the radio station, and sometimes there are syndicated programs that become available for this type of format that would be appropriate for the radio station to run. We have no plan at this moment on exactly what syndicated features we are going to run, but we did want to give you a sense that from time to time, we're going to run some of that programming. It's not going to be extensive, and it wouldn't be that often, but there are some great documentary syndicated programs out there, especially for oldies and oldies‑based programming. There are a number of specials on bands like the Beatles, the history of rock'n'roll and things like that that are continuing instalment documentary type of programs that run an hour or two at a time and could run for, you know, a number of weeks. On an average week ‑‑ over the course of a year on an average week, if we ran an hour and a half of syndicated programming on average a week, that would probably be a lot. We don't anticipate making use of much of that type of programming, other than for special events. There might be some things around Christmas or whatever that we would use some syndicated programming, but not very much at all.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12548 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: So could you give us a sense of what the percentage would be live programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12549 MR. MAHEU: Our proposal calls for live programming during the 6 a.m. until midnight portion of the day, Monday through Sunday. We're going to be live for those 18 hours each day, either a live announcer on the air or preproduced programming that's created on‑site by the station and broadcast at that time, and there will always be somebody in the radio station working, which we feel is important, and we're able to provide some sort of level of service and surveillance even during prerecorded programs that might have been put together by the station for broadcast at another time. So live, 6 a.m. to midnight, Monday to Sunday.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12550 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Let's move on to format, and I think I noted a comment in your presentation today. Just to clarify, according to the research, you say here, the demographic for this format is adults 35 to 64 with the strength at 45 to 64, skewing 55‑percent men, women, 45 percent. So what would be the median age of your core demographic?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12551 MR. MAHEU: The median age is 48.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12552 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: 48? Getting close ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12553 MR. MAHEU: I just entered into the target demo, but I'm not quite at the median age yet, so I'm getting close.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12554 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: All right. Looking at it in terms of the content, it's broad‑based classics format. If I go through this, it's an "oldies‑based classic hits format," quote unquote now. Can you describe to us what a typical day would sound like and give us a sense of how much is '60s, '70s, how much is '80s, '90s because at one point, I think we did describe primarily '80s and the '70s in your Supplementary Brief. So I'm not quite sure how it will work out through the day.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12555 MR. MAHEU: Sure.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12556 Well, to give you an overall sense of what the radio station would sound like during the course of an average day, this is the type of format that is very mainstream, popular broad‑based. There's no day parting involved or anything like that. It's a the same music on a 24/7 basis.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12557 And really what this format does is it takes the very best or the essence of the oldies format ‑‑ and the oldies format is rooted firmly in songs from the mid‑'60s through the late‑'70s, and it combines it with the classic hits sound from the '70s, the '80s, and the '90s.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12558 And what you end up with is a ‑‑ very much an up tempo, fun, pop‑music‑based, gold‑based format. When we're talking about music from the '60s and '70s, we're really talking about the great top 40 hits that people who are 45 to 64 grew up with, the Mammas and the Pappas, Diana Ross and The Supremes, the Temptations, The Guess Who, bands like that, and then moving into the '70s, artists like Three Dog Night and Steppenwolf and CCR and Rod Stewart, Doobie Brothers, those types of acts, really form the heart of oldies from the mid‑'60s through the mid‑'70s.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12559 But because of the way the regulations are with hit versus non‑hit on FM, it is impossible to do a format at this point in time that would be devoted just to music from the '60s and the '70s because they are ‑‑ it's all hit music that really drives this format.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12560 So we've had to modify it somewhat. If the rules changed tomorrow, for instance, and the hit/non‑hit regulation went away, the research shows pretty clearly it would be an oldies station, be '60s and '70s. And if after the radio review came out and that's what happened, then this would be a '60s and '70s radio station for the most part because that's what the folks really want. That's where the heart and strength of it is.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12561 To comply with the regulations, we brought in over 50 percent of the music coming post‑1980, and to work with music from the late ‑‑ mid to late‑'60s and the '70s, that music from the '80s and '90s is going to be very much in the mainstream pop side of classic hits, rather than the rock side of classic hits. So the radio station would sound very much like a mainstream popular music formatted radio station. The classic hits part of it, which will be about 55 percent of the radio station, will be firmly from that pop‑based classic hits genre, rather than the rock side.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12562 You might recall we were talking yesterday about Medicine Hat. Our proposal there, the classic hits portion of that format is from the rock genre side of classic hits, this one would be very much from the pop side. So a general popular music mainstream format.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12563 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Considering that, then, let me push that a little bit further and ask you why that wouldn't be the same as what is offered in the market today in terms of hot AC, AC, classic rock, AOR rock, how do you distinguish your proposal from what is currently available?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12564 MR. MAHEU: We've taken a look at what is available in the marketplace, and it's an interesting market because much of the radio, demographically targeting, tends to kind of be right ‑‑ right around that middle. Everybody is kind of converging in around the center of the popular music genres. When you listen to the radio stations in the market today and what they're programming, there's nobody in the market today programming predominantly or a good portion of their music from the '60s and '70s in the pop genre. The only radio station that comes even close from percentage terms would be JACKfm. And, well, we've done BDS analysis of every radio station in the market. We've taken a look at what they're playing, what year it comes from, and kind of give us a sense because your ears tell you one thing, and then the playlists tell you another. And the only one that's close is JACK with about 30 ‑‑ and this was an audit that was done by BDC the week of October 18th through the 24th, so it's very recent. It's last week. And 36 percent of their music comes from the '60s and the '70s. Actually, 7.3 percent from the '60s, 28.8 percent from the '70s, 36.9 percent from the '80s, 13.6 from the '90s, and 2000 until today is 13.6 percent. Those are a lot of numbers, but in terms of the era of the music, that's one thing, but the sound of the music is quite different. And it's interesting with the JACK format here in Regina, when you think of the JACK format, you immediately think classic hits because Rogers Radio has pioneered that format, and they've licensed the name throughout Canada and the United States. I don't know what the arrangement is with Rawlco, but they're using the name JACK. But it ‑‑ unlike in other marketplaces when you listen to a JACKfm radio station, it's classic hits. Here, it's very much based on classic rock or rock, and it's even marketed that way when you look at the radio station on television. So when we did the DDS monitor, we wanted to make sure that it ‑‑ you know, it was what it was, and we were right, it's a rock station for sure, it's not classic hits, but it's the only radio station in the market that comes close to playing that amount of music from the '60s and '70s. And how we're different is we're very much a popular music, top 40 oldies, '60s and '70s, where they're much more rock‑based.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12565 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Okay. So the difference as opposed to yesterday, where we used classic hits as well as a term, is that it's more rock‑based here, and yours ‑‑ classic hits would be more pop‑based?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12566 MR. MAHEU: Absolutely, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12567 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And can you see a distinction between what you're proposing and other applicants in this market that are proposing a similar format?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12568 MR. MAHEU: I think we're the only one that is really proposing the level of music from the '60s and the '70s, and I think that's what makes us different. It's what changes the targeting of the radio station slightly older as well. I also think our proposal, for the amount of spoken word in the news commitment that we're going to do on the radio station differentiates us as well. There is certainly a number of worthy applications. We just felt through the research that we did and the investigation we did in the market, and we ‑‑ we came up with this format, and I'm glad we tested this wide because everybody does research a different way, and there's always ways to have fun with numbers. But way we approach it is when we do research, we try to talk to as wide an audience as we possibly can so we don't leave very many people out. So our research was done with people between 18 and 64, so a very large group of people. We didn't just talk to 25 to 54s or older groups or younger groups, we talked to a representative why demographic 18 to 64 years‑old, and then we asked about nine different formats. We didn't ask about two or three that, you know, we kind of wish we could maybe do. We asked about country, we asked about AC, rock, pop, top 40, we did all those. And this is what came back that the marketplace felt that was missing, and that there was a significant enough interest here that you could actually build a business around it and that's the reason we came to you with this proposal because it's the one that listeners have told us, through the research, that they like the most and feel is needed the most in the marketplace. And when we look at the other stations in the market and what they're programming, the good news is that this format really doesn't impede or infringe on anybody's franchise in the market. Any time a new station comes on, there's always going to be competition and a little bit of share moving around, but this radio station format proposal does not target any one particular station in the market. So it could find its way in and maybe take a little bit of share from everybody and end up having a pretty good audience.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12569 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12570 We'll move to Canadian talent development. And I'm looking at the deficiency response of September 30th where there's a considerable discussion of the CTD contributions, as well as the earlier August 14th deficiency where there have been some changes in your proposal. So I'd like to just clarify some aspects of this. You indicated that the University of Regina will determine the criteria for distribution of scholarship funds and also the budget for funding festivals. At the time, you also indicated that funding earmarked for the university should be split evenly between scholarships and funding for festivals representing a departure from your application, which indicated 75/25 split.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12571 In your other letter of August 14th, you indicated that funding to the University of Regina would be increased twofold to 40,000 per broadcast year. So looking at all of this, do you intend the 40,000 to be split equally between scholarships and support for the university music festivals?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12572 MR. MAHEU: I'm going to have, if I may, Brad Boechler talk to you a little bit about how that money is going to be split and the reason why. We've had some excellent conversations with the folks at the university and found out a little bit more about what their needs are, and that's kind of driving what we're proposing and what we want to do.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12573 Brad, would you be kind enough to fill her in?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12574 MR. BOECHLER: Thank you, Mark.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12575 A few weeks ago ‑‑ actually, more than a few weeks ago, I had a few very good conversations with Dr. Lynn Cavanagh, who is the head of the University of Regina Department of Music. And though it looks like a beautiful facility here, and they do have a lot of very modern facilities at the university for arts and music, one of the things, as in most educational higher level institutions in Canada, they are stretched for money. When I explained to her about what our proposal was, and I am not a ‑‑ I'm not a professor of anything for that matter, but especially music, I wanted to involve her and her department in the process as much as possible.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12576 One of the things that ‑‑ and she states it quite clearly in her letter of October 5th, supporting our ‑‑ her letter of intervention supporting our application, so I won't have to go through it in great detail, but there are a couple of highlights that I'd like to point out, if I may, and the one is a financial support of the students. One of the things ‑‑ if we touch on festivals first, there is a festival currently in Regina, it's been operating for 25 years, supported by the Downtown Optimist Club of Regina. They ‑‑ another colleague of mine is one of the core organizers of this festival, and his stories back to me is it is incredibly arduous to continue to look through and for ongoing corporate sponsorship in Regina. This festival invites bands, orchestras, quartets of all genres of music from across the province to compete, normally in the spring. The two people ‑‑ Lynn Cavanagh and this fellow that organizes were fairly unaware of each other, and so when I'd suggested, because I'd met with him prior to meeting with Lynn, about the corresponding linkage between the two, both were very receptive at the idea of being able to work together for a couple of reasons. Number one, "The Regina Music Festivals," and if I may just quote this, "desperately needs serious sponsors. They feel they need a financial boost it would take to thrive economically a measure equally to the creativity of that the youngsters and their music teachers are exhibiting." Both would find a benefit because it's another ongoing way ‑‑ or another way that the University of Regina can seek out worthy scholarship applicants for their program and another way that the Optimists can grow their festival to the way ‑‑ or to the level that they expect.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12577 Another expenditure, which is also critical to them is in order to give the music festival any kind of credibility is that you need some world class adjudicators, and that's expensive because they normally come in from outside the city. The other thing in consideration with the scholarship portion to the university is ‑‑ and, again, I quote because she says it better than I could paraphrase it, if I may. She says, "It's a small wonder that a substantial number of our most talented, young musicians are attracted to music departments in other parts of Canada in the U.S., the ones that offer big scholarships to entering students in the amounts far above that of what we have in our disposal in our own department of music."
LISTNUM 95 \l 12578 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: One of the questions which we ask is, while considering what you just described, and I gather you've had considerable discussions with the University of Regina, how would you assure that the funds would be allocated in a manner that ‑‑ as you intend, so that they really meet with CTD eligible projects?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12579 MR. BOECHLER: In discussion with Dr. Cavanagh, she understands some of our requirements from a CDT point of view. Also, there are ‑‑ at the University of Regina, there are strict guidelines, if you will, on how scholarships can be awarded ‑‑ can be awarded, and she assured me that we would work with their scholarship people at that time to ensure that both are met.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12580 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Turning now to another component of your proposed CTD, which I'm looking at the August 14th, 85,000 to Saskatchewan Recording Industry Association, correct?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12581 MR. MAHEU: That is correct, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12582 MR. BOECHLER: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12583 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: And we asked you, I think, for further information on that particular ‑‑ on that particular project, and you gave us a breakdown on page 5 of the September 30th, and I believe that that breakdown would have changed with the total amount changing. You increased this initiative by $15,000 per year to a total of 85,000 per broadcast year. Can you provide us with a revised budget incorporating the $15,000‑a‑year increase?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12584 MR. MAHEU: I have it right here. We'd be happy to.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12585 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12586 And in that breakdown, you mention ‑‑ I think it's a typo, "Marketing and branding of the east coast artists." Did you mean ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12587 MR. MAHEU: I hope it's a typo. Yes, it is, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12588 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: You've earmarked in this breakdown, and I assume the revised one as well, certain funds to administration costs. Can you indicate how such an allocation would fall under eligible, direct CTD contributions? I think there are two points ‑‑ there's administration costs of of 3,500 in the established artists program, and there's administration costs 2,300 in the emerging artists program, and a programming administrative costs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12589 MR. MAHEU: Those numbers have changed, by the way, in the revised budget. The administrative costs on the established artist program is now $4,500, and the administrative costs on the emerging artists program is estimated to be $3,100 each year. I'm not exactly sure what ‑‑ what the administrative fees are made up of, but I can certainly find out and document it with ‑‑ when we supply this budget to you, the revised budget, we can itemize what we expect the administrative cost to be composed of, if that would be okay?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12590 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: We would appreciate that if you could give us some detail on each of the administrative components, and, at the same time, if you could also describe for us the costs that are earmarked to funding artist representatives, such as publicist and managers. As well, they may be integral to the program as you've described it, but we have to be sure that they really are monies going to artists in terms of CTD ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12591 MR. MAHEU: Certainly or to the direct benefit of the artist, and we'll do our homework on that and provide you the appropriate documentation that supports these amounts, and we'll do that rather quickly.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12592 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Just a comment too. I was interested in your choices for the Canadian talent development area, and considering the presence in ‑‑ in this part of the world of something like the First Nations University of Canada, I was curious to know why you had not thought of a contribution to talent development in that area?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12593 MR. MAHEU: I do believe that in our discussions with the university, you know, First Nations People are certainly part of their program, and they're endeavouring to make it an even bigger part of their program.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12594 Brad, I'm going to let you maybe chip in on that a little bit ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12595 MR. BOECHLER: Sure.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12596 MR. MAHEU: ‑‑ because that is certainly part of the essence of what we're trying to do with this money to the university.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12597 MR. BOECHLER: In both with the University of Regina and Sask Music, part of their mandate, in particular to Sask Music, is also First Nations/Aboriginal performances, so, I guess, our belief was it's already included in there.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12598 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12599 Again, on CTD. On your comments today regarding the Starmaker Fund, you say, "We will request that the fund direct our annual 90,000 contribution to Regina artists first and any excess to Saskatchewan artists." Now, do you have any formal agreement with them in writing to this effect?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12600 MR. MAHEU: Our agreement with Starmaker is similar to previous proposals to the extent which they can, and you requested us to provide a letter as to the ‑‑ to make sure that that was on the record, and we've asked them to supply us with that in writing as well for this application and the third application you'll be hearing from us. So we'll be providing that to the commission within the weeks timeframe that we promised the original one. All three letters will be in your hands.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12601 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12602 We'll move on now to some questions regarding the market and your revenue projections. One of the points we wanted to ask you to comment on was ‑‑ I'm sure you're aware of the letter from Mr. Patrick Grierson of the Canadian Broadcast Sales, CBS, contained in the intervention from Rawlco, and the comment here is the ‑‑ as he puts it, the decline in national sales revenues due to the inelastic advertising budgets, funding, significant increase, and demand in price in major markets. Would you care to comment on this as it pertains to this market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12603 MR. MAHEU: I think there is a lot of truth to what Mr. Grierson is saying, and that's the reason he said it. Regina and Saskatoon, for that matter, are not exempt from the problems that are facing markets of similar size across the country. Ad rates in places like Toronto and Vancouver and Montreal to a great degree are escalating at an accelerated pace, and national advertisers are finding it harder and harder to squeeze their budgets, so what they end up doing, is as advertising gets more expensive in some of the major centers, some of the smaller centers or medium‑sized centers are starting to get bought around or purchased less. We're finding this in markets where we operate in places like Moncton and Fredericton, Thunder Bay, Sudbury are all facing this same kind of squeeze, but the good news is that every radio broadcaster in markets this size knows that national business is really a smaller part of the revenue that we would be generating. You know, 80 percent ‑‑ in a market this size, normally about 80 percent of your revenue is going to be local retail revenue, and when you do have a contraction in national advertising, although it does hurt and doesn't give you a lot of growth prospects in that small revenue slice, it's not the end of the world. And most radio stations, and I'm sure the ones here have found new ways to generate additional incremental local revenue to make up for any shortfalls in national business. As a company ‑‑ and I'm going to let Brad talk about this just the for a second because it's important. Is that thunder? It's ‑‑ this is a trend that's probably not going to reverse itself any time soon, and I think as radio broadcasters the sooner we get used to the idea in markets, you know, of under a half a million people start unhooking any reliance we have on national sales the better because the trend is quite clear in a lot of markets this size. There is not a lot of growth in national radio advertising. Retail is going to be where it's at, and it's going to be incumbent upon us to find new revenue sources, whether it be through things we do online with the Internet to maybe supplement some of the shortfall or the declining national sales in markets like this, and, Brad, if you could speak to that just for, you know, a couple of seconds.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12604 MR. BOECHLER: Sure. As you may notice in our budget projections for the first few years, in Regina, we're only forecasting 190,000 in national sales. And as Mr. Grierson alludes to, Regina, Saskatoon, and the province of Saskatchewan are facing the same problem from a national perspective. As Mark has mentioned, we have, in the smaller markets that we deal in on a day‑to‑day basis, our emphasis is really on the retail side. That's where we're really going to make an impact. National sales, at best, is a commodity buy, and when you start to come to rely on that from a certain percentage of your budget, especially when you're not in one of the nine majors, and particularly in Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal, Calgary, Edmonton, that's ‑‑ it requires some creativity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12605 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Just if we could keep on this discussion, I think it would be very helpful. As you know, an important part of our evaluation of new radio applications is determining the impact on existing stations and asking if any should be licensed in a market without resulting undue impact on the existing stations. Now, in the year ending August 31st, 2005, we note the profitability of the Regina/Saskatchewan combined radio market was below the national average for English‑language commercial radio. Nevertheless, here we are with a number of applications. So it would be helpful if you could tell us the factors you took into consideration in determining that the Regina/Saskatoon market was capable of supporting new stations at this time. How ‑‑ I notice, for example, in your presentation today you present us with an analysis of, I think it's four markets, and numbers of people required to support a station that you're looking at, some indicators there, so perhaps you could also expand on that as an indicator.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12606 MR. MAHEU: Sure. The ‑‑ in our opening remarks when we were talking about those different markets, it was really to just illustrate markets of similar or smaller size, their capacity, to handle the amount of radio they have. And we were kind of using that to support our premise that Regina is a market that would be large enough to support additional radio services because there are a number of centers across Canada that are smaller than Regina that have just as much radio and, in some cases, more. It's been, I think, almost 25 years now since a new radio station has gone on in Regina. The amount of service here has not increased. I can't remember, but I think it was 1984 ‑‑ '82 was the last time a new radio service came to Regina. So that's quite a long period of time.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12607 There's always ‑‑ and we know this from our experience because we do operate in a number of markets, small, medium, and large. There is always a certain amount of trepidation as an incumbent broadcaster when new competition is coming in, especially when it's been a marketplace that is very comfortable and has been giving you pretty decent returns for quite a while.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12608 In the case of Regina, the economy here is ‑‑ is not Alberta, there's no question about that, and I don't think anybody is going to argue that it's ‑‑ this is like Calgary or Edmonton or even Medicine Hat, but the economy here is pretty good, and things are continuing to pick up, and people in Regina are optimistic about the future. When we did radio research in the market, we also found out there is a hole in market for a new service that people would listen to that would generate enough listening share to actually make a business. So we know that there's ‑‑ from a listeners' side, there's a need and a want for additional service. The question really comes down to, can the market and the economy in this area support additional services, and when you look at the way the market is carved up, there are two operators, both have consolidated operations. They have three stations each, and they enjoy the economies of scale that go with operating three. The proposal we put forth is rather modest in terms of our revenue needs and our goals over the first seven years. As a matter of fact, we lose a significant amount of money for the first seven years if we just execute the business plan the way it is. But the reason for it is, that we have always entered marketplaces with the long‑term view in mind. We know we're not going to get rich in Regina overnight. It's going to be hard work and a lot of heavy lifting, but we're prepared to do it because we want to be doing business in this market today, tomorrow, seven years from now and 17 years from now. So the sooner we start, the sooner we can start to enjoy some level of success after we get the hard work and the expense and the investment out of the way. We do believe that there's room in a market this size, almost 200,000 people in Regina, for a third radio operator, especially one that's willing to come in and operate at somewhat of a disadvantage against consolidated competitors. We believe that there's enough economies of scale with the existing operations and enough new business out there that will only come out of the woodwork if a new entrant comes into the market and starts knocking on additional doors, and that's not to say that Harvard and Rawlco do not do a good job generating revenue. I'm sure they do, but it just goes that when there's "a new kid on the block," quote, unquote, that's willing to go out there and knock on doors that maybe aren't being knocked on right now or come to the table with new ideas to generate radio revenue, that radio pie, that revenue pie, is going to expand, and we see that in virtually every market where new radio stations have been licensed. We're seeing it in Edmonton right now, we're seeing it in Halifax right now, we're seeing it in Ottawa right now, and we'll see it in Calgary very soon when some of these new licences go on the area. So there's more money out there for radio, but a new entrant has to be the one to go out, knock on the doors, and ask for it, and we believe we can do that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12609 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: I think that takes my last question away from me because I was going to go back to a very precise point, and that is that you have said that your format ‑‑ based on your format that your advertising revenues in year one, 35 percent would come from existing stations. So it is your view that there is potential for new advertising, going back to our discussion on the retail market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12610 MR. MAHEU: Absolutely, and, Brad, if you could just maybe interject on that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12611 MR. BOECHLER: Sure. Thanks, Mark.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12612 If we take from this day forward, by the time the decision comes down on who may be fortunate enough to come into Regina, hopefully it's us, and following FP Market's research of the market growing eight percent, and then by 23 percent by next year, within the next two years, by 2008, eight percent, we would probably be on the air some time in 2008. So by that time, the market has already expanded. Our estimate being by about another million dollars. So if you can take into consideration a million dollars and our first year budget ‑‑ for our first year target is 1.3 million, in which would be less than ten percent what we believe of the radio advertising available in the market. And just following the retail sales forward, if you take that the market will naturally expand by a million dollars, we'll take 35 percent, so call it around 350,000, and let's say for sake of argument we take it equally from Harvard and from Rawlco, that's approximately, what, 150, $160,000 per operation? So as ‑‑ by the time the licence gets on, by the time the market naturally expands and grows, our effect on the two operators currently will be minimal at best.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12613 COMMISSIONER PENNEFATHER: Thank you. Thank you very much.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12614 Those are my questions, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12615 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you. Is it Mr. Boechler?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12616 MR. BOECHLER: Yes, Madam Commissioner.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12617 THE CHAIRPERSON: Good thing you left Saskatchewan. You're far too optimistic for us. We're the glass is half empty. On page 3, I wanted to ‑‑ is Moncton an ‑‑ and excuse my ignorance, is ‑‑ aren't there two languages ‑‑ dual languages operating in that market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12618 MR. BOECHLER: Yes, there is.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12619 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And what about Saint John?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12620 MR. BOECHLER: I don't believe so.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12621 MR. MAHEU: No.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12622 THE CHAIRPERSON: Is that a totally English market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12623 MR. MAHEU: English.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12624 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And my heart did palpitate, Mr. Maheu, when we got into the COL doing a hundred percent live to air, and you then said or prerecorded. What is the difference between being prerecorded and voice tracked?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12625 MR. MAHEU: What I meant when I said prerecorded were if we were running ‑‑ it was, I think, in reference to some of those syndicated programs that from time to time we might run on the radio station. We consider that to be prerecorded, so it's going to run. We're not going to do any voice tracking on the radio station between six in the morning and midnight. It's going to be live or live to air. In other words, if the programming that is on the air is being run on a prerecorded basis because we're running the Beatles documentary called Day in a Life or whatever, there's still going to be somebody in the studio that when the commercial breaks come on, they're going to be able to tell you about the weather forecast and what's going on around town and then back to the show. So we're going to have somebody on the air, in the studio on a 6 a.m. to midnight, seven‑day‑a‑week basis, no voice tracking.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12626 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So just so it's on the record so that it ‑‑ prerecorded means syndicated programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12627 MR. MAHEU: Yeah, it could be programming that was created inside the radio station as well. You know, the morning team if they're doing ‑‑ if we develop a program where the morning team is doing some sort of Saturday night oldies show that runs for a couple of hours and might have them introducing songs and doing bits from the morning show throughout the week, that might run on a prerecorded basis on Saturday night at 9:00, but there's still somebody in the studio providing live service, live surveillance, between commercial breaks when that program is running, but it's station‑produced programming for the most part.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12628 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, thank you. And now I have remembered. It is your time to tell us why we should licence you in the pearl of the prairies, Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12629 MR. MAHEU: We know you have many people that want to come up here and take the valuable time, so we won't take very long.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12630 Thank you for the opportunity to present ‑‑ for us to be able to present our idea for a new radio station in Regina. It's been a long time since Regina has had a new listening option, 1982 was the last time there was a new radio station in the city.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12631 The operators here are good operators. Rawlco and Harvard are responsible, they're professional, and they do an excellent job. Having said that, we do believe that listeners in Regina deserve an extra choice. We believe that the economic data supports a robust economy to the point that a new, modest radio entrant would be viable in the marketplace and have a minimum impact on the incumbent broadcasters to the benefit of everyone: Advertisers have another choice to look at for radio, a new entrant like Newcap will help expand the radio pie. We're prepared to bring our money to the table, a million and a half dollars over seven years for the development of Canadian talent, the programs with the university and SRIA are important, and will pay dividends in the long run.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12632 This is a new market for us in a new province. We're not doing business here right now, and we would very much like the opportunity to do so. And if we're awarded the licence we'll do it in the usual Newcap manner in a forthright and professional way. And thank you for your time and attention, and we hope we have that opportunity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12633 Thank you again.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12634 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12635 I hate to say we'll take five minutes. Does anybody wish to or ‑‑ no? Then we will simply be silent until the next applicant is seated.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12636 Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12637 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12638 I would now call on the next applicant, Standard Radio Inc. to come forward to the presentation table.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12639 We will now proceed with item 11 on the agenda, which is an application by Standard Radio Inc. for a licence to operate an English‑language commercial FM radio programming undertaking in Regina. Maybe I'll just give you a few minutes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12640 THE CHAIRPERSON: I think, Madam Secretary, we have to wait for Mrs. Taylor and I think a few more other panelists. Maybe we should take ten minutes. Like, is Ms Taylor supposed to be with you?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12641 MS MITCHELL: She is. She's just taking a quick break for the washroom. She'll be back in one moment.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12642 THE CHAIRPERSON: In one moment? Okay, we'll wait.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12643 HEARING SECRETARY: Okay. We'll start this again. Okay. We'll start this again. We're going to proceed with item 11 on the agenda, which is an application by Standard Radio Inc. for a licence to operate an English‑language commercial FM radio programming undertaking in Regina. The new station would operate on frequency 92.7 megahertz (channel 224C1) with an effective radiated power of 100,000 watts (non‑directional antenna/antenna height of 146.2 metres).
LISTNUM 95 \l 12644 Appearing for the applicant is Ms Sharon Taylor who will introduce her colleagues. You will then have 20 minutes for your presentation. Please go ahead.
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12645 MS TAYLOR: Thank you very much. My apologies for my quick bathroom break.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12646 Good afternoon, Chair Cram, Members of the Commission, my name is Sharon Taylor, and I am the VP and the GM of Standard Radio Manitoba. I oversee two FM radio stations in Winnipeg. Hot 103, which is a CHR, and QX104, a new country. As well, I'm also responsible for Standard Radio's two FM stations in Brandon, Manitoba, pardon me, 101.1 FM, the Farm, and a new country station, and KX96, a rock station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12647 It certainly my pleasure to be back in Saskatchewan. I was a market manager here in Regina just a few years ago, and early in my career, I was a program director at CHAB in Moose Jaw.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12648 Before we begin, I would like to introduce to you the members of our team, all of whom have played a key role in developing our application. To my right, Diane Morris, director of finances for western Canada; to my left, Norine Mitchell, our retail sales manager in Brandon, Manitoba; to Norine's left, Janet Trecarten. Janet is currently the program director of our country music station in Winnipeg, QX104 FM, and will be our general manager at Country 92 Regina, should you award us this licence. Directly behind me, Leah Singleton. Leah is one of our department heads in Winnipeg and the traffic manager for our Manitoba cluster. Today, she is with us in her capacity as an Aboriginal advisor for this application. To Leah's right is Betty Selin, regional news director for Standard Radio. Betty is in Vernon, BC. She is also the recent winner of the Jack Webster Fellowship, and last year, she won an RTNDA award for best small market newscast. To Leah's left is Tom Tompkins. Tom is a veteran of the Canadian country music scene, a past president of the Canadian Country Music Association, and our Canadian country music consultant. Another way to figure out who Tom is to look for the one that's not like the others.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12649 MS TAYLOR: Beside Tom is Janet Lazaris. Janet is the principal of the Research Strategy Group in Toronto, and she handled our research. That is our Standard Radio team.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12650 We are very pleased to be here today to apply for an FM country music station for Regina. This radio station, which we will call Country 92 FM during our presentation ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12651 THE CHAIRPERSON: Ms Taylor...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12652 MS TAYLOR: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12653 THE CHAIRPERSON: We rushed you. Would you like to take five minutes?
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12654 MS TAYLOR: We're fine.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12655 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12656 MS TAYLOR: I actually did run.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12657 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yeah, take a minute anyway and get your breath.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12658 MS TAYLOR: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12659 This radio station, which we will call Country 92 FM during our presentation today will play contemporary country or new country music featuring some of Canada's and Saskatchewan's great country music stars. Most importantly, Country 92 will play this music on FM allowing country music fans in Regina to hear their favourite music as it was intended to be heard, in crystal clear stereo and originating with pride from a radio station within their own community.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12660 Perhaps one of the most surprising things about Regina is the recent strength of the economy. The economic growth rate here has outpaced the national average for three years in a row. The service sector grew by 3.6 percent, the population is slightly up as are housing starts. Household income is two percent above the national average, and it's expected to increase 22 percent over the next five years. Another key indicator, consumer spending, it's strong. Retail sales in 2005 grew by almost 11 percent, and you can count on continued spending growth with last Friday's announcement that the Finance Minister chopped two percentage points off the PST. This surprising and welcome announcement was made possible, in his words, "Because the Saskatchewan economy is red hot right now." This ordinarily stable province is poised to experience inordinate growth, and we're very enthusiastic about the potential of contributing in all areas to the opportunities that are unfolding here.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12661 The Commission has been supplied with lots of statistics and information for these hearings. We ask that you consider one more additional point that we feel is highly relevant to the issue of whether the market can support another radio operator. When CRTC reported radio sales across the country are compared to population, and then the provinces are ranked on per capita radio sales, Saskatchewan is the province that comes out on top, number one, with only 34 radio stations, this is clearly not an overradioed province or market. In Canada, Regina is the city with the highest per capita radio sales with only six radio stations in the market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12662 Radio operators in this city are profitable and comfortable. The notion that licensing another broadcaster in the market will only thin existing revenues resulting in cutbacks of local services is not one that we subscribe to.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12663 As you know, Standard Radio is a family‑owned and operated business and a leading Canadian broadcast company. We have a well‑known track record of serving the communities we operate in, and an almost legendary reputation and commitment to the Canadian Music Industry. With 51 radio stations in seven provinces in markets small, medium, and large, Standard Radio truly understands the importance of local radio service.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12664 While some of our radio stations are located in major markets, like Montreal and Toronto, the majority of Standard's radio stations are in western Canada. In fact, Allan Slate(ph) learned some of his earliest radio lessons right here in Saskatchewan, as a news reporter and announcer at CHAB Moose Jaw before he moved on to Edmonton.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12665 In preparing our application for Country 92 FM, Standard listened to the needs expressed by the many members of the Regina community. We closely analyzed the Regina economy, and we commissioned research to accurately pinpoint what is currently missing, if anything, from the radio landscape.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12666 To highlight our research findings, Janet Lazaris of Research Strategy Group.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12667 MS LAZARIS: The purpose of our study was to help Standard Radio identify the most appropriate format for their plans to serve the Regina radio market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12668 First, our studies showed that there is a viable business opportunity for two different FM formats in Regina, a modern rock format, and a new country format. Both would attract a significant audience, each with a very distinct profile. Of the two formats, Standard chose the new country FM option for the following reasons: First, diversity. There is currently no country music format on FM in Regina. A large proportion of potential listeners to Country 92 FM, 45 percent, currently identified an out‑of‑market FM station as their favourite station. Country music fans in Regina also top the category for spending time with non‑traditional radio services. 42 percent reported listening to music from satellite radio, Internet radio, or a digital music channel in the past week, not so hard to imagine when there is no local service.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12669 Based on the results of the study, it became clear that the addition of an FM country format to the Regina radio landscape would cause minimal ratings hardship to the incumbent broadcasters, none of whom program country music on FM.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12670 Secondly, a new country format would draw a large and saleable audience. Fully 45 percent of the 18‑plus audience indicated that they would be either very likely or somewhat likely to tune the new country format. Based on the favourite station response, we would project that new country FM format has the potential to gain an eight‑percent share of the listening among 18‑plus adults in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12671 All in all, the research indicates that Standard's new country format would be viable with a high degree of diversity that would strengthen the local radio market and would be a welcome addition to the media landscape by both listeners and the advertisers who would like to appeal to these consumers.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12672 MS TAYLOR: Thank you, Janet.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12673 Country 92 FM Regina will feature artists that just don't get airplay on FM radio in Regina. We will be featuring many of the Canadian artists that Standard Radio supports across the country. To further illustrate we've prepared this brief audio presentation for you.
‑‑‑ Audio Clip / Clip audio
LISTNUM 95 \l 12674 MR. TOMPKINS: Regina's Country 92 FM will play artists like Toby Keith, Alan Jackson, Martina McBride, Kenny Chesney, and Keith Urban, as well as established Canadian acts like Terri Clark, Shania Twain, Brad Johner, the Wilkinsons, and Paul Brandt. We'll have a strong focus on new and emerging Canadian artists like the Coreblund Band, the Road Hammers, Johnny Reid, and local acts such as the Poverty Plainsmen and Shane Yellowbird, as well as the annual winner of our Country 92 FM talent contest.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12675 Country 92 FM will play a variety of country artists, none of them presently heard on FM in Regina. With the existence of an FM country music station, Canadian country music stars will be able to have their fans hear their music the way it was intended, in FM stereo.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12676 Janet Trecarten, our general manager, has a few comments regarding the programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12677 MS TRECARTEN: The country music format on FM is one of the most consistently successful radio formats in Canada. No longer a niche format, country music is now a mass appeal blockbuster. Country music stations on FM have consistently strong audience ratings in markets across all of Canada, but they are particularly popular in western Canada.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12678 To frame our position that Regina needs and deserves an FM country music radio station, Regina is the largest western Canadian city currently without one.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12679 Standard Radio owns and operates successful country radio stations on AM and FM in both small and large markets. Our expertise and success in this format, as well as our passion for the music and the artists who make it, will help ensure a successful and popular radio station for both advertisers in Regina and Canadian country artists.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12680 At Standard Radio, we compare playlists frequently with other liked formatted stations in our team, so if a local artist is successful in Regina, we can provide that opportunity to take their exposure from a regional to a national level. With this proactive approach to nurturing and exposing Canadian talent and our commitment to establish Canadian superstars, in this format, reaching and maintaining 40‑percent Canadian content, including 40 percent 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday to Friday will be very manageable.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12681 New and emerging country artists will be given an enormous boost on Country 92 FM. One in ten songs played on our radio station will be from a new and emerging Canadian artist, that's ten percent of the songs that we'll air.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12682 MS MITCHELL: As Sharon noted earlier, Saskatchewan is growing. Private companies across Canada and around the world are voting thumbs up on Saskatchewan as a place to do business. And as the capital city, Regina is poised to be a key benefactor in this current and future growth.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12683 In the past year, record job numbers have been posted in this province, and, with that, comes record retail spending. The general manager of Regina's largest mall, the Cornwall Centre, sees his mall's retail spending up ten percent over last year with no let‑up in sight, and that was before the provincial sales tax cut.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12684 I've met with key advertisers in Regina, many of them radio users with a long and strong relationship with the existing broadcasters. Many advertisers, even some who signed the incumbent's petition were anxious to find out more about our application. They were unclear on what was being proposed for this licence, and once I presented our plans for Country 92 FM, I was truly met with enthusiastic report.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12685 Cow Town, a major retailer who has a long and successful relationship with using radio, stated that if they had known a country FM station was possible, they would have reconsidered supporting the petition. The Country 92 FM audience is one he would very much like to reach.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12686 The owner of the Keg Restaurant stated that in comparison to other markets he does business in, he finds Regina to be underserviced and sees the benefit of a proposed radio station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12687 The owner of Wendy's restaurants was very excited about the possibility of having a Standard Radio station in the market, as he has dealt with us, with our company, in other markets and respects our integrity and the positive influence we bring to the communities that we do serve.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12688 Finally, I spoke with Ashley Furniture, the most recent big‑box furniture that opened in Regina. He agreed that he would use a country FM station if it were available in this market, and he did base his comment on his experience doing business in other markets with Standard's new country format and the valuable audience it delivers.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12689 Regina is open for business and growing. Standard Radio has a plan to work hand in hand with advertisers and the community to be part of and contribute to that growth.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12690 MS SELIN: Our application not only offers an opportunity for diversity in the Regina market, but it also brings a fresh new editorial voice to the region. We plan to air 30 live newscasts per work week. Our news center will provide road conditions, community information, sports, and weather. We'll have reporters covering community meetings and events and a website that will be truly interactive bringing our listeners the information they want any time they want it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12691 Ten percent of our workweek will be spoken word programming. We're very proud of our community news magazine program set to air each Sunday, designed specifically for those who don't currently have a voice in mainstream media, in particular, the Aboriginal community.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12692 By awarding this new licence for Country 92 FM in Regina, the Commission will be giving radio listeners a fresh new news option. It also helps strengthen our Standard Radio news centers across the country by adding a new Saskatchewan component. We look forward to sharing our passion for broadcasting with the residents and businesses of the region.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12693 It's our belief the strongest option for bringing diversity to the Regina market is that of Standard Radio.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12694 To further explain our special Sunday news magazine program and our Aboriginal initiatives, Leah Singleton.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12695 MS SINGLETON: Many Aboriginal people do not have a voice in the mainstream media in the city, yet Regina ranks second in the country in Aboriginal population per capita. In fact, by the year 2050, it is estimated that half of Saskatchewan's population will be Aboriginal, today at 17 percent. Needless to say, this year and every year for the next 44 years and onward, this city and this province will undergo terrific change. It promises to be a challenging time.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12696 Our Sunday morning news magazine program will address this change and the issues that effect the large and growing First Nations community. We will cover Band issues that relate to all Aboriginal people in the Regina region, and the weekly topics will range from local events to national events of the Grand Chief Council.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12697 Discussions ranging from Canada's Aboriginal Day, voting procedures for local Band councils, and the latest developments for survivors of residential schools will be aired weekly. Native youth programs, such as youth leadership employment programs, health and family issues will also be on our agenda. We'll plan on inviting Native Elders to advise youth through interviews in their Native languages, helping young people retain a sense of their history.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12698 As part of our Canadian talent development program, we will recruit and train Aboriginal stringers to provide local and relevant content for the show. And we have earmarked $15,000 yearly for this initiative.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12699 Additionally, we will guarantee a $10,000 annual bursary at First Nations University, which is located on the University of Regina campus. This yearly contribution will underwrite two aspiring Aboriginal broadcast journalists, as they participate in the two‑year program.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12700 Finally, Standard Radio has been a lot ‑‑ has long been a supporter of Aboriginal Voices Radio, and, again, we have an agreement with them. They will produce programming that can and will be included on our weekly news magazine program in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12701 Many people I spoke with were very excited about this new opportunity to connect, not just within the Aboriginal community, but the greater community of Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12702 MR. TOMPKINS: Our Canadian talent development program also includes some very unique artist and music concepts for the Regina community. First is the Shine On Saskatchewan Talent Search. Each year, $30,000 will be devoted to this initiative, including a cash prize of $10,000 and a special showcase to introduce our winner to influential people in the music business.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12703 Standard will also direct $25,000 per year toward the Saskatchewan Recording Industry Association or Sask Music of which it is now known.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12704 This province is home to a fantastic organization that we can't wait to support. The Saskatchewan Music Educators Association. We are now pledging $25,000 per year to assist with two very worthwhile programs that they administrate. The first is the Provincial Honours Group. Children from grades 8 to 12 are teamed together with professional musicians, and, together, they put on a gala concert. Two of the past students include last years runner up on Canadian Idol, Theresa Sokyrka, and this year's third‑place finisher on Canadian Idol, Tyler Lewis.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12705 The other program is the Heart of the City Piano Project. There are 11 intercity schools in Regina where volunteer musicians visit to play and speak to the kids about music. The goal is to convince kids to take up an instrument, and in doing so, help keep them interested in staying in school. Free instruments and lessons are part of this very successful program.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12706 Standard Radio will continue to support FACTOR with a donation of $20,000 per year, and we have discussed keeping as much of that money as possible, up to 50 percent, here in Saskatchewan. We will also direct $10,000 annually to Canadian Music Week, and those funds will underwrite Saskatchewan artists showcasing during the annual conference.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12707 Standard Radio will continue its support of the Starmaker Program with an annual cash donation of $10,000, and, finally, we will make a yearly $5,000 donation available to the Canadian Country Music Association.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12708 MS TAYLOR: Our Canadian talent development program also includes three non‑cash benefit programs. These include Standard's well‑known national free ad plan, which runs commercials promoting new Canadian CDs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12709 Standard Cares, our national program assisting local children's hospitals and our national public service announcement program, which has Standard radio stations airing public service announcements every hour.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12710 In total, Standard Radio will dedicate $150,000 in cash each year or $1,050,000 cash total over the seven‑year term.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12711 With our $875,000 in‑kind programs, our total Canadian talent development package is almost $2 million over the term of the licence.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12712 In summary, we've presented what we consider to be a well‑thought out and strong application for a new and unique FM radio station for Regina. The key highlights of our application are as follows: Research that shows that Regina wants, needs, and can support a country music station on FM, a new independent editorial voice with national connections, 40 percent Canadian content, including 40 percent 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday to Friday, a benefits package of $1,050,000 in cash over the licence term, as well as indirect Canadian talent development benefits of another $875,000, nearly two million in cash and in kind over the licence term, 20 new jobs, and almost 10 million in investment over the term of the licence, a partnership with Aboriginal Voices Radio that will be part of our news and magazine coverage to the area, a realistic and achievable business plan.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12713 We feel our application brings diversity to Regina with an exclusive format, country music on FM, and a new editorial voice. We know that the Commission is well aware of the commitment of Standard Radio, which starts at the very top of our organization to assisting in and being part of growing Canadian talent. It is both a pride point and the hallmark of our company.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12714 This concludes our presentation, we appreciate the opportunity to answer any questions, and thank you for suffering through my introductions.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12715 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12716 Commissioner Cugini...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12717 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Good afternoon, ladies, lone gentleman. Ms Taylor, you're right. We don't get to say that very often.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12718 I want to start the questioning with the appeal and demand of your format. One of the things that you say in your application is that you will have a minimal impact on Harvard Broadcasting, on CKRM. Other than CKRM being available on AM, and if your application is licensed you'll be available on FM, what other differences will the listener hear in these two radio stations?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12719 MS TAYLOR: The major difference that you will hear between CKRM, which is the existing AM heritage country station and our proposed new country station is the amount of music ‑‑ the amount of Canadian music that you will hear. We will be playing approximately twice as much music as the AM station does, which means twice as much Canadian content. We found ‑‑ I found in my experience in a number of markets that AM country heritage stations, their appeal goes far beyond the music that they play. The music that they play is an important part of their programming, but, really, one of very many important parts of their programming. For example, most AM country stations offer a full service. They carry sports play by play, they may carry religious programming, they may carry talk shows during the midday. They really are a much broader service to their community than simply the actual music that they play.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12720 In some markets the most recent and perhaps the most intimate example for us would be in Brandon, Manitoba. We operate two FM radio stations there. There are also two other FM stations in the market ‑‑ or two other stations in the market. One is an AM country station. We decided to change the format of one of our FMs to a new country format. In doing so, the AM station, I don't believe ‑‑ just let me check on my notes here. I don't believe that the AM station lost any ratings to us. Yeah, we changed in early‑2005. In the fall of 2004 prior to our coming on the air as a country station, they had a 30 share. The following fall, they still had a 29.4 share. And I offer this as to proof that these listeners are coming to this station for much more than just the country music that they are offering, and we found that in a number of other markets as well. We operate CHAM in Hamilton. There is an FM country station there. While our ratings at CHAM may not be what we want them to be, we don't feel that they have been negatively influenced by the FM country station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12721 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Is there a difference in the target demo of the two stations?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12722 MS TAYLOR: Yes, there would be.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12723 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And what would that be? What's CKRM's ‑‑ if you had to assess what their target demo is, what would that be, and what is your target demo for this proposal?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12724 MS TAYLOR: Our broad demo would be 25 to 64. Our bulge, our narrow demographic, would be 35 to 54 with a median age of about 40. I can't tell you specifically about CKRM's audience, but I find that traditionally the audiences attracted to AM country stations are older. I would hazard to guess that the bulge of their audience would be somewhere in the 50‑plus demographic.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12725 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: You do talk in your application about your experience in Manitoba, in Brandon, and what happened there? Why are you confident that that can be paralleled in this market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12726 MS TAYLOR: I see the situations as being very, very similar. They are both heritage stations, they've been in the market offering the type of programming for many, many years, they are ‑‑ they have important services that the community clearly responds to that are non‑musical, and it's just been my experience ‑‑ as well in Toronto when KISS FM launched on the air as a country station, a new country station, there was an existing AM country station that did not suffer audience loss as a result of the FM country station coming on the air. There were clearly problems with running an AM music station, especially ‑‑ this is going back a few years now, but I find that the AM country music stations are offering a much bigger package to their listeners than just the music.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12727 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: You also talk in your application about being able to repatriate listeners who were currently tuning in to CKCK from Moose Jaw. Again, what factors have you taken into consideration to give you the confidence to say that you'll be able to repatriate some of those listeners from Moose Jaw?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12728 MS TAYLOR: I think I'll ask Janet to ‑‑ I'd like to ask Janet to address the specifics of what the research found for us there, but, generally speaking, when there is ‑‑ country music fans are country music fans.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12729 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Yes. We've also been hearing they're quite loyal to the stations that they listen to.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12730 MS TAYLOR: They are very loyal to the stations that they listen to. That said, the biggest difference, I believe, between Country 92 Regina and the Moose Jaw FM station will be the spoken word. The Moose Jaw radio station services their community very well, but that's the Moose Jaw and surrounding community. They don't service Regina. That's not their mandate. We will be servicing the Regina community, and our spoken word will be about what's going on in our market that our listeners will respond to. So when you have people whose prime music interest is country music, and it's not available in your market, you will go elsewhere to get your fix, whether it is to an out‑of‑market station, whether it is to satellite radio, whether ‑‑ very popular here as well is the digital music channels. I believe that those listeners that are elsewhere picking up their country music will be thrilled, not just to hear country music on FM in Regina, but to hear it, as we said in our presentation, originating from their community with pride. But I'll ask Janet to, perhaps, expand on some of the research numbers.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12731 MS LAZARIS: Okay. That finding does come from the research and from an analysis that we do of the people who say that the new country format would become their favourite station, which is the proxy measure for share. We look at what station is currently their favourite, and fully 45 percent of them name CIGL‑FM as their current favourite station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12732 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Okay. One more question with regards to your target audience and your demo. You ‑‑ as part of your deficiency response, you stated that your format would appeal equally to female and male. Are you really talking about a 50/50 split between female and male?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12733 MS TAYLOR: We're talking pretty close. Traditionally, and I'm going back 15‑plus years, we used to say 60/40. Now, I'm finding that it is pretty much 50/50. It might be a few percentage points skewing female over male, but to not put too fine a point on it, it's pretty close to 50/50 generally.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12734 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: At the median age of 40 ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12735 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12736 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: ‑‑ for both?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12737 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12738 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Okay, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12739 I'm now going to move on to your spoken word commitment, which, of course, you were just speaking about. On page 14 of your Supplementary Brief, you state that, "Approval of your application will provide an opportunity to improve the diversity of editorial voices in the region and in Regina." And you say that, "Approval would be supporting an important expansion of a local news service at a time when other news voices are being consolidated." Your commitment to scheduled news, weather, sports, spoken word per week is two hours. And programming, that will be restricted to the morning period only. Am I correct in that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12740 MS TAYLOR: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12741 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: So I'm wondering if you could reconcile this very strong statement about commitment to local programming and local news with a commitment of two hours of scheduled news, weather, and sports, spoken word programming per week that will be restricted to the morning periods only.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12742 MS TAYLOR: Yes, I'm going to ask Betty to expand on just a couple of comments I'd like to make.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12743 First of all, in our application, the ‑‑ I believe that we did not include our news magazine program, and we did not include, perhaps, the ‑‑ well, I'll get Betty to run down the numbers for you. I'm not ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12744 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: I just want to focus for the moment on this news, weather, and sports. And you do say in your application that 70 percent of those two hours will have a focus on local news stories. I'm just curious as to why you wouldn't plan on doing news in any ‑‑ during any other time of the day, other than the morning?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12745 MS TAYLOR: First of all, Betty would tell you that she would like to do news all day long, and I appreciate that, especially coming from someone like her who lives and breathes news and doing what she can to service the community. The ‑‑ one of the reasons that we structured our news service this way is we will acknowledge that there is two AM stations in the market doing an excellent job of covering news and other surveillance. I think that Regina is fortunate to have a news talk radio station that does an excellent job, and, also, as we discussed, CKRM also does an excellent job. On FM in the market currently, I don't believe that there is an awful lot of news past the morning show newscast currently in the market. So, certainly, we are going to participate like we do with all of our radio stations in providing as much news and information in the morning when our listeners are looking for that, but not planning on scheduling newscasts in the afternoon.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12746 I'll get Betty to expand a little bit on our thinking behind that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12747 MS SELIN: Thanks, Sharon. First of all, I just wanted to clarify our numbers. You're correct in that we have just over two hours of news through the week, but in addition to that, we understand how important weather is in a province like this. We have an additional two hours of weather and then our road reports are over and above that in addition for another 45 minutes, so our total spoken news and information package component would be five hours and 46 minutes broken down in those ways.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12748 But even I have come to realize that people get their news in many different ways, and it's certainly changing from the traditional radio model that I grew up in. And we are going to focus being a traditional radio station in the morning, giving people news when they need it when they're busy getting their families out the door on the way to work, and we will have news at both the top and bottom of the hour on the morning drive, but then we will certainly focus on updating our website throughout the day because we've come to realize that people certainly use that as a resource, check it when they get to work, check before they go home from work. We bring the strength of the Standard Radio news centers across the country to this market, so that's one of the ways that we think that we are bringing something new to offer, this new editorial voice. We also will have the availability of a reporter in the building, as well as announcers in the building. Should breaking news happen, we will, you know, break into regular programming and let our listeners know what's going on. But as far as the traditional, as Sharon mentioned, we think that the incumbents are doing a good job, and we really want to set ourselves apart from that in the music‑concentrated format.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12749 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: One of the things you also say about your newscasts in that they will be different is because it will rely on actively involving the public and encourage the listeners in the communities you will serve to help drive local reflection. What do you mean by these statements, and how exactly are you going to involve the community?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12750 MS SELIN: Well, one of the ways that we'll involve the community is just in our daily news packages. Our reporters will spend a great deal of the time covering meetings, on the phone, allowing the people within the community to tell the story, and we really ‑‑ that's the tradition at Standard Radio. The newsmaker tells the story, not the announcer reading all the information.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12751 The other way that we will do it is through our Sunday news magazine, the special one‑hour program that we'll air each Sunday morning, and Leah has certainly done a lot of work for us in making connections and already developing some partnerships within the Aboriginal community. We hear from them that they don't feel that their voice is being properly reflected currently, and they're very excited about that opportunity. So based on the substantive population of First Nations within this region, we really felt that this was an important way to go.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12752 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: But in terms of involving the community and encouraging listeners to help you drive local reflection, what is the mechanism that you're going to put in place to encourage this kind of participation? Is it going to be through your website, is it going to be through your airwaves, is it ‑‑ what are you go going to do before you actually launch, for example, before you have a voice in the market to let these community leaders or, you know, community people in the community know that that's what you're looking for from them?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12753 MS SELIN: Certainly we do them in all of those ways. Now, we encourage people to call our news hotlines with news tips. It will be available on our website. They will be able to contact us if they have a message they want to get out, and, of course, through our community announcements. Standard Radio has a long reputation of involving the community through those messages of getting their community service announcements out as well.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12754 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Okay. You touched upon the Sunday news magazine, which will be an hour a week?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12755 MS SELIN: That's right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12756 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And along with discussing and airing issues of the day, community events, you did also add that this would be dialogued particular to the Aboriginal and multi‑cultural communities in Regina. So to what extent do you think your new country format would attract listeners from these two communities and numbers to make this type of programming both viable and compatible with your format?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12757 MS TAYLOR: Could you restate that for me just a little bit so I understand?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12758 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: In other words, you have an Aboriginal community in Regina, we've heard that, and there are multi‑cultural communities. What is it about your format, in particular, that is going to attract these two communities to your listeners ‑‑ these two communities to your radio station as listeners?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12759 MS TAYLOR: I think we have a number of different ways. I don't think that our musical format holds an edge per se. I think that there are elements of the new country format, whether they be the roots‑based elements inside the music that may have some attraction, but I don't think the actual musical format will give us any kind of inside track on that. I think it's just a ‑‑ you know, we look at what we feel are the needs of the community, and then we go about best trying to fill those needs. One of the needs that we feel is very strong in Saskatchewan is, of course, Aboriginal and First Nations concerns. The population, as everyone who lives here is aware, is growing, and that brings with it many challenges, not just today and tomorrow, but down the road, whether it's integrating into our industry, into the workforces, whatever. I think that this is just a fresh start for us to acknowledge that these issues are out there, that we're open, that we are looking to dialogue with these groups that may or may not currently have a voice in the mainstream media. We have set aside our news magazine program on Sundays that we're very excited about as being a real point of difference in our news coverage and the way that we handle the issues, not just of Aboriginal peoples in the area, but as you suggest, the other special interest groups that are looking for exposure, recognition, and a chance to greater communicate their issues and needs, not just within their own community, but the Regina community as well.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12760 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Thank you for that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12761 I noted that in relation to your Sunday morning news magazine programming, one of your proposed CTD initiatives is an allocation of $15,000 per year to pay stringers from both the Aboriginal and multi‑cultural communities to provide content for this program. Could you elaborate a little bit on how this will work?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12762 MS TAYLOR: I'd like Betty to address that for us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12763 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Sure.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12764 MS SELIN: Thank you, Sharon.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12765 While, of course, the news director will be ultimately responsible for the program, it's been my experience that getting into some of these communities is very difficult as a reporter, and so we felt ‑‑ especially with the advantage of having the university here with a broadcast program, this would be a perfect opportunity to get some of these people who are eager to join our industry and give them an opportunity to practice the skills that they're learning at university. So it's our intention that these stringers would probably be broadcast students, and we would give them an opportunity to put together programming, because while it will be on Sunday morning, it won't be live programming. I mean, Sunday morning live programming is a bit of a challenge, so this will be an opportunity for them to practice their skills in a prerecorded format and put something that they can be very proud of together, so we felt that this was an opportunity to take.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12766 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: It could almost be characterized as a paid internship?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12767 MS SELIN: Absolutely. That's a great way to look at it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12768 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Okay ‑‑ sorry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12769 MS TAYLOR: I would just like to add a point to that. Leah and I were recently at an Aboriginal awareness seminar, and I think that one of the other points of difference that our Aboriginal stringer program will bring is that there is an enormous difference between reporting on what's going on in these communities and actually employing people from within the communities. There's just a different point of view, there's, perhaps, a more intimate relationship with the issues at hand, and we think that, as well, will make a big difference in the overall sound of what we're doing, and, in fact, the issues that we're discussing.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12770 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Now, because you listed this initiative as a CTD, it may or may not be eligible under our current guidelines. If we deem that it is ineligible, will you still expend this $15,000 a year on the stringers?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12771 MS TAYLOR: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12772 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Okay. You talked about, in your application, page 2 of our Supplementary Brief in particular, to available programming synergies with other Standard stations in the areas of local reflection as well as regional, national, and international news. You say that approval of your application would allow Standard to draw on our expertise from other radio stations in the Standard chain, creating more opportunities for synergies within our broadcast group. What type of programming synergies are you referring to in those statements?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12773 MS TAYLOR: Betty will speak to that, but I will tell you that what we generally mean in that instance is that we have lots of experience in our news centers across the country of reacting to needs within the community. We'll be drawing on that expertise for community issues here at home, and Betty can elaborate for us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12774 MS SELIN: Perhaps one of the best examples would be recently during the tragedy in Montreal where many stations were using the reports coming from Broadcast News and our Standard Radio stations. We had a Standard Radio reporter on the scene, so that brought a different editorial look at that very same story; whereas, most of the other stations in any given market were using the Broadcast News version of what happened there; whereas, we had our own reporter. So if you flip back and forth between two stations, you'll hear two different stories. I'm sure, basically, the same facts would be there, but just a different voice, which we think is important.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12775 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: So what I'm hearing based on what we discussed earlier, and that is that 70 percent of your news will be local and that 30 percent may be made up of national, international or ‑‑ and/or news stories from other Standard Radio stations from across the country?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12776 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12777 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: One last question on the 70 percent. Is that a daily commitment or a weekly commitment?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12778 MS TAYLOR: I would say it's both. I mean, it will probably be much greater than 70 percent. Our intent is to serve the community locally, but to put a number on it, 70 sounds fair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12779 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: On a weekly basis?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12780 MS TAYLOR: Yes. It depends, of course, on the issues and what's going on, but it would certainly never be less than that, and hopefully much more.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12781 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: I'd like to move on now to CTD, and I do need to go back to your original application because I don't believe I heard everything in your presentation that was included in your original application in terms of organizations to which CTD money would be directed. We have Shine on Saskatchewan Talent Search at $30,000 a year. What I didn't hear is the First Nations University of Canada bursary program, which was originally proposed in your application at $10,000. Full tuition funding of one Aboriginal student to study journalism and communication arts program, and I didn't hear that in your presentation.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12782 MS TAYLOR: That is the First Nations ‑‑ it might be just the way that we've not used the same words in each ‑‑ that's the First Nations university located at the U of R campus that we referenced in our oral.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12783 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12784 MS TAYLOR: And that's on the top of page 8 in our oral.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12785 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Thank you very much, my mistake. It's good to have these things clarified.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12786 MS TAYLOR: It's good to have page numbers.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12787 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: The Northern Alberta Institute of Technology, you're proposing annual $10,000 scholarships to assist two Aboriginal students to attend a two‑year journalism program at the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology. Can you provide us with more specific information related to this course in the sense of what kind of skills training this provides, and is it a component of the two‑year broadcasting diploma course, or is it a separate full‑time journalism course that is provided?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12788 MS TAYLOR: We did revise that. We ‑‑ after discussions with the First Nations University at the U of R campus, we discovered that a bursary program of $10,000 would underwrite two journalists, two Aboriginal journalism students throughout their program, so we advised the ‑‑ I believe it was NAIT that we referenced in our original application. Instead, we're ‑‑ the money is going to the U of R to the First Nations program.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12789 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And was that revised just today, or did you revise that in a deficiency letter to the Commission?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12790 MS TAYLOR: When we originally set down the parameters of the application, that was included in that. It was not revised in deficiency. It was after we spent a great deal of time in the market discussing our initiatives, discussing the Sunday morning news magazine, the Aboriginal stringer program, and sitting down with First Nations University that we ‑‑ again, like I referenced earlier, we sat back and we looked at, you know, what we felt the unique needs were for this community, and then made that allocation change.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12791 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Okay. This now leads me to the $64,000 questions, as they say, which is, you may have heard Commissioner Pennefather ask the previous applicant about the important role of the Commission's evaluation of new radio applications is determining how many new radio stations, if any, could be licensed in a market without resulting in undue impact on existing stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12792 For the year ending August 31st, we note that the profitability of the Regina radio market was below the national average for all English‑language commercial radio. Nevertheless, we have received a number of applications for each market, some from well‑established Canadian broadcasters. Can you tell us what factors you took into consideration in determining that the Regina market was capable of supporting a new station at this time?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12793 MS TAYLOR: Regina is growing. We looked at the regular economic indicators that anyone would look at to get some sense of how healthy the economic market is. We looked at the fact that the growth rate here has outpaced the national average for the last three years, that retail sales have grown considerably, that they are, by all accounts, predicted to grow over the national average in the next little while. The PST cut certainly didn't hurt. The Finance Minister was quite adamant that this is an economy that is on the move, and we see that. We see that in just about everywhere that we look. I ‑‑ I've spent ‑‑ I've lived in this province, and Saskatchewan tends to be, in my opinion, a province of neither boom nor bust. While you may not experience the great upswings that other provinces will have, you also don't tend to have big downs. So Saskatchewan and Regina tends to ‑‑ or in the past, has tended to just kind of plod along and stay on the right side of the track. The fact that the population in this province is staying on the positive side of the ledger is an accomplishment with Alberta right next door, and we all know what's going on over there with jobs. So all in all, when we looked at the economic indicators, which looked good, when we factored in the per capita radio sales, which I think presents a very strong case for the fact that the market can support at least one other operator, and the fact that income here is slightly greater than income in the other provinces, again, a good indicator that retail spending will continue to go up, it looks positive. It's ‑‑ it is a tough market, no question, so is Manitoba. Standard Radio is a very conservative company when it comes to projecting revenues, and we handle our expenses aggressively.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12794 We're very confident that we can operate here and that the market can support it, particularly with a musical format that is unduplicated in the market with country music on FM.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12795 All put together, we feel it looks very positive for ‑‑ for this type of station and for our company in the market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12796 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Ms Taylor, did you have an opportunity to read the letter submitted with the Rawlco intervention by CBS and what they have to say about the market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12797 MS TAYLOR: Yes, I did.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12798 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: I was wondering if, in particular, you could give us your reaction to the paragraph that says, "The addition of any new radio stations to the Regina market will not" ‑‑ and it's not underlined ‑‑ "will not result in any new national advertising dollars coming available. The money already there will just be split between all stations resulting in any national sales revenue for a new station coming directly out of national sales revenue of existing stations."
LISTNUM 95 \l 12799 MS TAYLOR: I don't have CBS's letter in front of me, but I did read it, and I appreciate the refresher. I agree with what has been said before about national sales in smaller markets. It is tough with rates going up in Toronto and whatever. There have been markets where the national dollars have stayed kind of steady, and, again, national dollars ‑‑ national revenue in ‑‑ in a market this size is typically 20 percent. It's not a large portion of your overall revenue. Local sales is really what matters in terms of living or dying. That said, I do believe and have had conversations with our national rep. house that to have a country format will probably attract some national advertisers who are currently not advertising in this market. It does represent a desirable audience to some ag business to, you know, different national advertisers, who currently, in Regina, can't go to that one station that they feel will deliver that audience to them. So I agree with ‑‑ with the gist of it, that the national business is not going to grow substantially. Local business, we feel, will grow; however, I will take a little bit of exception or argument to his claim that they would ‑‑ that there is no new broadcaster in the market that will attract any new national money. I believe an unduplicated service, country music, just might, and we're hoping that it will.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12800 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Ms Taylor, thank you. Thank you to your panel.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12801 Those are my questions, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12802 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12803 Vice‑Chair Arpin...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12804 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12805 I want to bring you back to your introductory remark, and it's ‑‑ and I'm going to start by the second paragraph of your page 8 where you say that you, Standard Radio, has an agreement with AVR regarding its news magazine program for Regina. First, what's going to be that ‑‑ what is that agreement?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12806 MS TAYLOR: The agreement is that they will make available to us produced programming that they are preparing in the other markets that they are currently up and operating in, and we can cherry pick, if you will, from that produced programming, should any of it, we feel, be relevant to our audience here.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12807 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: And is it an agreement that ‑‑ a longstanding agreement that you have across Canada, or is it specific to Regina?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12808 MS TAYLOR: I do know that we have entered into this agreement with AVR in other markets. I can't speak to which ones specifically, I don't recall, but I do know that we have had it in other markets that we serve, and we do have a letter of agreement with them for Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12809 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: And where in this application would I find any documentation regarding both the agreement and your plan with AVR? I've been perusing your ‑‑ the application and never saw any reference to it, unless I went over it. So can you help me find out where in the application it is?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12810 MS TAYLOR: That's a very good question. I truly can't recall whether it was mentioned in our Supplemental Brief, but it was in AVR's intervention letter in support of our application. They made mention of the agreement that we have to utilize their programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12811 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So, as you know, AVR will be appearing later in this hearing, and if you were to be ‑‑ both of you be granted a licence, does ‑‑ what's going to happen? Will you still maintain your Aboriginal commitment in the news magazine on one end ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12812 MS TAYLOR: Oh, yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12813 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: ‑‑ and will you keep getting your programming from AVR?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12814 MS TAYLOR: It's my understanding that AVR certainly, should they be granted the licence, may or may not be up and running as quickly as if we were granted the licence, we may be. So in that interim, their programming would be made available to us. If we were both up and running, I would love to see a partnership between the two of us where we can exchange ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12815 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So you're going to serve as a teaser for AVR to come up with the programming in the Regina market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12816 MS TAYLOR: Not at all.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12817 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: No?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12818 MS TAYLOR: This is a stand‑alone project that we're very proud of, and to just ‑‑ in the ‑‑ to have the ability to source some of their programming, we feel, will be an advantage.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12819 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Now, are you already making use of the AVR programming in other markets?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12820 MS TAYLOR: I'm not confident that we are. Again, I think that we do have those agreements, and I know that in our applications, I believe, in Fort McMurray and Grande Prairie, we also had an agreement there. But I don't know whether we're up and running in any of our markets.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12821 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Any other market? Well, only for the people representing AVR that are in this room, I will have similar questions for them when they will appear.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12822 So thank you, Ms Taylor, you have answered my questions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12823 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Vice‑Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12824 Ms Taylor, could I take you to your Supplementary Brief at page ‑‑ I guess I'll start at page 19 under the total benefits proposed. And you say, "Based on the foregoing, Standard has proposed Canadian talent development benefits amounting to at least a hundred thousand dollars a year in direct financial aid," and that adds up, in my silly little mind, to 700,000.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12825 MS TAYLOR: You are, again, correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12826 THE CHAIRPERSON: And today you're saying the CTD is going to be one million, 50, over the seven years?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12827 MS TAYLOR: That is correct, $150,000 per year is now what we have outlined in cash benefits for our Canadian talent development.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12828 THE CHAIRPERSON: And do you think that's, particularly fair to the other participants in the Regina hearing that you are upping your commitments at a point when they are in a position when they can't reply?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12829 MS TAYLOR: It's my understanding as Phase I of the hearing that ‑‑ you know, that they would be in a position to respond to that, if need be. Again, my understanding was that $100,000 was our floor. That's our minimum commitment in this market to Canadian talent development. Once we took a good, hard look at the needs and where we thought we could fill those needs, there was more money that needed to be spent, we felt, to really round out what we needed to do to put a ‑‑ the kind of product on the air here and be the kind of broadcast member in the community. So it's my understanding that introducing it now will still give the other broadcasters an opportunity to respond.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12830 THE CHAIRPERSON: What about Newcap who came before you? Would they be out of this ‑‑ it appears you think that Phase I is an auction, and I, frankly, have to disabuse you of that belief. But even if it were, Newcap was ahead of you, and they're in no position, at this point, to say they'll up you by, you know, whatever. And I ‑‑ I mean, this is just an academic issue because I'm unaware us ever having conducted auctions in Phase I, but, I mean, wouldn't it be unfair to Newcap?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12831 MS TAYLOR: First of all, I like the auction analogy, but we are still, I believe, under Newcap. You know, we did not look at this as a competitive part of our licence where we were adding in in order to, you know, do better than the other applicants. We saw it ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12832 THE CHAIRPERSON: How is this different from CJVR having said nothing about Canadian content in their application in Medicine Hat and then coming in and proposing above the regulatory amount at the hearing just before us. How does this situation here differ?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12833 MS TAYLOR: I apologize, I wasn't present for their portion of the hearing.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12834 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Well, can we go through the changes, and it will be up to the Commission to decide whether or not we will accept any amendment to your application as filed.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12835 MS TAYLOR: Of course.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12836 THE CHAIRPERSON: You have to be clear about that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12837 MS TAYLOR: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12838 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. The ‑‑ yes, we'll decide after we've heard what the rest of the other applicants have to say. I mean, we make a decision on any amendments after everybody else has had a chance to say what they think about it. But let's go through them so we're clear on them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12839 The $15,000 for stringers, do I understand you to say that this is presently included in your one million, 50?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12840 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12841 THE CHAIRPERSON: And if it is not accepted as eligible CTD, that will simply be taken out of the picture, or you'll give more money to Starmaker?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12842 MS TAYLOR: We'll redirect it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12843 THE CHAIRPERSON: To Starmaker?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12844 MS TAYLOR: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12845 THE CHAIRPERSON: You would, however, still continue to do the program with the stringers?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12846 MS TAYLOR: Yes, we would.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12847 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Then there was the 10,000 to INCA, that is the same.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12848 Today you're saying $25,000 to SRIA instead of 15,000?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12849 MS TAYLOR: That is correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12850 THE CHAIRPERSON: The 25,000 to the Sask. Music Educators, the Honours Group, and Heart of the City Piano Project, that's absolutely new, never proposed?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12851 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12852 THE CHAIRPERSON: And how is that going to be administered, you're just going to give the money over to them, and they'll make the decision?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12853 MS TAYLOR: We've had discussions with them about their programs ‑‑ about their funding, about their needs, and have discussed, to some length, these two programs in particular, which we expressed to them ‑‑ we felt that they were the programs that would be the best fit for us to contribute. That said, we would certainly be working with them in administration ‑‑ I mean, they would administrate the money there. It's their programs, but we would like to participate, for example, in the ‑‑ in the one program, the choral program, we would like to discuss bringing some of the Canadian country artists into that program where they team up the professional musicians with the students. So there would be some give and take, but, essentially, they would administrate the funds into the programs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12854 THE CHAIRPERSON: The $30,000 talent show remains.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12855 Instead of 5,000 previously proposed to FACTOR, it is now 20; is that correct?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12856 MS TAYLOR: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12857 THE CHAIRPERSON: Canadian Music Week was 5,000, it is now 10?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12858 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12859 THE CHAIRPERSON: Starmaker with zero, it is now going to be 10?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12860 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12861 THE CHAIRPERSON: And CCMA was 5,000, and it remains the same?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12862 MS TAYLOR: I believe the CCMA is a new initiative.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12863 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, you're right, yes, it is.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12864 MS TAYLOR: Canadian Music Week is probably the one.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12865 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, you're ‑‑ no, you're right. And then the $10,000 designated fund going to NAIT is now off the board?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12866 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12867 THE CHAIRPERSON: That's where it's at?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12868 MS TAYLOR: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12869 THE CHAIRPERSON: I wanted to ask you to provide us with a chart showing your spoken word programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12870 MS TAYLOR: Certainly.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12871 THE CHAIRPERSON: Similar to ‑‑ and I'm not holding Newcap up as the golden child, but similar to that, so we can see what the hours of the news and how long each one is.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12872 MS TAYLOR: We can get that for you today.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12873 THE CHAIRPERSON: Perfect. And when are you live to air?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12874 MS TAYLOR: I'll ask Janet Trecarten to respond to that. She has a fairly good grasp of our live to air and other programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12875 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12876 MS LAZARIS: We're planning to be live 73 hours each week, and the live portions of the programming will be our morning drive show, our afternoon drive. We have a live interactive evening program, and weekends from noon to six, we will also be live.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12877 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. When is your morning show?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12878 MS LAZARIS: From 5:30 to 10, but we've only counted 6 a.m. to 10 in ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12879 THE CHAIRPERSON: So you'd be live six to ten?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12880 MS LAZARIS: That's right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12881 THE CHAIRPERSON: And then when?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12882 MS LAZARIS: The afternoon drive show, which will run two until seven.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12883 THE CHAIRPERSON: Two to seven.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12884 MS LAZARIS: And the evening show, which will run seven until ten.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12885 THE CHAIRPERSON: Seven to ten?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12886 MS LAZARIS: That's right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12887 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And then you say you're going to be voice tracked for 32 hours, and that's, presumably, the noon hour and the other time, but what is automated?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12888 MS LAZARIS: The ‑‑ I'd like to elaborate on that. When we filed the application initially, the automated times referred to a combination of a live program, which is available internationally that we were considering taking in the evening. We've rethought those plans and determined that we didn't want to continue with that plan, and we were going to a live program in the evening instead. So that 24 hours that were first automated with a combination of the live nationally done program as well as preproduced programs, so our commitment, in fact, is 73 hours live, 47 hours voice tracked, and six hours of preproduced local programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12889 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, okay. Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12890 Mr. Vice‑Chair...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12891 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: You refer in your descriptive of your local live programming to a live interactive. What's going to be the content of that program? Is it an open line, is it ‑‑ what are you planning to do?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12892 MS LAZARIS: It be request‑based in nature, and we thought that the 7 p.m. to 10 p.m. period would be a good spot for it when people, you know, have the time to interact with their radio stations, versus middays when people are at work and not able to take advantage of the interactivity. We'll be encouraging people to not only e‑mail us during the day with their requests and dedications that we'll broadcast on air that evening, but, as well, to call us live and interact with request‑type programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12893 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So you'll be broadcasting those requests from the audience?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12894 MS LAZARIS: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12895 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12896 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12897 Now, Ms Taylor, you have two minutes, not five minutes as you say on your summation, to tell us ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12898 MS TAYLOR: Oh, dear.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12899 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ why we should choose you. Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12900 MS TAYLOR: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12901 I'd like to just reaffirm some of the points that we did make. We believe that our application represents a new and strong voice for Regina, a brand new format that's currently not available in the market, 20 new jobs, numerous new opportunities, 40‑percent Canadian content, which includes our commitment to 40‑percent Canadian content 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday to Friday, a terrific benefits package, 1,050,000 in cash over the licence term, as well as our indirect benefits, a news package that incorporates the strength of our national news centers, along with a commitment to local coverage, a unique news magazine program that will truly reflect the Aboriginal communities, and a realistic and achievable business plan.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12902 And we certainly appreciate the time and the attention you've given us. This is not, although some may question, the first time I've sat in front of you, it's just as nerve-racking as it was the first time. It is the first time for some members of our panel, and we really appreciate your time and attention.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12903 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12904 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you. We'll take a ‑‑ it will be a 17‑minute break, so it will be quarter to five.
‑‑‑ Upon recessing at 1627 / Suspension à 1627
‑‑‑ Upon resuming at 1648 / Reprise à 1648
LISTNUM 95 \l 12905 THE CHAIRPERSON: Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12906 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12907 Before we proceed, I would like to indicate for the record that Standard Radio Inc. has filed their spoken word chart or description of programming, and it will be placed on their application file, in case anybody wishes to review it in the examination room.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12908 We will now proceed with item 12 on the agenda, which is an application by Touch Canada Broadcasting Inc. for a licence to operate an English‑language FM commercial specialty radio programming undertaking in Regina. The new station would operate on frequency 96.1 megahertz (channel 241C1) with an effective radiated power of 86,000 watts (non‑directional antenna/antenna height of 146.2 metres.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12909 Appearing for the applicant is Mr. Allan Hunsperger, who will introduce his colleagues, and you will then have 20 minutes for your presentation.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12910 Mr. Hunsperger...?
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 12911 MR. HUNSPERGER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12912 Madam Chair, Members of the CRTC and Commission Staff, thank you for allowing us the opportunity of sharing with you our reasoning for applying for a specialty FM gospel music radio licence for the City of Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12913 Before we get started, let me introduce to you our panel. To my far right is Beverly Gillespie, our business manager, and to her left is Maureeta Percy, vice‑president Ipsos Reid. To my immediate right is Malcolm Hunt, our network program director. To my far left, Dionne Smith, a representative of the Shai Awards for gospel music, and to my immediate left is Jamie Moffat, sales manager for our Edmonton station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12914 Attached to the end of our presentation document is a seating chart for ease of identifying members of our panel.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12915 At the present time, Regina has no gospel music radio station. With your approval and our ability to provide the infrastructure including personnel, programming, marketing, and the financial backing to sustain such a station, we are confident that we can establish a successful gospel voice in this market thereby satisfying the needs of 26 percent of Regina residents who have indicated an interest in such a service.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12916 Touch Canada Broadcasting Inc. has remained within this format since our first station CJCA 930, Edmonton began airing gospel music in April of 1994. Subsequently, we have had the privilege of establishing this format in Calgary on 88.9 Shine FM, and then in September 2004, the Commission granted us a FM licence for Edmonton, 105.9 Shine FM.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12917 Due to the success of these stations, we now are ready to try to grow our business in other markets across Canada, such as Regina and Saskatoon.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12918 MS GILLESPIE: The mayor of Regina, Mayor Pat Fiacco, along with his city council has adopted the slogan, "I love Regina." Quoting from the city's website, "The I love Regina campaign was born in the mayor's office and has grown into a huge community‑driven initiative. It began as more and more residents are calling Regina home. With building permits skyrocketing this year and last and more and more businesses popping up everywhere, Regina's image is starting to change too. I believe in Regina and its residents, so I decided it was time to celebrate this city and change our image here at home, across the country, and into the U.S. I want our residents to celebrate Regina and to be proud of our capital city," unquote.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12919 We, at Touch Canada Broadcasting, would like to be a part of the mosaic of this revitalized city.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12920 We called in Ipsos Reid to survey the city and area to see what the response would be in offering a gospel format. I want Maureeta Percy, vice‑president of Ipsos Reid, to explain to you their process and also share with you the results of this survey.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12921 MS PERCY: Thank you, Bev.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12922 Ipsos Reid was commissioned by Touch Canada Broadcasting to conduct a telephone survey with a random sample of adults from the Regina area to determine the interests in a contemporary Christian music station and a southern gospel music radio station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12923 Respondents were contacted using random digit dialing in the Regina area. All telephone interviews were conducted between May 8th to 16th, 2006.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12924 Interest in a contemporary Christian music station in Regina is high. A total of 26 percent of respondents indicated that if a contemporary Christian music radio station was available in Regina, they would listen to it, either regularly or occasionally.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12925 Furthermore, 34 percent of Regina adults say they currently listen to Christian music indicating a healthy appetite for the format in this market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12926 Those interested in the contemporary Christian music station indicate they would listen to the station for an average of 57 minutes per day. Additionally, 18 percent who would listen to the station say their overall radio listening habits would increase if the station was available.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12927 Interest in a southern gospel music station is weaker than that for a contemporary Christian music station, but still promising. A total of 21 percent of respondents say that if a southern gospel music radio station was available in Regina, they would listen to it, either regularly or occasionally. Those interested in the southern gospel music station indicate they would listen to this station for an average of 42 minutes per day. Additionally, 17 percent who would listen to the station say their overall radio listening habits would increase if this station was available.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12928 If these stations existed today, they would likely be among the most popular stations in Regina. By virtue of the 26 percent who say they would listen to the contemporary Christian music station, at least occasionally, and 21 percent who would listen to the southern gospel music station, at least occasionally, these radio stations would have the potential to become popular stations in Regina, if they were launched. These station could rival the popularity of CFWF 104.9 FM, "The Wolf." 28 percent indicate they've listened to this station in the past month. CHMX 92.1 FM, "Light 92," which 26 percent of respondents have listened to in the past month, and CKRM 620 AM, CKCK 94.5 "JACKfm," and CIZI 98.9, "Z99," all of which 22 percent have listened to in the past month.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12929 Few Regina residents are very satisfied with radio in Regina, and few who watch or listen to Christian programming are very satisfied with the amount of Christian programming currently available to them. Although almost all Regina adults listen to the radio on a daily basis, only 36 percent report being very satisfied with radio options in Regina indicating that the needs of most radio listeners are currently not being met.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12930 Only 14 percent of respondents who watch or listen to Christian programming say they are very satisfied with the amount of Christian programs available to them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12931 Only 9 percent of respondents who listen to Christian music say they are very satisfied with the amount of Christian music currently being played on the radio.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12932 MR. HUNSPERGER: Based on our experience and the result of the Ipsos Reid survey, we determined that a contemporary Christian music format would best suit Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12933 We have trademarked Shine FM for Canada so that when we approach different markets with our style of radio, they will know exactly what to expect, and usually we find an excitement that their market could have the possibility of a Shine FM.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12934 I would now ask Jamie Moffat, sales manager for Edmonton to explain to you our marketing plans for Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12935 MR. MOFFAT: Advertising revenue is different with regards to a specialty gospel format from more traditional radio formats.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12936 Since becoming sales manager for Touch Canada Broadcasting Inc. more than two years ago, I found that we attract most of our accounts from non‑traditional advertisers.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12937 At the start‑up of our current operations, we discovered that more than 60 percent of our advertising revenue was derived from new radio clients. Our past experiences have shown us that there are advertisers specific to this format that would not usually be found on other formats. Businesses and listeners know that a gospel format cannot make it without their support. And in the markets that we are in to date, this support is growing and giving us a very positive effect.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12938 As a result of our research in Regina, we are confident that there's a large enough market to sustain and grow a contemporary gospel music station. Further evidence of this are the supporting interventions sent in for this hearing from businesses expressing their desire for this format in the market. You will hear from some of them in Phase III of this hearing.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12939 MR. HUNSPERGER: The person responsible for programming our existing stations is Malcolm Hunt. He was the first employee that I hired back in 1994, and, except for three years where he left us to help CHVN in Winnipeg launch their gospel music station, has been successfully programming our stations to meet the needs of our listeners. I would ask Malcolm to share with you a little of our programming plan for Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12940 MR. HUNT: Thank you, Allan.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12941 Probably every programmer will tell you that he would do it differently if finances were no problem, but, unfortunately, this is not the case with most programmers, and I am, certainly, not the exception.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12942 Attached to this presentation is Appendix B, programming schedule, that I have drawn up to give you a representation of what the programming will look like at 96.1 Shine FM Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12943 As far as personnel is concerned, we will be hiring two full‑time on‑air personalities, plus one part‑time to assist in the morning drive. This position will become full‑time in year two.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12944 We consider our voice trackers as part‑time on‑air staff, as they voice track solely for Regina. They talk about Regina and the things that are happening within the area. Voice tracking is done daily so that local issues and events happening in Regina now can be addressed.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12945 A very important aspect of our programming is Canadian content. We continue to exceed our licence requirement of 10 percent. For example, last week our Shine FM at Edmonton aired 14.8 percent, while in Calgary, we reached 15.3. We will continue to exceed the required level in Regina should we obtain a licence.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12946 We will provide a weekly total of 31.4 hours of spoken word programming. This will include 6.6 hours of news, weather, and sports, 8.3 hours of local reflection and announcer content, 1.5 hours of comedy and human interest features, and 15 hours of brokered programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12947 News is an area in which Touch Canada Broadcasting is planning expansion. The plan can only come to fruition with the addition of more licences. We will provide a full slate of news programming using our own staff in Regina, supplemented by our Edmonton center and the services of RaeDioNews.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12948 Community involvement is an area that Touch Canada Broadcasting prides itself on. In Calgary and Edmonton, we have seen continuous growth in our fundraising for local charities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12949 I will now ask Bev Gillespie to share with you our charitable activities to date.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12950 MS GILLESPIE: We teamed up with Kids Kottage 12 years ago, even before they became an association. Kids Kottage is open 24/7 as a place where parents without a support system can take their children for up to 72 hours while they deal with the pressures they are facing. It is an organization that helps prevent child abuse and neglect, and it is currently operating at capacity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12951 Touch Canada Broadcasting also partners with the Mustard Seed, which provides assistance to those residing in the inner city offering food, clothing, and shelter. Year‑to‑date, over $500,000 has been raised for both Edmonton and Calgary combined with the help of local businesses and listeners.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12952 Another partnering charity, the Dream Centre, provides a safe housing environment while developing skill sets for recovering addicts supporting their development towards a self‑sufficient lifestyle.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12953 We are very proud of Touch Canada's fundraising efforts to date, and hope to be even more supportive with the addition of new licences. We will continue similar efforts in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12954 MR. HUNT: We recognize the Broadcasting Act requirement for opportunity for expression of differing points of view on matters of public concern and the Commission's expression of that concern in the religious broadcasting policy.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12955 While we do not believe that we are a religious station as defined in the policy but, rather, we are a gospel music radio station that carries brokered programs, just as some country music, ethnic, and talk stations do.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12956 When it comes to adding programming to our lineup, we take special care on the quality, presentation, and content of the product. We have a daily que sheet on each program and know, in advance, the material that is going to be covered. We take this requirement seriously.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12957 In Regina, we will set up a dedicated phone line and voicemail that will record the opinions and views of our listeners. We will review this listener input and air the comments. If necessary, we will seek out other points of view to ensure that balance is achieved.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12958 We recognize the importance of Canadian talent development. We believe the stronger the fledgling Canadian gospel music industry becomes, the better sounding our radio stations will be.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12959 We propose a commitment of $56,000 over the licence term. That money will be entirely to the Shai Gospel Music Awards. Dionne Smith, the executive director of the organization is here on our panel, and I would like her to share a little about how they assist aspiring Canadian gospel music artists.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12960 MS SMITH: The Shai Awards are Canada's only people's choice awards dedicated to gospel music. The awards, for the last five years, have been held in various locations across the country, laying the foundation for a now rapidly growing gospel music industry here in Canada. Gospel artists across Canada are depending on Shai as we have filled a very important role, providing support, advocacy, education, promotion, and recognition of the gospel music artists and their industry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12961 Shai gospel music, with our awards, seminars, and events, offer a unique platform for the gospel music industry, the listeners, and the artists. These awards are open to all gospel artists throughout Canada, and, each year, gather more than 20,000 votes from gospel music fans across the country via online voting. The public votes for Canada's best gospel artist in 23 categories including: contemporary pop, rap, rock, Aboriginal, Francophone, and instrumental, just to name a few.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12962 There is a need for the Shai Awards to continue to be a vital component of the music industry here in Canada and also to have radio stations continue the support of Canadian gospel artists. As a result of exposure through the Shai Awards, artists like Jake, Greg Sczebel, Toronto Mass Choir, and Amanda Falk have gone on to win Juno Awards, Canada's highest music honour. All these artists currently are aired on Touch Canada Broadcasting's radio stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12963 Since the inception of the Shai Awards, Touch Canada has supported our endeavours each year. The addition of further radio stations across Canada will only provide growing support and inspiration to our artists, the music fans, and the gospel music industry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12964 MR. HUNSPERGER: When gospel music lovers heard that there might be a possibility of having a Shine FM station in Regina and area, they began to send in letters and e‑mails, faxes, and phone calls encouraging us on this endeavour. In our short history, we have never had such a ground swell of support as we've had here in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12965 Regina has been a city that, in the past, has been down on itself thinking nothing could ever happen here. That is changing and changing quickly. Through the efforts of the mayor with his "I love Regina" campaign, and through the efforts of many others in this city, Regina is rising up to become a very positive and vibrant community. Allowing Regina a gospel music radio station would be another steppingstone in this direction.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12966 We bring balance and diversity within the broadcast system and would do all we can to be a part of the positive growth happening in Regina. We will be happy to answer any questions you may have regarding our application. Just in case you have none, have a good day.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12967 Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12968 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you Mr. Hunsperger.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12969 Commissioner Williams...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12970 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12971 Mr. Hunsperger, a good day for us includes many detailed questions and carefully considered answers.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12972 MR. HUNSPERGER: I was just kidding.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12973 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Your application/presentation is very thorough, so you may notice some of our questions will allow you to cover some parts of your information and the ground twice. This also makes for a good day, as we could have a very clear understanding of your application, and that's our intent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12974 So let's begin and learn a bit more about Touch Canada Broadcasting's plans for Regina. I note that in your application you've not specified a target audience. Could you tell me what specific demographic will makeup your core target audience?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12975 MR. HUNSPERGER: We usually demograph ‑‑ our demographic is pretty well between 25 and ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12976 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: 25 to 44, say, or ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12977 MR. HUNSPERGER: Yes, yes, and we usually look at ‑‑ someone female 33 to 35 years old is probably even narrowing it down even more.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12978 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Do you believe ‑‑ why do you believe your contemporary Christian music format will provide the greatest degree of diversity and represents the best choice of format to serve the population of Regina?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12979 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, basically, because there is nothing here in Regina that's offering that kind of music right now, and there's a real void here, there's a real need, and, you know, like I said, the ground swell for us coming in and applying for a licence for a radio station here in Regina has been phenomenal, and people are very excited about it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12980 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12981 MR. HUNSPERGER: You could probably tell by our letters that wrote in support. We went way over 50, closer to a hundred. I don't ‑‑ can't ‑‑ I don't know how many exactly came in, but it was phenomenal.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12982 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Hmm. We note you plan to devote 31.4 hours a week to spoken word programming of which 6.6 hours would be news, weather, sports, and entertainment information. I also note you plan to provide 8.3 hours of local reflection and announcer content. Could you, please, describe for us the programs that will make up the other 16 hours of spoken word programming? And regarding your 8.3 hours of local reflection, could you give us some examples of the types of programs that you will be offering?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12983 MR. HUNT: Absolutely. Basically, the local reflection and announcer content, I'll start there, if that's okay, that basically describes the spoken word that our announcers will do in between the music. That's basically ‑‑ I mean, the content is going to vary from local activities and world events, but the bottom line is, and we tell all of our announcers on all of our radio stations that it needs to be relative to the market that they're in. So that information through the week is from our announcers for the most part, the 8.3.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12984 The other part, the 15 hours of the brokered programming, and then I think you were asking me about the 16‑and‑a‑half hours remaining, and the other hour and a half was the comedy and human interest features, which, you know, they go ‑‑ basically, comedy is comedy. I don't know how much more I can describe that one.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12985 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yes, it's usually funny, right?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12986 MR. HUNT: It's usually funny. Not always, but, you know, we do our best.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 12987 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12988 MR. HUNT: And, of course, the human interest features could be health‑related and those types of things, family, of course.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12989 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: How will you determine and ensure that these programs will meet the needs and interests of Regina?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12990 MR. HUNT: Well, I mean our experience in other markets that our audience has taken those features and applied them to their daily lives. As I mentioned, we have lots of family‑related issues, and it doesn't matter where you live in Canada ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12991 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: The issues are the same?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12992 MR. HUNT: ‑‑ the issues are going to be the same, correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12993 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: I note you've indicated that the proposed station will provide 52 hours of voice tracking, which would initially be scheduled during midday evening and weekend hours. Could you specify the exact time, and I guess you have in the handout ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 12994 MR. HUNT: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12995 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: ‑‑ but, for the record, could you specify the exact time that will be voice tracked, i.e., what does midday, evening, and weekend really mean, and could you tell us what your future plans are regarding voice tracking?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12996 MR. HUNT: Well, initially, we had set out exactly what we put into our program schedule, which would be our midday program, which would run from 9 a.m. until 1 p.m., and that would be voice tracked. Wherever possible, we will try to use the people from this market. Of course, we have other stations within our network, and ‑‑ initially, but not all of our voice tracking will be done by some of our other staff, and our goal is to be a hundred percent Regina at the quickest possible point. Evenings, from six to 9 p.m., again, voice tracked, and the times indicated on the weekends, as well, for, again, the total of 52 hours.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12997 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 12998 In your application, you state, and I quote, "The proposed FM station will utilize the TCB News Network and RaeDioNews Network to cover breaking news, current affairs, sports, regional events, and news specials." You also specify that a Regina news reporter will add local news and community reflection to the package. Could you tell me how you will ensure the news will address the needs and interests of the Regina listeners?
LISTNUM 95 \l 12999 MR. HUNT: Well, again, we tell all of our staff that it needs to be relative to Regina. And we use, you know, our listeners as a sounding board through various ways of communicating through them ‑‑ with them through our website, telephone calls, and that type of thing, and we will ensure that that content is something that they are going to be needing at the specified times that we have in our schedule in terms of news, yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13000 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Mr. Hunt, could you tell me a bit more about the RaeDioNews Service?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13001 MR. HUNT: Sure. It's a service that a lot of our specialty format stations use in the country. It's out of Ontario. Again, we've been using this for a number of years now, and we have, in the last couple of years, realized that we need to spend a lot more time dealing with local content. That's where a lot of our national and international news comes from, and the local people that we are adding to our network are specifically there to provide the local aspect of our news programming. And it is something ‑‑ as we gain more licences, we'll have more resources to be able to add more to that network. It's still in its infancy for us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13002 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: How is our speed, are we going a little quick for you?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13003 COURT REPORTER: It's fast.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13004 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: A little bit fast? Maybe we'll slow down just a tiny bit because she's trying to record all this. I'm just as big an offender as anyone, so I'll try and lead by example.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13005 I note that in your deficiency response dated 21 July, '06, you indicated that TCB will not schedule newscasts on the weekend until your news department expands. Can you give us an idea of when that would be, and why have you chosen this approach?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13006 MR. HUNT: Resources, basically, and, again, the more radio stations we have, the more staff we'll be able to hire, the more newscasts we'll be able to provide. It's just simple economics from our standpoint that we just need more resources in order to fulfill this and to continue to expand it, and it is something that we are very passionate about expanding. We have talked about it in previous applications about expanding our news aspect because it is something that we realize is very, very important to our audience.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13007 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: How will your audience be kept informed of what's happening in their community during these periods that you're not providing news?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13008 MR. HUNT: That would be through the local content and announcer banter that we will have on the air during those times.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13009 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. So you will have live, local interactions during those time periods?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13010 MR. HUNT: Outside of the voice tracking, you know. Even during our voice tracking, with technology, we're able to update that very quickly, so even within the voice tracking, we'll be able to stay relative to the Regina are.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13011 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13012 MR. HUNSPERGER: If I could ask ‑‑ just insert here, sir, that, you know, what we try to do in our application is be very conservative in our promises to make sure that we can fulfill them, but our goal would be to, you know, be full ‑‑ announcing full news. I mean, we want to be a full live type of radio station as much as possible. And it's all determined, obviously, by economics. So we're giving you the bare minimum here of what we know that we can do financially, but our desire would be to keep increasing that, and in ‑‑ like I've said about Regina, it seems that that may happen even sooner than we think because of the positive response that's been coming from this market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13013 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: That's very helpful. Thank you, Mr. Hunsperger.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13014 Again, in your letter of July 21st, you indicated that the proposed station would have a dedicated newsroom. I note, however, that you have not provided information regarding the size of the news room, except for stating there will be a news reporter and news staff to be added to the ‑‑ or to the network. Could you tell us what your staffing plans are in this area and what their responsibility would be, example, news gathering, production, editorial content, on‑air broadcasting, et cetera, and could you also expand on the news staff to be added to the network? And I heard your last response, but in your ‑‑ in your forward looking visioning, I guess, what do you see?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13015 MR. HUNT: Initially, we have the half‑time person, and I know we don't really like talking about half people, but it is a part‑time position initially, and, as we mentioned in our opening statement, that will grow to a full‑time position in year two, and then ‑‑ it's difficult to expand upon what's going to happen in a couple of years with our company in terms of news. I mean, our prayers, as Allan had mentioned, is to, you know, grow as quickly as possible and add people to everyday parts. So, I mean, our plans are certainly to grow that quick, but we do want to be conservative and realize that we work with what we have, initially, but ‑‑ I hope that answers the question about who we have initially.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13016 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yeah, it helps.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13017 MR. HUNSPERGER: If I could mention ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13018 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Sure.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13019 MR. HUNSPERGER: ‑‑ about the ‑‑ you were talking about the space and how that would look. You know, it doesn't look like when I was ‑‑ when I was in radio in the '70s and '80s, you know, where we actually had a separate newsroom and everything else, we'll basically have the master control room, and then we'll have a production room. And because of the way ‑‑ a lot of our commercials are done out of the Edmonton master production area, there will be some production done here, but news and other specialty type of programs and whatever will be done under that kind of studio 2 that will be done. There wouldn't be a space that would be, quote, "dedicated to news," but there would be those two studios. One, of course, would be the main studio, and then the other one would be a production studio that would be used for news and other things.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13020 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. Given the fact you propose to produce over six hours of news per week, do you believe that your half person becoming a whole over a couple of years would be sufficient to produce this amount of news, but also high quality newscasts?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13021 MR. HUNT: Well, it would be a combination of our resources in Edmonton and the radio news along with the local person, so ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13022 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yeah, I think I was thinking specifically to the local ‑‑ the Regina‑oriented news.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13023 MR. HUNT: We will certainly make that happen. That's definitely something that we ‑‑ we put that in our application, and we believe we're going to be able to maintain high quality newscasts in everything that we do.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13024 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: And that's based upon your experience in other markets?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13025 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13026 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. In your other markets, I'd like to take a little bit of time to talk about your plans for the sharing of resources with your existing stations, and more particularly, the programming synergies that will be realized. Could you provide us with more details on these, including in the area of voice trafficking [sic] and traffic?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13027 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, first of all ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13028 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Voice tracking, pardon me.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13029 MR. HUNSPERGER: We understood what you meant, yes. First of all, obviously the synergies in the business office and the accounting office and even management, you know, those synergies are all put together, and I'll let Malcolm, then, handle the voice tracking.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13030 MR. HUNT: Again, initially, some, but not all of our voice tracking will be done by existing Touch Canada Broadcasting staff. You know, it will be done outside of our Regina studios, but, of course, all of the voice tracks are inputted at the local level into our systems, and that's ‑‑ and that's, basically, how we will begin to get the thing on the air with our voice tracking. And as time continues to tick along, we'll be able to add people from this area.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13031 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: I note that you will broadcast local and non‑local religious programs like Focus on the Family, Insight for Living, In Touch, and Love Worth finding. Will you do any station‑produced religious programming, and, if so, how much weekly?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13032 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, that's always a hard figure to come up with. We constantly are trying to get Canadians involved in broadcasting, and it's never been in their vision to do it, and we slowly are starting to see this happen. For example, this last month in Calgary, we actually added a local pastor and his group putting on a weekly half‑hour, and what I do is I go ‑‑ I drive down to Calgary, and I help them in the production of that program, and we usually do a month at a time, and so we're trying to nurture that, encourage that. I think there's a lot of people that say, oh, we'll do it, and then when they find out, well, it costs money, they have the tendency to withdraw a little bit. But we're trying to encourage that more and more, and we would do the same in Regina. My guess is in Regina we're probably going to have some people come on the air right away from a local perspective, which will be very exciting and welcomed by us.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13033 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Please discuss your plans for brokered programming. To what extent have you had discussions with program producers interested in purchasing air time?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13034 MR. HUNSPERGER: Before we ever get to an application, sending it off to you, we always sit down with particularly the agencies that handle the brokered spoken word and ask if they're interested in a market like Regina, if they're interested in a market like Saskatoon. One of the things that they found is that even though some of their programming may already be in this market ‑‑ like, I know it is. I know that Swift Current, for example, carries a lot of programming. I know that they'll want to come on ours as well just because of our specialty format. So they're all very excited, and we check with them and keep in contact with them all the time as we're applying for different centers.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13035 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: How much air time would be made available to groups interested in purchasing time to air religious programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13036 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, we talk about the three hours a day to start off with, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13037 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Three hours a day? I note that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13038 MR. HUNSPERGER: Monday through Friday.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13039 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yeah. I note that in response to how the proposed station would provide balance, you indicated, and I quote, "We will invite listeners to comment on matters of public concern and religious topics through recorded telephone calls or e‑mails. Now, we will review and air this listener input, and, if necessary, seek out other points of view to ensure that we meet this requirement." Can you describe for me how these plans would provide balance on issues of public concern, including religion, and be in line with the Commission's policy as set out in Public Notice 1993‑ 78?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13040 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, that would be our goal is to fulfill that mandate and make sure that there was balance in that area. Believe it or not, we ‑‑ even though in this situation we have many people who will probably call in and give us positive reinforcement of programming, in this kind of community, there's always different kinds of thought and different kinds of discussion, and even on a programming that I'm doing in ‑‑ and producing, we welcome the exchange of thoughts and ideas, even differing from other ideas. I mean, let's discuss it. We've got nothing ‑‑ no harm to be done here for us to discuss, and we know that we're going to do our level best to make sure that that balance comes. Now, if it doesn't come from the listener, then we're going to seek after, whether it be through the universities here or other colleges or whatever, trying to get that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13041 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Seek out various religious leaders within the community?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13042 MR. HUNSPERGER: Yes, hit that other thought, yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13043 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Now, how much of the broadcasting week would be devoted to balanced programming, and, also, in your discussion, consider the possibility that the Commission impose this level as a condition of licence. So how much of the broadcasting week would be devoted to balanced programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13044 MR. HUNSPERGER: I'm not sure I understand the question in the ‑‑ I mean, we go under the balanced policy of broadcasters, like any other broadcaster, so all of our programming is under the balance.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13045 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: And so ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13046 MR. HUNSPERGER: Am I understanding that correctly?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13047 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yeah, I'm just trying to rephrase here. Well, I guess if you come forward with all of your programming, then there's certainly no difficulty with the condition imposing that level as a condition of licence then, because that's something you'd be doing anyway?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13048 MR. HUNSPERGER: Right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13049 THE CHAIRPERSON: Balanced programming, Mr. Hunsperger, is a program that balances against your initial ‑‑ I'm not going to call it bias, but the purport of your station is essentially Christian. Balanced programming is to show the viewpoints of the other people who are not Christian, so if you've just agreed that all of your programming is balanced programming, it means you should be looking through the Muslim community fairly quickly and the Jewish community and the Aboriginal community because you won't be able to do any Christian programming, so you better think about that fairly carefully.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13050 MR. HUNSPERGER: Oh, okay, well ‑‑ so you're talking then about ‑‑ you're talking only about the brokered programming then, you're not talking about our entire programming; is that correct?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13051 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: I guess I want to know how much of your broadcasting would be devoted to balanced programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13052 MR. HUNSPERGER: You're asking for a specific time?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13053 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Or an estimate.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13054 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, on those ‑‑ on those matters of airing comments, they would probably run a 60‑second spot, you know, several times a day. I don't have any specific time. I don't ‑‑ we've never sat down and discussed a specific amount of time that that ‑‑ that that would be.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13055 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: So if you can discuss the possibility of the Commission imposing some sort of level as a condition of licence, then I guess what I'm understanding from how you've just answered is that you wouldn't be comfortable with that at ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13056 MR. HUNSPERGER: No.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13057 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: ‑‑ this point because you haven't identified exactly how much it is?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13058 MR. HUNSPERGER: No, we wouldn't be comfortable with that. I mean, we have ‑‑ first of all, we know that when it comes to this kind of programming, we know that other stations right across the country do the same spoken word programming that we do, and yet they're not under that same regulation, and we just want to be regulated in the same way as they are in ordering those ‑‑ or in airing those same kind of programs. We have a list here of ‑‑ of radio stations across Canada that are playing these spoken word programming, and I could submit this list to you, and you could see the many stations in the provinces across this country that are airing similar or the same or even more spoken word programming than we are. Can I submit that list to you?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13059 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: I think that would be fine. You can submit it to the ‑‑ our legal counsel will find a way to bring it into the record.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13060 MR. HUNSPERGER: Okay, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13061 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Moving on to Canadian talent development. We note that you've committed to spending at least 8,000 a year to support Vibe Gospel Music. Could you provide us a cost breakdown associated with this initiative, and should the Commission decide that some of these costs do not qualify as direct contributions to the development of Canadian talent, would you be prepared to redirect these costs to an eligible initiative as set out in Appendix 1 of Public Notice 1990‑111, entitled an FM Policy for the '90s?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13062 MR. HUNSPERGER: We have ‑‑ Dionne has so graciously given us a proposed budget for the year ‑‑ for example, 2007, which indicates where their monies are going, whether it's to vocal workshops or to band workshops or songwriting or production demos or et cetera, and we do have these budgets that we can submit to you for your review.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13063 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Again, we can ‑‑ we'll accept that information.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13064 MR. HUNSPERGER: Okay. What we would like to do ‑‑ you had said would we ‑‑ if these don't line up with what you would accept, would we accept someone else ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13065 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: A redirection to something that's eligible?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13066 MR. HUNSPERGER: Right. What we would like to do is we would like to then ‑‑ if you would say, well, no, this isn't what we think is right ‑‑ we believe you would agree with us that this does, but we would go back, then, to Dionne and say, Dionne, can we make arrangements because we want to build this industry, and that's the key of what we're trying to do. So we would go back and say, Dionne, can you tweak this, or can you do this in such a way that would satisfy the Commission with some of your questions or concerns so that we could line it up because we just want to promote these young artists, you know, that are struggling and trying to get involved in this particular genre.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13067 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. That's a good response, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13068 Your study by Ipsos Reid found that 24 percent of Regina adults currently listen to or watch Christian programming. In addition, this study found that about 34 percent of respondents said that they listen to Christian music. Would you have any additional comments to make regarding the level of demand among Regina radio listeners for your proposed religious station? And I recognize you've made this point a few times, but you have another opportunity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13069 MR. HUNSPERGER: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13070 It's very high, and we're very excited. And, of course, we know that any kind of a survey that comes up with 26 percent, we know that we're probably not going to get a 26‑percent share of the market, but if we got half of that, we'd be flipping cartwheels, but, yeah, we're very excited of what's happening here, and ‑‑ and we're ‑‑ we know that the support is there.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13071 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: How did you ‑‑ how did you estimate your contra advertising, and what does it include?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13072 MR. HUNSPERGER: I'll give that to our business manager.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13073 MS GILLESPIE: The question is, how did we estimate it?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13074 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Yeah or forecast maybe is a better ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13075 MS GILLESPIE: Okay, forecast. It's basically on our history. We try to eliminate contra over the initial licence. It will be higher in the first couple of years because, basically, we're giving contra advertising in expense for a contra revenue, which is, basically, promotional material, and which is very high promotionally in the first couple of years when you're trying to get your name out there. And then after that, we'd like to eventually have less and less.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13076 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Your application indicates that eight percent of your advertising revenues in year one would come from existing stations. How would you assess the potential of your proposed religious format to attract new advertisers to radio, compared to that of the other formats?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13077 MR. MOFFAT: Could I get the question one more time, please?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13078 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Oh, of course. In your application, you indicate that eight percent of your advertising revenue in year one would come from the incumbents, the existing stations. How would you assess the potential of your proposed religious format to attract new advertisers to radio as compared to that of the other formats?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13079 MR. MOFFAT: I think what we found in our history that because so many advertisers who come onboard our radio stations have either (a), never ever used radio before, or (b), are coming to us specifically because of the format.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13080 Contemporary Christian music is very similar to country in the audience loyalty factor. The people who tune it in are unduplicated, and advertisers recognize the power of an unduplicated audience, and they see that it's a hole in their marketing that they can fill with our radio station format.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13081 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Thank you, Mr. Moffat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13082 An important part of the Commission's evaluation of new radio applications is to determine how many new radio stations, if any, could be licensed in a market without resulting in undue negative impact on the existing stations. For the year ending August 31, 2005, we note the profitability of the Regina radio market was below the national average for all English‑language commercial radio. Nevertheless, we received a large number of applications for this market and from well‑established Canadian radio broadcasters. Can you tell us what factors you took into consideration in determining that the Regina market was capable of supporting your new station at this time? I imagine the marketing information, but were there other factors?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13083 MR. HUNSPERGER: Not really, other than the positive response that we've got both from the business community and the residents, you know, hereof Regina. We also know that our kind of stations really don't hurt other broadcasters, and so we can come in here and basically generate new money for radio. That's not being done now, and mainly because of what Jamie said, non‑traditional advertisers start advertising.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13084 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Mmhmm. Talk about ‑‑ there's certain elements in your application that distinguish your proposed service from the existing market stations. Can you elaborate on what sets you apart from the others, other than the religious content?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13085 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, what sets us apart is we're family radio. We're safe and fun for the whole family. I mean, we have moms even who have sent in letters and whatever who don't have to worry about what the ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13086 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: The material.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13087 MR. HUNSPERGER: ‑‑ disc jockey is going to say. They can keep the radio on and know that they don't have to run and quick turn it off or whatever. They could listen to it when they're taking their kids to school. They love that safe and fun for the whole family, and that's kind of what we use all the time. For example, our stations in Calgary and Edmonton, this October, we used October as Thanksgiving month instead of just using a Thanksgiving Day, and we, basically, celebrated and thanked, you know, the paramedics in our cities or thanked the police or thanked the fire department. We started to get people to think in more positive ways, and I think that's what parents are looking for. I think that's what families are looking for, something where a family can actually enjoy listening to radio, and the music and the fun that they can have on that, you know.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13088 And we know ‑‑ I mean, it's hard for us to prove this, but we know that way over half of our listening audience are people who don't necessarily go to any church or have anything to do with attendance in a church, but they just like the positive inspirational type of music.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13089 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Market profitability is a factor the Commission considers carefully when determining whether or not our radio market could sustain the licensing of new stations without, of course, creating undue impact on the existing stations. What other factors do you think the Commission should consider together with market profitability in arriving at a determination as to whether a new station should be licensed?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13090 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, I, personally, think, you know, format. I mean, there's no other applicant that's applying for a gospel music radio station here in Regina outside of us, and there is no gospel music radio music station to be heard in Regina, and so I ‑‑ you know, I look at diversity. We can offer that diversity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13091 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Okay. I believe I've reached ‑‑ reached the end of the questions that I have for Touch Canada Broadcasting. And we started out hoping for a good day. I hope it was good for you too. It's ‑‑ thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13092 MR. HUNSPERGER: It was, thank you very much.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13093 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Madam Chair...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13094 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13095 Vice‑Chair Arpin...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13096 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13097 The ‑‑ I'm sure that you are cognizant of the religious broadcast policy of 1993 that the Commission has released way back and ‑‑ no, not 1993, but there is one in 1996 ‑‑ the public notice was in 1993, but there was also another public notice in 1996. But I want only to have your comments regarding a section of the policy that we'll read to you, which says, "The Commission considers that the broadcast of programming by other denomination and fig(ph) groups offers a valid means of providing an alternative point of view, as well as serving the needs of the local community. It is not sufficient, however, merely to make airtime available to other groups. A broadcaster must actively solicit such programming to ensure that different views are presented." As an applicant to ‑‑ for a licence for Regina, do you think that this section of the policy applies to your application?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13098 MR. HUNSPERGER: I don't think our application is a religious application, if that's what you're referring to. We've always, you know, been in this discussion back and forth. We have resisted, and we've resisted this even all the years that I can remember even being before the Commission in the '70s and '80s. I do not believe that what we are doing with gospel music is to be considered religious ‑‑ a religious station, and I believe the policy says that, that the music and the banter that the disc jockeys play and all that kind of thing are not religious.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13099 And the other thing, sir, is that the brokered spoken word that we do play, we don't feel that we play it any more than any other broadcasters who play brokered programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13100 So, therefore, I guess our struggle that we struggle with is that if we're required to give this balance ‑‑ and let me just say this. In some ways, bringing other faiths into our situation can hurt us financially because people aren't looking for that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13101 What people are looking for is they're looking for a gospel music radio station, and these brokered programming that we put on supplement or add to, if you want to put, that music. Back in 1994, if you go back to the Edmonton Journal and get some of my quotes that I quoted when I first started, I didn't want to have any brokered spoken word on our radio programming. I wanted it to all be music, but then reality hit about finances and revenues, and so then we started to bring that on for that basis.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13102 So, I mean, that's where we struggle in agreeing with the Commission on whether or not we should be airing other religions, other faiths, or whatever. I mean, we don't have anything against them. I mean, if the Muslims wanted to start a radio station, more power to them. I believe in that freedom within this country. That's our struggle.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13103 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: But if a broker was coming to ‑‑ at your door with a Muslim program, what will you say, and what will you do?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13104 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, I will probably tell him ‑‑ first of all, I've never had that happen.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13105 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: And he comes with money.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13106 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, (a), in our Edmonton situation, for example, even in our Calgary situation, I'd have to tell him, sorry, we're sold out. The problem is for them, and they realize it as well, this might not be the best place for them to put their program for them financially, for them community, for anything else.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13107 We've done some programming and learned over our short history that, you know, you can put programming in there for resources or for money, but if it's not jibing with your listening audience, you're hurting yourself as well as you're not getting any points with that person who is broadcasting. And I can even put this ‑‑ take this out of the religious realm and put it in sports. We added the sports section. We thought, well, sports, you know, and we can bring in money and more revenue. It didn't work. Even Dr. Laura didn't work in our Edmonton situation. People wanted southern gospel music.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13108 So when the sales guys are under pressure with revenue, and the program guys have to make a decision on what they do, they sit down and discuss, and they have to make some hard decisions of what's going to give us the biggest audience so that we can get the greatest revenue in order for us to make this fly. And you know by looking at our reports that we turn in every year, this is, you know, not the kind of format that other broadcasters are beating up each other to try to play. They just know that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13109 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: It may come.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13110 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, I hope so. I hope that we can break through this and show everybody that this is a moneymaking situation. But that's the struggle we have, and that's even the struggle that we have here. Nothing against anybody or any faith, but that's the struggle we have.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13111 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13112 Those are my questions, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13113 THE CHAIRPERSON: Commissioner Cugini...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13114 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13115 Thank you and good afternoon. Just a couple of questions for you, Ms Smith. I do remember you appearing with Touch Canada in Edmonton, so if I'm repeating some of the questions that we asked you there, I apologize in advance, but it's late in the day. You said in your presentation that the Shai Awards have been in operation for five years now?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13116 MS SMITH: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13117 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Are they annual awards?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13118 MS SMITH: It is, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13119 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And where is the home base of the Shai Awards?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13120 MS SMITH: Our home base is in Calgary, Alberta.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13121 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: In Calgary?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13122 MS SMITH: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13123 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Do you receive any other funding, other than what you receive from Touch Canada?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13124 MS SMITH: Yes, we do.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13125 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And what sources of funding do you have?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13126 MS SMITH: We have some investors to other sponsors, such as World Vision and some other local companies within Calgary that support what we're doing.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13127 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And are the awards broadcast on radio, maybe on a Touch Canada radio station?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13128 MS SMITH: Our awards ‑‑ our awards have been fed through broadcasting, and we've done our press conferences on announcing the nominees. We are also televised Global and also on Vision Network, and we've been televised in the U.S., Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13129 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Congratulations, that's very impressive.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13130 MS SMITH: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13131 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Do you receive any promotional time from radio stations?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13132 MS SMITH: We do.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13133 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And is that ‑‑ because you say, also, that the Shai Awards are given in various locations across Canada. Does that mean that the actual show travels across the country?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13134 MS SMITH: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13135 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And do you receive radio airplay from the radio stations in the cities where the Shai Awards are being held that year?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13136 MS SMITH: It is ‑‑ that is also correct, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13137 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: And from other radio stations from other parts of the country?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13138 MS SMITH: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13139 COMMISSIONER CUGINI: Thank you. Thank you very much for that information.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13140 Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13141 THE CHAIRPERSON: We were talking with an intervener earlier today about present and future. Maybe I'll start off, I understood from your application that you were going to be doing 52 hours of voice tracking, but the numbers have all changed, have they not? If I'm looking at the bottom of your program schedule, there are live shifts, 40 hours, voice tracked, 52, so they haven't changed. Syndicated, 19 ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13142 MR. HUNT: No, they have not changed.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13143 THE CHAIRPERSON: They have not changed?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13144 MR. HUNT: No, I learned my lesson.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13145 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah, okay.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13146 THE CHAIRPERSON: Live shifts, what does that really mean? Is it somebody here talking?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13147 MR. HUNT: Absolutely. A live shift, a warm body in the chair speaking through the microphone, just like I am right now.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13148 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm. In a booth here?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13149 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13150 THE CHAIRPERSON: And for that, you are going to have ‑‑ do I get it right that you're going to have a half a person here?
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13151 MR. HUNT: Yes, we literally cut them in half and ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13152 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah, one FT ‑‑ one‑half FTE, yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13153 MR. HUNT: ‑‑ bring them out.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13154 THE CHAIRPERSON: Are you going to have a half a person doing that programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13155 MR. HUNT: No, the ‑‑ half of a full‑time person. It's hours, not physical.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13156 THE CHAIRPERSON: I know, I ‑‑ yes, mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13157 MR. HUNT: So, basically, we have a morning drive person with a co‑host, which is the half‑time person, and then an afternoon drive person, and the rest will be voice tracked.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13158 THE CHAIRPERSON: So how many FTEs is it, full‑time equivalents?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13159 MR. HUNT: 2.5.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13160 THE CHAIRPERSON: 2.5?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13161 MR. HUNT: And then year two will be three.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13162 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And they are going to be doing for you 40 hours per week?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13163 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13164 THE CHAIRPERSON: And if you were a commercial station, Mr. Hunsperger, how could you, based on that ‑‑ oh, no, then you would be doing 52 hours of voice tracking, and that would be originating where?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13165 MR. HUNT: Well, it ‑‑ I think we've had this discussion once before. It originates from the radio station. It's recorded ‑‑ as I mentioned before, initially not all of our voice tracking is going to be done by Regina people, they'll be done from existing Touch Canada staff from Edmonton and from Calgary, specific to the Regina area. They're not talking about Calgary events and Edmonton events, they're specifically talking about what's going on in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13166 THE CHAIRPERSON: The word is, does it originate with the station?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13167 MR. HUNT: That's a difficult one for me to wrap my brain around because, yes, it does originate. It comes from this particular ‑‑ these studios.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13168 THE CHAIRPERSON: But it will ‑‑ it is possible that it will be produced as if it originated from Regina, in Edmonton?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13169 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13170 THE CHAIRPERSON: And if that is the case, then if you were a commercial enterprise, as you assert you are, Mr. Hunsperger, you could not solicit advertising because you need 42 hours.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13171 MR. HUNT: If I could just direct your attention over the to the Countdown show that we air on the weekend, which is also a program that we produce, and it is also the Power Prays program on the weekends as well.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13172 THE CHAIRPERSON: Well, I've got live shifts her, 40 hours per week, on this document entitled program schedule.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13173 MR. HUNT: You're talking about local programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13174 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13175 MR. HUNT: Yes. The Power Prays, if you look at the weekend programming guide. I'll just direct your attention to the weekend programming guide.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13176 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13177 MR. HUNT: And if you look, Saturday nine ‑‑ 9:00, that's a two‑hour program ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13178 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13179 MR. HUNT: Top 20, that's produced by us. Power Prays during the weekend is a four‑hour program. That is an additional six hours, which would bring the total of local, outside of voice tracking to 46 hours.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13180 THE CHAIRPERSON: So ‑‑ oh, okay. So then this is only Monday to Friday? This document, program schedule?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13181 MR. HUNT: No, that's Monday to Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13182 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: It totals up to 126 hours?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13183 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13184 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: So you have life shifts, 40 hours, voice track 52, syndicated 19, and brokered, 15. The total is 126.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13185 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13186 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: What Madam Cram is saying here is you need ‑‑ in order to solicit local advertising, the ‑‑ as per the regulation that has been enacted all over the ‑‑ need to have 42 hours of local programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13187 MR. HUNT: If I could just point out, the 19 hours where it says syndicated or TCB‑produced programs, that's where that extra six hours is ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13188 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: And TCB ‑‑ and what you're saying is that out of that TCB programming, there's six hours ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13189 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13190 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: ‑‑ produced here in Regina?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13191 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13192 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Which has to ‑‑ will add up to the 40 hours so ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13193 MR. HUNT: No, it's in addition to the 40 hours live programming.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13194 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Yes, okay, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13195 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So Power Prays and the top 20 also?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13196 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13197 THE CHAIRPERSON: Produced by TCB in Regina?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13198 MR. HUNT: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13199 THE CHAIRPERSON: For Regina?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13200 MR. HUNT: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13201 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So instead of ‑‑ if we broke it down into live productions for Regina, made in Regina, it would be forty ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13202 MR. HUNT: Six.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13203 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ six hours, voice tracked, 52, syndicated, 13?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13204 MR. HUNT: Right. But the difference ‑‑ the reason why I didn't put it there is because it's not a live program. Those are produced by our people, but it is prerecorded, but it is locally produced.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13205 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah, okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13206 MR. HUNT: That's why I didn't put it as a live amount.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13207 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And the syndicated stuff, if I've read that correctly, that is at page ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13208 MR. HUNT: That's the weekend programming guide. It has the ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13209 THE CHAIRPERSON: Isn't that at three of your Supplementary Brief, and that is ZJAM, Red Better Rock(ph), Gospel Greats; is that it?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13210 MR. HUNT: Yes, that's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13211 THE CHAIRPERSON: Are any of those Canadian?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13212 MR. HUNT: No, not at the current moment.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13213 THE CHAIRPERSON: And the brokered programming, is any of it Canadian?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13214 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, like we had mentioned before, we tried to ‑‑ we tried to get that brokered programming as Canadian. Yes, we tried to get ‑‑ we tried to get local broadcasters to do that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13215 THE CHAIRPERSON: The brokered programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13216 MR. HUNSPERGER: Yeah, that's what you asked, is any brokered programming Canadian? Was that your question?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13217 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13218 MR. HUNSPERGER: And I said, yes, we had answered that earlier where we tried to do our best to get local broadcasters to provide that kind of thing. Like, for example ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13219 THE CHAIRPERSON: I'm talking about Focus on the Family, the ones that you're brokering.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13220 MR. HUNSPERGER: Yeah, right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13221 THE CHAIRPERSON: Insight for Living.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13222 MR. HUNSPERGER: Right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13223 THE CHAIRPERSON: Are those Canadian programs?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13224 MR. HUNSPERGER: No.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13225 THE CHAIRPERSON: That was my question.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13226 MR. HUNSPERGER: Okay, okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13227 THE CHAIRPERSON: So on the one hand, you want to be a commercial radio for the benefits it will give you for not having to provide balance, but on the other hand, you want to air Christian music, which is at a ten‑percent level, and given the amount of American programming, I would find it difficult for you as a commercial station ‑‑ I don't know if you could ‑‑ well, there's ‑‑ it's spoken word, so I guess you could. It's a ‑‑ you're a weird duck. It's a very weird duck. Why, if you disagree with the fact that you are a religious broadcaster, have you agreed in the past to COLs regarding adherence to the policy?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13228 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, my understanding is those were general COLs, and we will accept general COLs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13229 THE CHAIRPERSON: And you will accept that COL here?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13230 MR. HUNSPERGER: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13231 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes. And when you talk about staffing and the fullness of time, I have to tell you, I'm not keen on that. Will that depend on the results of the Regina station only, or will that depend on the results of the Touch net ‑‑ or Touch group as a whole?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13232 MR. HUNSPERGER: Each station is judged on its own. The only difference on that will be the news, the expansion of our news, local news network kind of thing that we will do. That will be a combination of all the stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13233 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So based on your projection, when would a news bureau be developed here?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13234 MR. HUNT: Well, it's actually being developed now. I mean, again, it's in its ‑‑ it's in infancy stages, but ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13235 THE CHAIRPERSON: When would there be an actual news person here ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13236 MR. HUNT: The day we get a licence and we get on the air. There would be a ‑‑ a ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13237 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, but those are programming people.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13238 MR. HUNT: ‑‑ part‑time person ‑‑ the part‑time person is the news reporter, the part‑time in the morning. That will become a full‑time position in ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13239 THE CHAIRPERSON: In one year?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13240 MR. HUNT: ‑‑ in your ‑‑ in the second year, correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13241 THE CHAIRPERSON: In year two of the licence?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13242 MR. HUNT: Right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13243 THE CHAIRPERSON: And you would accept a COL to that effect?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13244 MR. HUNT: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13245 THE CHAIRPERSON: What further expansions are planned, and when will it happen?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13246 MR. HUNT: That's very difficult because we ‑‑ only you folks know how many radio stations we're going to be able to get, and that really is what it boils down to, is the economy as a scale. The more radio stations, the more people we can hire.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13247 THE CHAIRPERSON: Well, I have to tell you that I have a problem with you proposing to take a half a million dollars out of this community in local revenue with having two and a half people here, and very little in, what I see, an investment in this community. So I want you to, specifically, tell me when you're going to build up to being a real station with only the slight, you know, inputs going back to mother station; otherwise, why aren't you getting a network licence?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13248 MS GILLESPIE: I believe Mr. Hunt was talking 2.5 was in regards to the programming staff, just the on air staff. We also have a half‑time writer, a half‑time production person, two and a half equivalent full‑time positions in sales, a half‑time tech person, and a full‑time admin person.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13249 THE CHAIRPERSON: And that's starting day one?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13250 MS GILLESPIE: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13251 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm. And when will the Regina station be able to take over more responsibility for programming and there be less voice tracking? When can you tell me there will be no voice tracking, and it will be locally Regina originated programming from 8:30 to noon, 12:30 to 2:30, 5:30 to nine? When will that happen? What year of your licence?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13252 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, we've never discussed it in that terms, but I would say that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13253 THE CHAIRPERSON: Well, you're in my community now, and you're talking about taking money out of my community, and I want to know what you're going to give back. And the Broadcasting Act not only has a cultural aspect to it, it certainly has a commercial aspect to it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13254 MR. HUNSPERGER: Right, right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13255 THE CHAIRPERSON: So I'm listening. You're giving money to Shai Awards, you're not giving anything to Saskatchewan by way of talent development, so when can you have a full station?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13256 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, we are giving money to talent development to local artists here. Even local artists here in Saskatchewan have already received benefit from the Shai Awards.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13257 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, from Shai, okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13258 MR. HUNSPERGER: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13259 THE CHAIRPERSON: That's fine. Tell me when I'm going to see a full station?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13260 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, as soon as the profits dictate. I mean, that's dictated by the revenue.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13261 THE CHAIRPERSON: Can I impose a COL of the year three or year four, or why aren't you asking just for a network licence, and when you can actually present to this country, this city, a real station that is a Regina station that is affiliated with you and has all your good programming but is a Regina station, why don't you apply then?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13262 MR. HUNSPERGER: Well, because, you know ‑‑ I mean, the reason why we're applying for what we have now is so that the Regina people, you know, can get as much local as possible with this format and that we can continue to sustain it financially.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13263 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you. You have your two minutes now to tell us why we should licence you. Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13264 MR. HUNSPERGER: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13265 Well, thank you so much for the opportunity for us to come before you and to share about this. I think that the reason why we should get a licence here for our Regina ‑‑ for the Regina market is because of the people here in Regina who are excited and requested even for us to come and to apply here and to have a gospel music specialty format station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13266 Many mothers, father, and families are looking forward to this. We believe we bring diversity to the market, and we are so excited about the possibility.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13267 We're thankful for all the people that have come and shown that this could be possible, and we thank you for this opportunity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13268 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13269 We're now going to take five minutes for CJVR to set up.
‑‑‑ Upon recessing at 1809 / Suspension à 1809
‑‑‑ Upon resuming at 1811 / Reprise à 1811
LISTNUM 95 \l 13270 THE CHAIRPERSON: Madam Secretary...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13271 THE SECRETARY: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13272 Before we proceed to the next applicant, I would just like to indicate that Touch Canada has filed a document regarding the 2007 artist developments and budget figures with respect to Shai Gospel Music. It will be placed on their application file.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13273 We will now proceed with the next applicant with respect to items 13 and 14 on the agenda, which are applications by Radio CJVR Limited for a licence to operate two English‑language FM commercial radio programming undertakings in Regina. One of the new stations would operate on frequency 103.1 megahertz (channel 276C1) with an effective radiated power of 100,000 watts (non‑directional antenna/antenna height of 146.2 metres).
LISTNUM 95 \l 13274 The other new station would operate on frequency 106.3 megahertz (channel 292C1) with an effective radiated power of 100,000 watts (non‑directional antenna/antenna height of 146.2 metres).
LISTNUM 95 \l 13275 Appearing for the applicant is Mr. Gene Fabro, who will introduce his colleagues. Given your two applications, you will be given 30 minutes for your presentation. Mr. Fabro...?
PRESENTATION / PRÉSENTATION
LISTNUM 95 \l 13276 MR. FABRO: I'll let Mr. Singer introduce our panel.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13277 THE SECRETARY: Sorry, Mr. Singer, then.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13278 MR. SINGER: Thank you, and good evening, Madam Chair, Commissioners, and Staff. Thank you for allowing us this opportunity to appear before you once again.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13279 Before we begin our presentation for two new FM licences in Regina, I'd like to introduce the members of our team. My name is Ken Singer. I am vice‑president of broadcast operations for our company.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13280 On my right is the president and owner of Radio CJVR, Gene Fabro.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13281 To Gene's right is Linda Rheaume, administrative manager for Radio CJVR's two stations in Melfort and our new FM station in Whitecourt, Alberta, CIXM‑FM.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13282 Next to Linda is Dean Sinclair, a broadcast veteran whose 30‑year career includes programming, on‑air sales, and senior management experience.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13283 Dean has provided input and direction for our proposed formats here today.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13284 Next to Dean is Jessica Schnell, director of research services at Insightrix Research of Saskatoon, and with her is Corrin Harper, a partner at Insightrix Research.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13285 To my left is Kevin Gemmell, recently appointed station manager and sales manager of our two Melfort stations, CJVR‑FM and CKJH‑AM. Kevin has been with our company over ten years.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13286 To his left is Dave Marcoux. Dave has 24 years of experience in Saskatchewan broadcast media sales, and for the past six years, has served as CJVR's Saskatoon territory sales manager.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13287 Behind me is Joan Therens, a past president and lifetime member of the Board of Directors for the Saskatchewan Music Educators Association, and next to her is Harrison Thunderchild, a distinguished member of the Aboriginal community, an accomplished educator, and a prominent member of the office of the Treaty Commissions Speakers Bureau.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13288 MR. FABRO: Madam Chairman ‑‑ Madam Chair and Members of the Commission, Radio CJVR welcomes this opportunity to appear before you today seeking approval to establish two new FM radio stations on frequencies 103.1 and 106.3 to serve Regina and surrounding communities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13289 Each of the new FM undertakings, Classics 103 and Oldies 106 are essential components to CJVR's strategic broadcast plans for Saskatchewan. Approval of these applications will bring much needed programming diversity, listeners' choice, and competitive balance to Regina's radio market, while significantly improving CJVR's ability to compete in today's challenging broadcast environment. As a Saskatchewan career broadcaster, CJVR is totally committed to growing its radio business through acquisitions and new licensing opportunities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13290 Classics 103 and Oldies 106, coupled with the dual FM proposals for Saskatoon and our existing Melfort stations, will allow CJVR to increase its critical mass and play a larger role in Saskatchewan's private radio sector.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13291 CJVR is also engaged in a parallel strategic plan for Alberta where we recently acquired and launched CIXM Whitecourt, appeared before the Commission in Edmonton in June seeking FM licences for Grande Prairie and Fort McMurray, and, earlier this week, for Medicine Hat.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13292 Today, Canada's private radio sector is rapidly evolving from a collection of independent operators to large, commonly owned multiple chains of stations with the result that it is becoming increasingly more difficult for smaller broadcasters, like CJVR, to grow its critical mass through acquisitions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13293 It is equally difficult for motivated independents to seek out new licensing opportunities because with the paucity of broadcasting frequencies in large to major‑sized markets, multiple chain operators are now targeting small to medium‑sized markets to further increase their broadcast holdings.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13294 Given these realities, the Commission's call for Regina and Saskatoon is critically important to CJVR as it represents a rare, if not final opportunity for our company to meaningfully increase its critical mass in Saskatchewan.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13295 MR. SINGER: Madam Chair, one of the many challenges facing the Commission in today's broadcast environment is to strike a balance between preserving a diversity of news voices in the market and the benefits of permitting increased ownership consolidation. The issues of diversity and consolidation can, in our view, be offset by licensing motivated independent broadcasters, like CJVR, with the credentials to be a viable licensing alternative to larger corporate interest and even more concentration.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13296 It is our view that the balance weighs heavily on the side of concentration in the Regina market at the expense of diverse news voices, given that all six radio stations in the market are controlled by two ownership groups.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13297 Of further concern to CJVR is the fact that 26 of the 35 English‑language commercial radio stations in Saskatchewan are controlled by two ownership groups. That's almost 75‑percent ownership concentration within the province, the highest in Canada.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13298 Approval of CJVR's proposed new FM stations will help correct both the diversity and ownership concentration issues by establishing competitive balance within Regina's radio market through the addition of two distinct alternative news voices and increased ownership diversity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13299 MR. FABRO: Madam Chair and Commissioners, in responding to the call for Regina and Saskatoon, we concluded that pursuing such rare opportunities in highly concentrated markets would require a bold initiative on the part of CJVR.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13300 As such, in preparing the business plan for Regina, CJVR recognized the challenge that any new entrant would have to face in competing with two ownership groups who dominate the market with three radio stations a piece.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13301 It was obvious to CJVR that in order to compete in such a concentrated environment, it was necessary to develop a strategy that would help negate the competitive advantage enjoyed by the two incumbent ownership groups.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13302 MR. GEMMELL: Madam Chair, upon completion and review of a consumer demand study and an economic analysis of the market by Insightrix Research Services of Saskatoon, CJVR found the answer to its competitive approach for Regina in the IRS survey results, apply for two FM licences.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13303 Essentially, the IRS study underlines the degree to which Regina's 35 to 54‑year‑old demographic spectrum is underserved relative to musical listening needs and preferences. Further, the study points to the changing trends within Regina's population, which shows that 30 to 39‑year‑old demographic component has steadily decreased over the past six years. This trend reverses itself, however, within the 40 to 44 age group, and reflects a major increase in the 45 to 54‑year‑old component, which is the cohort of Regina's maturing population that is the fastest growing and the least served.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13304 Despite Regina's steady growth in population and a strong, vibrant economy, it only has six local commercial radio stations serving in excess of 200,000 persons within the principal marketing area.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13305 The six stations provide a broad range of musical styles that primarily cater to the 18 to 34 listenership spectrum at the near exclusion of the 35 to 44 and 45 to 54 age groupings.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13306 As an integral part of its consumer demand study, IRS presented a 15‑item battery of music genre to 500 respondents aged 18 to 54. Results of the IRS music survey showed that classic rock, at nearly 74 percent, was the most popular style of music among respondents.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13307 Upon hearing a description of CJVR's proposed new classic rock station, an overall total of nearly 74 percent of respondents stated that it was somewhat likely or very likely that they would listen to the station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13308 In breaking out the projected listenership levels within age groups that Classic 103 proposes to target, 80 percent of respondents aged 45 to 54 followed by 75 percent of those aged 35 to 44, and 66 percent of respondents aged 25 to 34 all indicated they were likely to listen to the new station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13309 MR. SINGER: Madam Chair, with respect to oldies, 43 percent of respondents overall indicated that they listen at least sometimes to oldies, and those in the 45 to 54 age group are most likely to listen. While the 35 to 54 age group is the prime demographic for this format, 39 percent of respondents in the 18 to 24 said they listen to oldies music.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13310 Beyond the economic and competitive considerations, the fact that both the Regina and Saskatoon radio markets have the same classic rock and oldies musical programming voids at the expense of the underserved 35 to 44 and 45 to 54 demographic segment in each market called for a bold initiative.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13311 In determining which combination of formats would be the most compatible in terms of added diversity and listener choice, programming, fulfilling listener needs and preferences, and having the latest impact on existing stations, it was evident that classic rock and oldies made the most sense.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13312 Approval of Classic 103 and Oldies 106 will largely meet the needs of the 35 to 44 and 45 to 54 age groupings. By serving this growing sector of Regina's population with two FM services, both stations can specifically target their primary audiences, and, thus, provide better service than one station trying to be more things to more listeners within the broader 35 to 54 demographic.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13313 Taking the results of the IRS survey and measuring them against the music formats currently available in Regina, there is no station that specifically targets either the classic rock or oldies formats, thus, ensuring that maximum diversity will be achieved.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13314 MR. SINCLAIR: Madam Chair, CJVR in programming Classic 103 musically will specialize in playing classic rock including milestone rock albums. The playlist will feature music by international artists such as Tom Petty, Pink Floyd, Santana, The Eagles, The Rolling Stones, The Beatles, and Canadian artists like Bryan Adams, The Guess Who, Neil Young, Tragically Hip, and Streetheart, to name but a few.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13315 We'd like to provide the Commission with a sense of how Classic 103 will sound and feel musically with the following musical montage.
‑‑‑ Audio clip / Clip audio
LISTNUM 95 \l 13316 MR. SINGER: Madam Chair, CJVR, in bringing fresh diversity to Regina radio, will compliment rather than compete with existing music formats. Classic 103 will further enhance that diversity through its in-studio production of two special music programs. In this regard, CJVR will produce a 20‑minute program called Canadians On Track, where four Canadian rock artists will be featured Monday through Sunday.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13317 The second program entitled Saskatchewan Rocks, is a 60‑minute weekly special in prime time on Saturday at 8 p.m. exposing Saskatchewan artists to help advance their careers. As such, each week Classic 103 will aggressively seek out new artists and showcase their talent through interviews and playing their music. In addition to delivering great music, Classic 103 will provide its listeners with inclusive locally relevant community‑driven programming that is reflective of the daily news events and activities that are happening within the broader Regina community.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13318 MR. GEMMELL: The IRS consumer demand study held few surprises in terms of what Regina and area residents are looking for on a consistent daily basis from their local radio station in relation to basic informational priorities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13319 Essentially, the stated listener needs and preferences included local news, weather, road conditions and closures, school closings and bus cancellations, updates on local community events and activities, national news, sports scores, and news and information about other communities and their events and activities from across the province.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13320 On the cultural side, the IRS study indicates significant interest by Regina residents on updates on the entertainment scene and cultural events, the exposure and promotion of local Canadian artists and performers, and a reflection of local history, people, events, and cultural heritage, and lifestyle programs and features.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13321 Beginning with daily news coverage, Classic 103 will bring an independent news voice to the Regina market that will increase diversity and provide an alternative perspective on issues and events of direct relevance and interests to residents throughout the coverage area.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13322 CJVR's proposed new Classic 103 will employ a news director and four full‑time news reporters, who will form the station's newsroom team.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13323 Classic 103 will broadcast locally originated news at the top of the hour and every half hour in the mornings, and again during selected hours throughout the day. The station will also Broadcast News on weekends.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13324 One of the news reporters will staff the proposed CJVR Legislative News Bureau, which will keep listeners informed of legislative activities, as well as other governmental affairs and actions of direct relevance and impact on them and their communities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13325 The Legislative Bureau will also figure prominently in the news and public affairs coverage provided by CJVR's other Saskatchewan‑based stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13326 In all, the station will provide over five hours of scheduled newscasts per week plus additional surveillance material when necessary and as it becomes available.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13327 Given the importance that respondent's placed on traffic and road conditions, a minimum of 12 reports will air daily between 6 a.m. and 7 p.m. During extreme weather conditions, Classic 103 will air more frequent weather bulletins, engage the use of weather watchers, and bring in additional people to staff the snow desk and ensure locals are frequently updated on school closings and school bus cancellations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13328 In view of the increasing role the Internet plays in people's lives today, CJVR feels there is a unique opportunity for Classic 103 to further reach out and interface with its various publics via this communication medium.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13329 One such initiative, Listener Feedback, will provide a means whereby listeners will be invited to comment on issues and concerns relative to Regina and area via e‑mail to Classic 103's website. Our staff will review the e‑mails daily and choose those that do justice to the topic for on‑air presentation each day of the broadcast week.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13330 MR. SINGER: Madam Chair, CJVR feels it is extremely important that Classic 103 reach out in inclusive fashion to the rapidly growing Aboriginal population and the increasing number of ethnic groups among others, and through a series of unique spoken word initiatives, build bridges of understanding between people in communities by giving them a radio voice.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13331 As such, CJVR has devised an inclusive broadcast plan for Classic 103 that enables it to keep a finger on the pulse of daily events and activities occurring within Regina and surrounding communities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13332 This will be achieved in a number of ways, including the recruitment of a network of correspondents who will be responsible for regularly providing Classic 103 with news and information specific to their communities. These 90‑second reports, known as Community Connections, will be featured four times daily as part of Classic 103's regular program schedule.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13333 As well, information on current and upcoming events and activities within the coverage area will be highlighted every hour by Classic 103's Culturally Speaking information snippets.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13334 Included among the special features that will be incorporated daily into Classic 103's program schedule are the following: Regina Lifestyle features will cover a wide range of topics including parenting, health, investing, legal, and other such issues. City Beat will provide Regina residents with reports and updates on need‑to‑know information on local, civic, and municipal issues. Classic 103's Live from the U of R will report on a wide range of campus events and activities. The School of the Day weekday reports will cover happenings within Regina elementary and secondary schools.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13335 CJVR, in recognition of the dramatic growth of the Aboriginal communities in both Regina and Saskatoon felt it was important that initiatives be taken to help foster greater understanding and communication between Aboriginals and the broader community.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13336 As such, CJVR is most fortunate to have retained the services of Mr. Harrison Thunderchild, a distinguished member of the Aboriginal community, an accomplished educator, and a prominent member of the office of the Treaty Commissioners Speaker's Bureau. Mr. Thunderchild has agreed to serve as CJVR's Aboriginal special program coordinator. As such, he will help produce and host a series of special features to be known as The Bridge. These special two‑minute features will run twice daily and share the Aboriginal community's culture, highlight its successes and help foster a greater understanding and awareness of Native issues and concerns.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13337 In addition, Mr. Thunderchild will contribute to a special 15‑minute segment on the Sunday News Magazine Show of Regina Perspective.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13338 MR. FABRO: Madam Chair and Commissioners, as we mentioned earlier, the combination of CJVR's proposed Classic 103 and Oldies 106 will largely meet the programming needs and listener preferences of Regina's underserved 35 to 44 and 45 to 54 demographic spectrum.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13339 The significant upturns that Regina and Saskatoon are experiencing in their 45‑plus populations have put them in step with the overall North American trending towards an aging population that will only grow larger as the baby boomers' generation continues to mature.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13340 While there are significant opportunities to be realized in addressing the growing needs and preferences of the best educated and most affluent demographic group in history, there is also the challenge to elevate the focus of many beyond the younger segments of the population and begin to recognize the changing dynamics of the 45‑plus end of this demographic scale.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13341 As such, the Regina and Saskatoon radio markets are a good place to start, given the fact that the very demographic component is growing the fastest; namely, the 45‑plus listeners are, at the same time, being served the least.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13342 MR. SINCLAIR: Madam Chair, currently, those wanting to listen to oldies music have to tune into a variety of stations with formats ranging from Country 620 to The Wolf. The problem is that none of these stations play more than a small sampling of oldies music. Like their classic rock counterparts, oldies listeners are left to their own devices to source their favourite music from out‑of‑market stations among other options.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13343 CJVR's newly proposed Oldies 106, if approved, will quickly move to fill that music void in the Regina market with its unduplicated oldies music format. CJVR, in programming its proposed new FM station musically as a dedicated oldies music station, rather than some hybrid variety, will feature classic hits from the '50s and '60s by artists such as Elvis Presley, the Beach Boys, the Beatles, and Buddy Holly, and Canadian artists like Joni Mitchell, Paul Anka, Bobby Curtola, Gordon Lightfoot, Andy Kim and The Poppy Family, to name but a few.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13344 We would like to provide you with a sense of how Oldies 106 will sound and feel musically with the following montage.
‑‑‑ Audio clip / Clip audio
LISTNUM 95 \l 13345 MR. SINCLAIR: Oldies 106 will also feature specialized nostalgic programming for the 45‑plus demographic, such as big‑band music from the '40s. There will also be an album component to the station featuring classic albums by the biggest artists of all time.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13346 MR. GEMMELL: Madam Chair, in creating even more musical diversity, CJVR will produce in studio two special musical programs, namely, the Great Canadian Song Book and Canadian Folk, both of which will profile and play the music of Canadian pop and rock artists of the past, as well as Canadian folk music artists.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13347 The Great Canadian Song Book is a 20‑minute segment that will run each day at 3 p.m. featuring up to four different Canadian rock and pop artists from the past.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13348 Canadian Folk is a 15‑minute program that will run every day featuring Canadian artists in the folk music genre. Artists such as Gordon Lightfoot, Anne Murray, Ian and Sylvia, Bruce Cockburn, and Gene MacLellan, to name but a few will be profiled and have their music played.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13349 As is the case with Classic 103, Oldies 106, in addition to delivering great music, will provide its currently underserved 45 to 54 audience with a comprehensive blend of spoken word programming initiatives that will address their news and informational needs and preferences.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13350 Further to the news, informational and special feature programs that Oldies 106 will share with Classic 103, like Community Connections, Regina Lifestyle, City Beat, The Bridge, and Listener Feedback, there are also a number of special programs that are exclusive to Oldies 106. These include Prairie Mosaics, This Week on Campus, This Week in Politics, Huskies Football, and Stock Market Report.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13351 I would note that a fully detailed description of the Oldies 106 planned news and information programming, in addition to those special features that are exclusive to the station, are contained in the Supplementary Brief filed with our application.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13352 I would like to briefly comment on the news magazine show, A Regina Perspective, which is a 60‑minute production that will run Sundays at 11 a.m. The program will feature four 15‑minute segments. One segment will be devoted to the Aboriginal community, a second to Regina's diverse ethnic communities, a third to Regina's business community, and the fourth will be an Omnibus component.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13353 MR. FABRO: Madam Chair and Commissioners, CJVR brings to Regina a proud legacy of achievement and commitment to the development, promotion, and exposure of Canadian talent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13354 In our applications for Regina and Saskatoon, CJVR and my family have made an unprecedented level of direct expenditures on Canadian talent development initiatives across a diverse field of educational, cultural, and music‑driven endeavours.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13355 Approval of our Classic 103 and Oldies 106 applications will yield a minimum of 2.45 million in direct expenditures, along with an indirect on‑air expenditure budget of two million.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13356 The combined total of 4.45 million in direct and indirect expenditures would have a profoundly beneficial impact on Saskatchewan talent at all levels for many years to come.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13357 My family has been highly supportive of local Canadian talent over the past 15 years, and we are proud of CJVR and what it has been able to achieve for local Canadian talent from its Melfort‑based radio station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13358 The opportunity to grow our critical mass in Regina and Saskatoon has translated into higher expenditure levels and a broadened mandate for CJVR to do its very best for Saskatchewan and Canada's developing young talent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13359 Madam Chair, my family's passion and commitment to help make a difference in the lives of young Canadian talent is, perhaps, best exemplified by the Horizons Unlimited initiative, which is driven by the basic philosophy that talented youth should not have their goals and dreams for a musical career limited or sidetracked by a lack of resources and proper mentoring.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13360 Hence, through the financial system and attendant support structure inherent within its three‑tiered approach, Saskatchewan's talented youth, through hard work and commitment, can live their dreams through their realization that, indeed, their horizons are unlimited.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13361 Given the number of Canadian talent development initiatives and the limited time for this presentation, I have listed each project and its seven‑year dollar amount.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13362 While each of Classic 103 and Oldies 106 are listed separately, the dollar amount ‑‑ the dollar figures shown are based on both licences being granted. We have also filed with this application the figures for each application on the basis of only one licence being granted.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13363 The total direct expenditure budget based on approval of both Classic 103 and Oldies 106 totals 2.45 million as follows: Aboriginal scholarships, 550,000; University of Regina Faculty of Arts ‑ Journalism, 370,000; U of R Fine Arts Music Program, 300,000; Horizons Unlimited, 433,000; Music 101, 178,000; opening acts, 360,000; FACTOR, 99,000; Regina Mosaic Cultural Festival, 75,000; Regina Symphony Orchestra, 65,000; and the Saskatchewan Recording Industry Association, 55,000.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13364 MR. GEMMELL: Madam Chair and Commissioners, a recent supplement in the Globe and Mail states that, "Saskatchewan's landscape may be flat, but its economy is clearly on a roll." That comment while, perhaps, ruining the day for the doomsayers brigade, succinctly describes the momentum of Saskatchewan's diversified economy as evidenced by the fact that the province's economic growth rate has outpaced the national average for three consecutive years, according to Statistics Canada.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13365 The local market economies of Regina and Saskatoon inextricably linked to Saskatchewan's provincial economy are buoyant in terms of economic growth and activity.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13366 Both cities have been beneficiaries of the rural to urban population shift that has been occurring for some time and will likely continue at the expense of many of the 100 small communities that our Melfort AM and FM stations are dependent on from a revenue perspective.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13367 An examination of some of the key economic indicators relative to Regina in terms of population, retail sales, average family income, and employment rates, among others, are all heading in the right direction along with healthy forecasts for continued growth.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13368 With respect to the local broadcast economy, CJVR concluded that 16 percent or $15 million of the $92 million of available advertising revenues in the Regina market should be obtainable by all local radio. We believe the six existing stations currently garner about 12.8 million and operate profitably. This would leave about 2.2 million for our new market entrant.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13369 Further to our market study, however, as noted in a report filed relative to these proceedings, of the entire province's radio advertising expenditures of 64 million, about 56 percent or 36 million is captured by all radio in Saskatoon and Regina. Splitting the potential radio revenue based on the population proportions would be 46 percent Regina and 54 percent Saskatoon, or 16.6 million in Regina, and 19.4 million in Saskatoon. Using these market figures, the available advertising for a new entrant in Regina would be closer to $3.8 million.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13370 MR. SINGER: Madam Chair, the following are but some of the many important considerations that my colleagues and I feel warrant approval of CJVR's applications for two new FM programming undertakings for Regina: Classic 103 and Oldie 106 FM's unduplicated music formats will add significant programming diversity and listener choice to Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13371 Through their unique music formats and locally relevant spoken word initiatives, we will meet many of the unfulfilled listener needs and preferences of Regina's underserved 35 to 54 demographic.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13372 The new programming formats will bridge the service disparity gap within the 25 to 54 age groups whose combined demos represent the majority of Regina's adult population.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13373 The proposed new music formats and community‑driven spoken word programming will repatriate out‑of‑market listeners and draw former listeners away from alternative audio options, resulting in new listeners and increased hours of tuning to Regina's local radio spectrum with minimal impact on existing stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13374 Approval of both licences will bring badly needed competitive balance, ownership, diversity, and an alternative news voice to the Regina market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13375 CJVR will establish a Legislative News Bureau to cover legislative sessions and governmental affairs and activities. The listening public's desire for the proposed new stations, coupled with their commercial appeal, will result in new radio dollars being attracted to the Regina market with minimal impact on existing stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13376 Approval of CJVR's proposed new FM stations will provide advertisers with a highly cost‑efficient advertising vehicle to target and serve Regina's maturing 35 to 54 adult population.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13377 In all, CJVR's total direct expenditures commitment to Canadian talent development, should both its applications be approved, is a minimum of 2.45 million as well as a $2 million budget for indirect on‑air expenditures.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13378 Approval of our stations will result in the creation of 26 full‑time and two part‑time employment equity opportunities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13379 CJVR's inclusive local programming approach will reach out to the rapidly growing Aboriginal population and the diverse multi‑cultural groups and provide them with a mainstream radio voice.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13380 CJVR's proposed new FMs will maximize the utilization of frequencies 103.1 and 106.3 by extending their unduplicated music formats to meet the needs and preferences of Regina's underserved 35 to 44 and 45 to 54 listenership spectrum.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13381 While the foregoing does not capture all of the benefits that will flow to Regina‑area residents should both applications be approved, they are a fair reflection of the positive manner in which Classic 103 and Oldies 106 will serve the public interest and advance and strengthen Canada's private broadcasting system.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13382 MR. FABRO: Madam Chair and Commissioners, in completing our Regina presentation, I wish to underline the absolute need for CJVR to grow its radio business by significantly increasing the size of its critical mass.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13383 Unlike several of our competitors at this hearing, CJVR does not have the luxury of serving large concentrated urban markets like Calgary, among others.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13384 There is a major difference in serving 150,000 people in a hundred small communities scattered across northeast Saskatchewan and operating radio stations within the urban environment of Regina and Saskatoon.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13385 The Fabro family is proud of what we have accomplished in Melfort. We have enhanced and expended the AM and FM operations to their maximum potential. As such, our main task these days is to maintain the status quo in the light of growing challenges from alternate audio platforms and worrisome of all, the ongoing erosion of our listener and revenue base, which is one of the by‑products of the rural to urban migration trend within Saskatchewan's population, and then there is a growing out‑migration to Alberta.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13386 Madam Chair, we are bullish about radio broadcasting, and we want to do a lot more of it in Saskatchewan and Alberta. As such, we have not come here to this hearing with a small broadcaster's cap in hand, rather we have come forward with a full plate of major commitments that we want the opportunity to implement for the benefit of Regina and Saskatoon's underserved 35 to 54 demographic spectrum, and the 150,000 rural residents of northeast Saskatchewan who are dependent on CJVR's daily lifeline to their communities.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13387 On behalf of CJVR ‑‑ of my CJVR colleagues and the Fabro family, we wish to thank the Commission for this opportunity to be here today, and we respectfully ask for your approval of our two applications.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13388 Thank you, Madam Chair. My colleagues and I will be happy to answer any of the questions the panel may have.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13389 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13390 I wanted to start off, I guess, Mr. Fabro, with the strategy in Saskatchewan, and I notice that you say in the second paragraph of your presentation today that, "Each of the undertakings here are essential components," and I take it that ‑‑ I mean, your first preference is that we would licence all four, Saskatoon and Regina. What would be your second preference?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13391 MR. FABRO: I guess that's a little like asking, do you want to win all four games that you're going to play or just two? We came to the hearings wanting to win all four games. We don't go out and try to lose two or try to win two, it's all four.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13392 THE CHAIRPERSON: And ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13393 MR. FABRO: I don't ‑‑ I guess it really depends on what the makeup ‑‑ if you were ‑‑ it depends on if you want two markets to ‑‑ or in ‑‑ there are two markets, four licencees. I mean, that's probably the worst preference. If none of them were ours, then that would be the worst. If we got one, that would be the second good ‑‑ the second better, I guess, and the best, we'd have all four licences. So obviously the more licences we can get, the better position we're in.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13394 THE CHAIRPERSON: So, I mean, if you don't get all four, you would take one or two or three?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13395 MR. FABRO: Absolutely.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13396 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And if you don't get all four, would you prefer ‑‑ because I noticed you ‑‑ there was some discussion in the ‑‑ in your memo about national advertising and that it would be best to have the same format in each of ‑‑ if two were licensed, if one for Saskatoon and one for Regina, it would be best to have the same format licensed in each market for the purposes of advertising nationally?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13397 MR. FABRO: From a national ‑‑ from a national perspective, that's true.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13398 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes. And do I take it, then, the one that you would want ‑‑ based on your financial projections here, the one that you would prefer to be licensed here, worst‑case scenario for Regina alone, would be the classic rock?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13399 MR. FABRO: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13400 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes. And your ‑‑ that's your worst case. Your second worst case would be both classic rock in Saskatoon and here?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13401 MR. FABRO: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13402 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm, okay ‑‑ no, that would be ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13403 MR. FABRO: I mean, the worst case from our perspective would be receive no licences. The second worst would be to have probably one licence in each market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13404 THE CHAIRPERSON: That would be second worst?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13405 MR. FABRO: Well, I guess I would have to discuss that with my colleagues, whether it's ‑‑ actually, no, when I think about it, we'd probably rather have two licences in one market ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13406 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13407 MR. FABRO: ‑‑ for efficiency, but, I mean, there are a lot of permutations and combinations, and ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13408 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13409 MR. FABRO: ‑‑ we can go through them all if you want, I guess.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13410 THE CHAIRPERSON: No, well, I mean, I'd much rather know ‑‑ know that than us proceed to choose for you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13411 MR. FABRO: Mmhmm, okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13412 THE CHAIRPERSON: I mean, I know we were talking about in Charlottetown having asked Newcap that, you know, if they knew that Santa came, you know, but if they didn't know Santa came, you know, what would they want?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13413 MR. FABRO: Yeah, would Santa want ‑‑ bring a fire truck or a baby doll or something, right?
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13414 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, mmhmm, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13415 MR. FABRO: Well ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13416 THE CHAIRPERSON: So we may as well know rather than ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13417 MR. FABRO: Yeah, so we can answer that when we come before you on the Saskatoon hearings, or we can present something, if you wish, tomorrow.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13418 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, Saskatoon is fine.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13419 MR. FABRO: Okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13420 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, mmhmm. So can I ‑‑ let's talk, then, about Regina. And if both Regina applications were granted, how many staff would you have in the news area?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13421 MR. SINGER: We will defer that question, Madam Chair, to Linda Rheaume, our administrative manager who has those figures for you, if you don't mind.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13422 MS RHEAUME: Thank you, Ken.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13423 Madam Chair, if both stations were licensed, we would have five news people, one news director, and then four other news reporters.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13424 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And how many in programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13425 MS RHEAUME: Like, announcers?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13426 THE CHAIRPERSON: And ‑‑ yes, mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13427 MS RHEAUME: We would have four and a half program announcers, two program directors, a.m. drive people, two midday announcers, two ‑‑ oh, that number was wrong, it's eight and a half, not four and a half, sorry. Two midday, two p.m., two swing full‑time positions, and then a part‑time swing person to total eight and a half.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13428 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, yes. And would there be ‑‑ you say only one news director?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13429 MS RHEAUME: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13430 THE CHAIRPERSON: So there would be a single news room?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13431 MS RHEAUME: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13432 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And would the newscasts be the same on each station, and that's not your area, Ms Rheaume, I know.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13433 MR. SINGER: The ‑‑ essentially, the ‑‑ I guess the ‑‑ you know, the top stories would be the same each day, but they'd certainly be written, where applicable, as they appeal to the two different audiences for the two formats. We do that similarly with our stations in Melfort operating a country format and an oldies format. There are some variances, but, generally, it's one news person preparing the newscasts for both radio stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13434 THE CHAIRPERSON: And is it the same newscast that goes on each?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13435 MR. SINGER: I would say probably more ‑‑ more similar than dissimilar. There would ‑‑ as I say, once in a while, there would be a story that we would not run on our oldies station if it was about, say, a current rock artist or something in the news and say how does that relate to our ‑‑ our oldies audience?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13436 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And if it was classic rock alone, did I ‑‑ I understood the staff would be a news director plus four ‑‑ or a news director ‑‑ now, maybe I misunderstood. Just ‑‑ Ms Rheaume, just give me a number, so I don't ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13437 MS RHEAUME: Three‑and‑a‑half people.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13438 THE CHAIRPERSON: Three and a half?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13439 MS RHEAUME: Mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13440 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm. And in programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13441 MS RHEAUME: Four and a half.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13442 THE CHAIRPERSON: Four and a half?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13443 MS RHEAUME: The half person being a swing part time.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13444 THE CHAIRPERSON: And you have given me, thank you very much, the last page of your presentation, and on a stand‑alone basic basis, the classic rock would still have those ‑‑ those are minutes a week, are they?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13445 MR. SINGER: You're referring to the spoken word programming, Madam Chair?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13446 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, I'm sorry, where's the news? Yeah, there would be 131 minutes a week of news ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13447 MR. SINGER: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13448 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ 52 of weather, 67 of sports, and 57 of traffic?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13449 MR. SINGER: Correct. We're ‑‑ the news commitments are equal on either station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13450 THE CHAIRPERSON: On either side on a stand‑alone basis?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13451 MR. SINGER: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13452 THE CHAIRPERSON: And if it were classic rock alone, how many programming people would there be, announcers?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13453 MS RHEAUME: One station would be four and a half.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13454 THE CHAIRPERSON: I'm sorry, I've asked that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13455 MS RHEAUME: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13456 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, so if either station were licensed alone, there would be three‑and‑a‑half news and four‑and‑a‑half programming?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13457 MS RHEAUME: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13458 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, mmhmm. And if they were licensed alone, when would either station be live to air?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13459 MR. SINGER: Madam Chair, I have that figure. Our live would be 108 hours weekly, and our voice tracked hours would be 18.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13460 THE CHAIRPERSON: And that is if one ‑‑ on a stand‑alone, if either one were licensed ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13461 MR. SINGER: There would be no difference.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13462 THE CHAIRPERSON: No difference either way?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13463 MR. SINGER: Either way.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13464 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So you would accept a COL that there would be live‑to‑air programming of a minimum of 108 hours during the broadcast week?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13465 MR. SINGER: Yes, we would.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13466 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thanks. Now, then there is the other programming, and I'd like to go back to your document, the spoken word programming, and I must say, this is kind of ‑‑ this does not include DJ banter, right?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13467 MR. SINGER: No, it does not.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13468 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah, which it appears everybody else is saying is about 12 hours a week?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13469 MR. SINGER: I would say 10 to 12 hours.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13470 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, mmhmm, yes. So this shows the other spoken word programming ‑‑ and so the ‑‑ would it be the same Community Connections that would be on the classic and the oldies?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13471 MR. SINGER: Yes, it would be. We would likely vary the times on the two radio stations in terms of ‑‑ like, we would have programs in rotation, so we wouldn't have the same ones running on both stations at, say, 8 a.m. They would be different programs, but they'd be in a rotation, but, essentially, they are the same.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13472 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. The same with Culturally Speaking?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13473 MR. SINGER: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13474 THE CHAIRPERSON: Now, what about ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13475 MR. SINGER: Well, no, I'm sorry, no, there might be ‑‑ you know, the Culturally Speaking feature really is an update on events going on in the communities, so, again, there might be occasions where the content might not be targeted to ‑‑ to the one station over the other. So, I guess, again, similar to the news answer, there would be minimal differences in that, but, again, it's ‑‑ these are ‑‑ a lot of these snippets of information and Culturally Speaking will come from audience contacting us with that information. And if we feel it's appropriate for both stations, we'll certainly give them ‑‑ that event exposure on both stations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13476 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Now, Regina Perspective, you've got nothing here, so ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13477 MR. SINGER: I am sorry, that should be ‑‑ it's not in the column, but the total is there. It's 60 minutes. That's a typo. It's 60 minutes on our oldies station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13478 THE CHAIRPERSON: It's 60 on the oldies?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13479 MR. SINGER: Yes, it is, on Sundays at 11:00.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13480 THE CHAIRPERSON: This Week on Campus will only go on the oldies?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13481 MR. SINGER: Correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13482 THE CHAIRPERSON: Government and Politics, is this the same program?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13483 MR. SINGER: Yes, it is.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13484 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Now, the U of S Huskies, you just didn't put a time in?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13485 MR. SINGER: I didn't put a time in because that ‑‑ we carry the ‑‑ we originate and carry the Huskies football broadcasts from our AM station in Melfort, and there are eight regular season games plus playoffs in a season, so it's ‑‑ I don't think it's fair to calculate that into our regular spoken word programming. Our intention would be, if successful in Regina and Saskatoon, to ask for Network to run those broadcasts in ‑‑ during football season.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13486 THE CHAIRPERSON: And the Listener Feedback, this is people phoning in and you putting it back. Is that the idea?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13487 MR. SINGER: Phoning in using our website and ‑‑ and we would create a daily program that would play the highlights of that listener feedback.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13488 THE CHAIRPERSON: And ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13489 MR. SINGER: Now, that ‑‑ and, Madam Chair, that ‑‑ because they'd be calling in to one or the other station would be two different programs in terms of if they called in to ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13490 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, right, okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13491 MR. SINGER: ‑‑ a listener feedback on Classic, that would run on Classic.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13492 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And I take it that Regina Lifestyle, City Beat, Live from the U of R, School of the Day, The Bridge, are only on the classic rock because you think they more fit the format; is that it?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13493 MR. SINGER: Well, that is correct, but there are components of those features that will be integrated into the segments of the Regina Perspective that is running on the oldies station on Sundays.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13494 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, okay. And, again, the same for Prairie Mosaic, the Stock Market, This Week in Politics, you think that it only fits with that ‑‑ with the one format?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13495 MR. SINGER: I'm sorry?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13496 THE CHAIRPERSON: I'm sorry, the same with the Prairie Mosaic, The Stock Market Report, This Week in Politics, you think it fits with that ‑‑ with the oldies format?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13497 MR. SINGER: That was our determination in evaluating where they would run, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13498 Madam Chair, it's just been pointed out to me that ‑‑ and I apologize for this. We have an additional 28 minutes because The Bridge program does run on both the classic and the oldies. So there would be 28 minutes added to that 10 hours and 45 minutes on the oldies side.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13499 THE CHAIRPERSON: So how much of the programming, then, is shared?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13500 MR. SINGER: I would ‑‑ well, Community ‑‑ the first two items, Community Connections, Culturally Speaking, Government and Politics would be shared. The Listener Feedback would be different. Those ‑‑ again, the items as mentioned, the Lifestyle and so on features, there might be a portion of that that is recycled into our Sunday program on the oldies, so portions of that could be shared. Prairie Mosaic, these are strictly oldies station features, so I guess the first two items plus Government and Politics on a regular basis.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13501 THE CHAIRPERSON: How when there's going to be one, two, three, four, five, six, seven ‑‑ I'm going to say about eight hours common programming, including news, weather, sports, how can that be seen as the optimum use of the frequency when it's going to be the same programming on a second frequency?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13502 MR. SINGER: Well, I guess there certainly is some sharing there, but it's sharing it with two different audiences. We feel that, you know, we're going to be attracting or sharing this information or targeting it to ‑‑ there would be some crossover between our formats in terms of dialing back and forth, I suppose, but, generally, these two formats should hold a loyal listenership to each one of them. So I think we are really exposing some information to two distinctly different audiences. The reason we chose to combine these is really the synergies of operating a combination of radio stations. The resources are ‑‑ I guess that seems to work best with the resources that we budgeted for to put on the air. I think this is just a starting point for our radio stations. We ‑‑ I'm sure as we get on the air we'll be approached to try different things on the air because of these initiatives, and some may be unique to the one station or the other.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13503 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Moving on to CTD. I note that you didn't ‑‑ or staff noted that you said in the application that you would be paying the 3,000 to the CAB, but it's not in your financial projections. That's just a typo?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13504 MR. SINGER: To FACTOR?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13505 THE CHAIRPERSON: No, CAB. In the application, it says, under the issue of CTD, it says that ‑‑ I don't know if it's ‑‑ which application it is. It could be the second application.
‑‑‑ Pause
LISTNUM 95 \l 13506 THE CHAIRPERSON: 7.2 of the form ‑‑ well, maybe ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13507 MR. SINGER: I think I've found the page.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13508 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes, you see, 7.2 in each of them it says, "The applicant undertakes to accept as a COL to participate in the Canadian talent development plan developed by the CAB, as set out in Public Notice 95, dated November '95. It's amended time to time, approved by the Commission. X, yes." That's a $3,000 issue in both cases, so I'm not going to go crazy about it.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13509 MR. SINGER: Yes, we did indicate that, and I guess my interpretation was that that was a part of the CAB ‑‑ FACTOR/CAB talent fund, I guess, in our calculations here, so it's an oversight on our part, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13510 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, yes. Now, you have scholarships in each, and they are Aboriginal scholarships, U of R Faculty of Arts ‑ Journalism, U of R Fine Arts. You don't mean to limit ‑‑ limit as such that Aboriginals wouldn't be eligible for either the second kind of scholarship or the third kind of scholarship?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13511 MR. SINGER: No, but we do have both Aboriginal and non‑Aboriginal scholarships there, so ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13512 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, okay, so they ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13513 MR. SINGER: ‑‑ so they are earmarked. The Aboriginal scholarships has a budget of its own as do the ‑‑ our University of Regina Journalism and U of R Fine Arts Music scholarships.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13514 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So those are for non‑Aboriginals only or ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13515 MR. SINGER: Yes, we have both, so in the Aboriginal scholarships, there are broadcast journalism and music scholarships available to the Aboriginal applicants, and then we have University of Regina Journalism and U of R Fine Arts Music scholarships for non‑Aboriginals as well. So there's two components or two ‑‑ two programs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13516 THE CHAIRPERSON: You surely don't mean that, do you?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13517 MR. SINGER: Pardon me?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13518 THE CHAIRPERSON: You surely don't mean that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13519 MR. SINGER: I'm not quite sure what your question is, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13520 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Why wouldn't Aboriginals be eligible for both?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13521 MR. SINGER: They are.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13522 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, they are?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13523 MR. SINGER: They're ‑‑ we've earmarked $310,000 on our classic station and 205,000 on our oldies station for a total of $515,000 for Aboriginal scholarships of which these are broken down either journalism or music. So those are available to Aboriginals.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13524 THE CHAIRPERSON: And so the next two ones are not?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13525 MR. SINGER: And the next two are separate scholarships available to non‑Aboriginals.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13526 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. I noticed that in your ‑‑ you refer to institutions in your Supplementary Brief, and you talk about the U of R, and you never mention FNUC at all.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13527 MR. SINGER: Never mentioned, I'm sorry?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13528 THE CHAIRPERSON: FNUC, First Nations University.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13529 MR. SINGER: No, we did not, and because we ‑‑ I guess we ‑‑ you know, we felt that we ‑‑ we discussed the programs with the university level. It's not to say we couldn't add to that, but we certainly ‑‑ you know, we discussed it with the two universities, Saskatoon and Regina, and did not include that. I guess it was ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13530 THE CHAIRPERSON: Did you look at the INCA program with FNUC, the Indian and Native Communications ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13531 MR. SINGER: I guess we did initially. We just ‑‑ we felt that, you know, working with the large university, we weren't going to restrict this. I mean, if there were opportunities there as well, we certainly would consider those, but we talked to the University of Regina in terms of assisting us with the administration of this, so I think that wouldn't be a problem.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13532 THE CHAIRPERSON: So the U of R is going to assist you in ascertaining the recipients for the Aboriginal awards, so clearly, it will ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13533 MR. SINGER: So that ‑‑ that would be our hopes that that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13534 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ clearly it would then only be Aboriginals who applied to the U of R who would be eligible for that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13535 MR. SINGER: At this stage, that is the only organization that we have talked to about this, yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13536 THE CHAIRPERSON: And you're aware that far and away FNUC gets the majority of applications from Aboriginals to attend?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13537 MR. SINGER: We'll certainly take that under advisement to add that. I ‑‑ as I say, that ‑‑ that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13538 THE CHAIRPERSON: And you haven't discussed with FNUC about administering it at all?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13539 MR. SINGER: No, we have not.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13540 THE CHAIRPERSON: No. Now, the number ‑‑ I'm at scenario one. The number of scholarships in scenario one for each station, the amounts go up. So is that an increase in the number of scholarships or in the amount of the scholarship?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13541 MR. SINGER: The reason the numbers go up is we've ramped up all of our CTD initiatives. They're not the same/consistent year one to seven. They start smaller, and as our cash flow increases, we plan to increase the CTD initiatives. So, basically, these are $2,500 scholarships, so you'll find the numbers as you go across the page are multiples of 2,500.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13542 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, okay. And so you are ‑‑ the selection is going to be done with the university selecting the particular faculties of fine arts and journalism? Are they going to be choosing the recipients?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13543 MR. SINGER: We would work with ‑‑ through the university, certainly, to develop a type of program. I ‑‑ that ‑‑ you know, the measurement of the scholarships clearly lies with the universities, and we don't feel that we should be in that role in selecting the students ourselves. So it's our hopes that through the educators we could work with them and have them administer this and report back to us as to the ‑‑ as to the use of the funds.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13544 THE CHAIRPERSON: So have you actually talked to the journalism school?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13545 MR. SINGER: We have only just generally outlined our overall plans to commit the dollars. We haven't really gotten to the stage of actually working the fine detail of the mechanics of this.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13546 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So you're not really clear on how the applicants would be recruited, but the recipients would be chosen by the college itself; is that ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13547 MR. SINGER: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13548 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And you wouldn't ‑‑ what's the word? You wouldn't set the criteria, the college would set the criteria?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13549 MR. SINGER: Well, I think we would ask for their direction and advice on what is the best way to manage this. Again, I draw on their expertise because I really feel that ‑‑ again, this is an area that is out of our realm, and the educators certainly have some criteria that we would adapt. We would give them our input, but I feel that, you know, our role is to be supportive for these initiatives.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13550 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm. The Horizons Unlimited project, this money goes directly to, is it, Mrs. Therens or Theren?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13551 MS THERENS: Therens. Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13552 THE CHAIRPERSON: It goes to the association of which you were the president for, I'm assuming, some considerable time? So this money goes directly to you and ‑‑ or not to you, the Music Educators and the Orchestral Association, and how will the monies be used by your association, Mrs. Therens?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13553 MS THERENS: The monies will be administered by the Saskatchewan Music Educators Association, and according to the breakdown that has already been established and outlined in the Horizon's Unlimited brief. Essentially, there are three programs: The starter program for inner city youth, the intermediate program, and the senior level that will provide direct financial assistance to the two junior orchestras in Saskatchewan, the south Saskatchewan youth symphony in Regina and the Saskatoon Youth Orchestra in Saskatoon.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13554 THE CHAIRPERSON: In Saskatoon?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13555 MS THERENS: And the breakdown of the amounts there, I just happen to have it. I believe it's 50 percent of that initial funding will go to the starter level, 15 percent will go to the bursary level at the intermediate, and 35 percent will go to the senior level. The Saskatchewan Music Educators Association and the Orchestra Association, but, basically, SMEA would administer and manage the budget and the bookkeeping. They are in a very, very good position to be doing this because they're a member organization of Sask. Trust, the lottery foundation.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13556 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, okay, yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13557 MS THERENS: And the conditions for them in accountability and in bookkeeping are very stringent, so it ‑‑ the SMEA does have the credibility to handle those kinds of funds and administer them on behalf of the program.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13558 THE CHAIRPERSON: And the intermediate program, that consists almost entirely of bursaries, do I have it right?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13559 MS THERENS: It's my understanding, yes, that it does.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13560 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. And how would the recipients be chosen?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13561 MS THERENS: Here again is where a number of organizations come into play. Because the Saskatchewan Music Educators Association, the Orchestra, the Band Association, choral, Saskatchewan Music Festival Association, and the Registered Music Teachers of Saskatchewan are all under the umbrella of Sask. Culture. They are in communication with each other. Each of these organizations, through its educators and through its boards of directors, each have different criteria set out as to how to select students with talent. I would suspect that there is ‑‑ there are very good things in each one of those because some of them involve instrumental as opposed to vocal and so on, so you need different types of criteria. But given the fact that these organizations are in communication with each other, I would think that the best way would be for them to strike a committee to collaborate as to what the criteria would be for qualifying for the bursary and also for the selection process. All of these organizations are quite familiar with selecting and auditioning and choosing, so that's almost ‑‑ with a little refinement and a little collaboration, I can't see a problem there.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13562 THE CHAIRPERSON: How you visualized it? Okay. And the senior program is direct financial assistance to the youth orchestra themselves? Is that what it is?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13563 MS THERENS: Yes, and it's ‑‑ the youth orchestras in both Regina and Saskatoon are probably the best mechanism for young people who get into an orchestral situation to move through those junior type of orchestras into the senior orchestras in the province. Now, programs ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13564 THE CHAIRPERSON: Like, what would the money actually be used for? That's what I'm ‑‑ you know, for them to travel ‑‑ like, I know the youth orchestra here, they travel from all of southern Saskatchewan, you know, every Saturday or something and practice.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13565 MS THERENS: Well, yes, that ‑‑ it's because the south Saskatchewan youth orchestra is made up of students that live in many parts in southern Saskatchewan, and so they travel into town. But much of that is parental support.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13566 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm. So what would this money ‑‑ the direct financial assistance, what would it be used for; do you know?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13567 MS THERENS: There's a program, I believe it's in here too, and it should be described that to utilize the orchestras within the education component, within schools.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13568 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, right, travel of, that's right, mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13569 MS THERENS: It can be done through an Artist in Residence, it could be done through the symphony's youth or the seniors performing in schools. Another innovative program that the Toronto symphony has done is to adopt ‑‑ adopt a player, where a school will adopt a player from the symphony orchestra. There are a variety of different theme and variations as to how this could happen, but the funding would go towards that ‑‑ those types of programs.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13570 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13571 Mr. Singer, my concern is if you could ‑‑ how are you going to ensure that this is going to be all eligible CTD? That's going to be my issue.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13572 MR. SINGER: I think we'll ‑‑ you know, we're certainly aware of the items that ‑‑ or the types of initiatives that do qualify, and when we set up these programs, we're just going to have to make sure they do qualify because obviously we put the money on the table, and we don't want to come back and find out after we've spent it that it doesn't qualify.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13573 And, Madam Chair, if I could just take a step backwards, and I apologize for ‑‑ my mind just went blank when you asked about the First Nations University of Canada, and we've been so busy preparing applications that it all seems like a bit of a blur. We're here for five applications, but I guess the one reason we haven't approached that ‑‑ or that educational facility is because the qualifying initiatives under the definition of the CTD are ‑‑ or the CRTC are either journalistic scholarships or music scholarships, and that college does not offer either of them. So I guess that was our thinking. Now ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13574 THE CHAIRPERSON: Or I think if you look at the curriculum for the INCA program, it may very well qualify.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13575 MR. SINGER: Well, we will investigate it further ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13576 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah, mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13577 MR. SINGER: ‑‑ but I think that's why we kept going down the road and ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13578 THE CHAIRPERSON: Because they end up being qualified and do work in various broadcasting institutions.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13579 MR. SINGER: Yeah, well, and we will certainly take it under advisement that if there are opportunities to involve them, we would certainly consider that under this initiative.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13580 THE CHAIRPERSON: The same issue on Mosaic. How do you ensure that it is going to be eligible CTD?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13581 MR. SINGER: The administration of the Mosaic funds would be handled through the Regina Multi‑cultural Association, and we would give them clear guidelines and request documentation that musical entertainment was ‑‑ was paid the allocated dollars that we ‑‑ we passed on to them.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13582 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Now, you did say that your FACTOR money would be directed to local artists in Regina. If you ‑‑ has FACTOR agreed to that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13583 MR. SINGER: Further to our discussion on the same topic in the Medicine Hat application, we are in the process of getting a letter from FACTOR with those commitments. If they could not make those commitments to us to assure us that that was going to be done to our satisfaction, we would shift the money to the Sask. Recording Industry Association, which is another beneficiary of our CTD.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13584 THE CHAIRPERSON: The SRIA, was it, that you ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13585 MR. SINGER: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13586 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes? Okay. Now, let me see. The opening act ‑‑ this is booking of the bands, and you're also going to air it on your classic station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13587 MR. SINGER: Where possible, we are going to do that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13588 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, okay.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13589 MR. SINGER: That is not an every occasion plan because, technically, it might not be possible in a lot of situations.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13590 THE CHAIRPERSON: Good, mmhmm. And the cost of recording it for broadcast are not included in that amount?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13591 MR. SINGER: The recording portion? No, it is not. That ‑‑ those funds are directly to the performers.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13592 THE CHAIRPERSON: Who bears the admin cost of that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13593 MR. SINGER: The radio station would bear that, that would be an admin function. We hope to develop a person. Should we be successful in acquiring more licences, we are already planning to designate someone within our staff as a Canadian talent development coordinator.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13594 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Music Business 101, and I ask myself when I see things like this if ‑‑ are you, in fact, just reinventing the wheel? Doesn't SRIA do this?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13595 MR. SINGER: SRIA does, but we've had discussion with them about that, and they'd love to do more, and we feel this might be an opportunity to work together to make something like this happen on a bigger scale.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13596 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So you are going to allocate the money, and then are you going to do it in conjunction with SRIA, or are you ‑‑ what are your ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13597 MR. SINGER: We developed this initiative to actually coordinate this on our own, and in further discussion, like long after we developed this plan. And then in discussion with SRIA about our other initiatives that we are dedicating to them, they felt, gee, that's a great idea. They certainly looked at it as what a great opportunity to work together on something and just make it that much better. So if that happens ‑‑ if it doesn't happen, I'm not sure, but we see that as an opportunity that can be ‑‑ became apparent to us after we put the initiative together.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13598 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm. Because otherwise, we're going to need the cost breakdown, we're going to need to know how you're going to choose the students, how you're going to let them know that the program is available, who is eligible, how are you going to create the awareness?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13599 MR. SINGER: We ‑‑ well, we feel that anybody that wants to attend this is eligible. They're not ‑‑ they don't receive this money, the instructors ‑‑ the cost is to put this event on. As far as ‑‑ you know, we would be promoting this on the air and on our website, that it's happening. We don't see this as a charge admission situation. Certainly, you know, we're going to learn as we go, but in talking to various musicians and bands, they think it's a tremendous idea because, you know, what musician wouldn't be interested in acquiring more knowledge about their proposed careers?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13600 THE CHAIRPERSON: Who ‑‑ how would the facilities be paid for?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13601 MR. SINGER: We would pay for the facilities. We would rent ‑‑ rent a facility to host this and ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13602 THE CHAIRPERSON: So would that be part of the budget of this Music Business 101?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13603 MR. SINGER: I believe, if you give me a moment, I think we did do a breakdown of this ‑‑ we ‑‑ it must be in our Medicine Hat application. That was one of the deficiency questions because we're proposing a similar initiative there, and we did do a breakdown, I don't have it here in front of me, as far as the cost breakdown of that project.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13604 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. So it ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13605 MR. SINGER: I could certainly file a copy of that response with our expenses listed.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13606 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay, that sounds good.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13607 MR. SINGER: And we could do that by tomorrow.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13608 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes. Programming, classic rock. Who is your core audience, Mr. Sinclair?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13609 MR. SINCLAIR: Thank you, Madam Chair. The core audience for classic rock is 35 to 44.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13610 THE CHAIRPERSON: The skew?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13611 MR. SINCLAIR: More male.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13612 THE CHAIRPERSON: And median?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13613 MR. SINCLAIR: 38.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13614 THE CHAIRPERSON: I like it when we get later in the day, people listen to the questions, they answer very briefly, it ‑‑
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13615 THE CHAIRPERSON: Now, I know you did a monitoring with CFWF and CKCK, and what I really want is ‑‑ do you have a percentage of duplication? Because it was so many songs out of so many songs, and last night I wasn't about to take out my calculator because I didn't know if I could use it right.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13616 MR. SINGER: If you would have called me, we could have got together, and I could have helped out with that. We were doing ‑‑
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13617 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah. 2:51.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13618 MR. SINCLAIR: Madam Chair, we do have the ‑‑ a breakdown of that for Regina. The percentages, essentially, with classic rock compared to the market run about 15 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13619 THE CHAIRPERSON: 15?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13620 MR. SINCLAIR: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13621 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm. The oldies, this is Beach Boys. You talk about Elvis, you talk about big band. And big band, of course, as you know, Mr. Sinclair, is category 3. How much will be coming from category 3?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13622 MR. SINGER: We haven't finalized the program. We felt that it could be a very workable ingredient with our oldies format, but what we're thinking of is a blocked program, likely a Saturday night, where we may do eight to midnight, big band Saturday night type program, and we certainly don't see it as a main ingredient of our format, but it would be a specialized program and certainly one that, depending on the feedback for that type of programming, we'll see how the audience likes it, but it is a ‑‑ it would be a specialized program that we would run ‑‑ at this point, our plan is once a week.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13623 MR. SINCLAIR: We like to use, Madam Chair, the word spice.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13624 THE CHAIRPERSON: Spice?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13625 MR. SINCLAIR: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13626 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Well, I'd like to have a COL because you only have to have ten percent Cancon, so can we have a COL limiting the amount to five percent?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13627 MR. SINGER: I think we wouldn't have a problem with that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13628 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Oldies, a difficult format on FM because of the hit restrictions. How are you ‑‑ and, in fact, I keep thinking about CKY moving from AM to FM and the whole structure of the good old oldies sort of went down the ‑‑ I mean, it's not an easy transition. So, Mr. Sinclair, how you going to make it a success ‑‑ or advise.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13629 MR. SINCLAIR: That's why they hire me.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13630 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13631 MR. SINCLAIR: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13632 I think one of the things to consider with oldies is that ‑‑ and we get caught up in it as broadcasters these days. There's a misconception that only oldies are hit‑oriented records. There's a lot of music from those eras that hadn't received airplay even in the condensed playlists, and I hate to say that some years ago I was a program director in this market on an oldies station, CKCK, although Mr. Singer worked with me. There was a lot of music excluded from the format at that time, and I think that one of the things that we consider is, although various groups have tried to do it, I think we could make it work considering we're talking '50/'60s and into the '70s, and there's a lot of product that just hasn't received airplay. This market, as Saskatoon, is devoid of anyone playing oldies more than 10 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13633 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Economic synergies.
‑‑‑ Pause
LISTNUM 95 \l 13634 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, my goodness, I forgot. What is the core audience, Mr. Sinclair?
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13635 MR. SINCLAIR: Sorry, Madam Chair, the core audience is 45 plus. It's ‑‑ it's bullet would be around 50, 51.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13636 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. That's the median?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13637 MR. SINCLAIR: That's correct.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13638 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13639 THE CHAIRPERSON: And the skew?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13640 MR. SINCLAIR: Skew? Well, the skew will be closer to 50/50. It's not necessarily a male‑driven format. It's a pop ‑‑ you have to remember, too, that oldies by nature is a pop‑driven format, so there's a great female appeal to it. But the male component of it ‑‑ pardon me for popping. Men enjoy the station a little more. We find that in markets where I've programmed across Canada. Women will come along certainly. It's kind of like that A&W commercial with the fellow that takes the old Mustang out, and they like the music, so I hope that helps.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13641 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13642 THE CHAIRPERSON: Do you anticipate economic synergies with your present stations between the Regina stations?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13643 MR. SINGER: Yes, we do, and we have actually worked out some numbers, primarily in the ‑‑ in the people department because it's one of the major costs, and I'll ask Linda to elaborate on that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13644 MS RHEAUME: Thank you, Ken.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13645 Madam Chair, like every other applicant here, the common synergies are always ‑‑ or as we have said also before, are with our accounting and our traffic departments. Your news departments have some common synergies, you know, sharing stories, you know, back and forth. Our writing department will also see synergies with two of our writers being housed in Melfort with, you know, the rest of the writers spread between the other licences. So with, you know, sharing ideas and creative storming, those synergies. So I would say, as well as the overall general management of all of the radio stations together, we'll, you know, make the radio stations all fit the same format. So, you know, between four and six people probably, you know, are sharing duties. With two ‑‑ if we were to run both of the Regina stations separately as separate radio stations without having the common ‑‑ having them together, we would, you know, probably have to have ten extra people to run them as two separate stations on our employment projections.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13646 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Now, I found it a little interesting. You're saying that you'll get an increase in national revenue because ‑‑ with the oldies because of the affluent aging population. I didn't think the advertisers were convinced yet. I thought they thought we were worthless and that they couldn't sell the above 54 demographic?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13647 MR. SINGER: Well, that may be one point of view or the point of view of several advertisers, but our ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13648 THE CHAIRPERSON: Not that I'm over 54, but, you know, I mean ‑‑ yeah.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13649 MR. SINGER: I'm sure that that's a story that's told from time to time, especially by our competitors for our oldies station in Melfort, but we're finding differently, that we do have a fair amount of advertisers who target very successfully and cost efficiently with our oldies format. And I'll turn it over to our station manager in Melfort and sales manager, Kevin Gemmell, to elaborate on the strength of that formula.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13650 MR. GEMMELL: Thanks, Ken, and Madam Chair. I have a piece with me that we often use to sell our oldies station, CK 750, and it's called, The Power of Boomers. It's based on two studies. Admittedly they come from the States, but they're certainly very relevant to this area. They bear of labour statistics and media market research. "Oldies is the must‑buy radio format ‑‑ radio station to target adult consumers." And the fact of the matter is that boomers control half of all spending. The baby boom generation, as you are probably aware, started in 1946 ‑‑ I'm just trying to find ‑‑ yeah, 1946, and the birth rate held its pace for close to 18 years. So in 2004 or now, the youngest boomer is about 42 years of age. In reality, it's probably more like 48, but I'm using the statistics in the research. So it's a strong ‑‑ a strong group. Again, they control half of all the spending. If you want to get into the real details, household furnishings, 50 percent of the market, vehicle purchases, 50 percent of the market, entertainment expenses, 53 percent, and so on.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13651 THE CHAIRPERSON: So in your station in Melfort ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13652 MR. GEMMELL: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13653 THE CHAIRPERSON: What is the percentage of your total revenue that's national?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13654 MR. GEMMELL: That's national?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13655 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13656 MR. GEMMELL: I would be happy to supply that to you under confidential cover.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13657 THE CHAIRPERSON: Sure. Yeah, it's just a percentage. If you'll notice ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13658 MR. GEMMELL: Yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13659 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ everybody is saying 20 or 30 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13660 MR. GEMMELL: I ‑‑ if you give me two minutes, I'll dig it up for you, actually.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13661 MR. SINGER: I would think we're in that range of 20 to 30 percent.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13662 THE CHAIRPERSON: 20 to 30?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13663 MR. SINGER: Yes, yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13664 MR. GEMMELL: Yeah. I don't deal with national sales regularly, that's Ken's job, so I don't ‑‑ I don't track them as much.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13665 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, okay, mmhmm, mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13666 MR. GEMMELL: I deal with the ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13667 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yeah, I was talking about national revenue. That's why I wanted to ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13668 MR. SINGER: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13669 MR. GEMMELL: Yeah, yeah.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13670 THE CHAIRPERSON: ‑‑ you know, sort of talk about, you know, being able to sell that audience.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13671 MR. GEMMELL: Mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13672 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. I want to seriously sort of get down to if you were given one licence in Regina, could you compete against two threefers, if I can call them that?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13673 MR. SINGER: Two threefers, I've never heard that before.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13674 THE CHAIRPERSON: Oh, well, but that's what I mean. You know, Rawlco has three, and Harvard ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13675 MR. SINGER: Yeah, two ‑‑ two groups of three?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13676 THE CHAIRPERSON: Yes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13677 MR. SINGER: Yes, and ‑‑
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13678 MR. SINGER: ‑‑ if we were given one licence, I think our projections that we've filed with our application show that we're quite confident that we could compete, but, certainly, the best‑case scenario is we would compete at a much better level in terms of evening the playing field, I guess. We also, as you just discussed with Ms Rheaume, is we have some ‑‑ certainly some cost savings in doing a combination.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13679 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm, okay. Well, you've heard, I'm sure, that the profitability of the Regina stations is well below the national average of all English‑language commercial radio. Now, you may not have known that when you made your application. What made you decide to continue your application once you became aware of, at least, the incumbents saying there's no room in the market?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13680 MR. SINGER: I'll turn it over to Kevin in just a moment to talk to that, but I guess the short answer is, our projections are of the estimated revenue that the six radio stations are taking out of this market indicate to us, given that opportunity to ‑‑ and also evaluating what's left on the table here, given the opportunity to work with those revenues, we certainly feel that our radio stations could be profitable. We don't understand why those ‑‑ that the profits are that low based against the revenue, unless they're ‑‑ you know, there are costs there that are wildly above our projections, but we feel confident that our projections are realistic in terms of both revenue and in operational costs. So I guess given the scenario of what we feel and what Kevin will elaborate on is in the market, we feel that there is profitability here for new players. So I'll let him talk to that.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13681 MR. GEMMELL: Thanks, Ken.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13682 Madam Chair, we've been before you as of yesterday and, of course, in June in Edmonton. And we've talked a lot about what percentage of the total advertising dollars would be available to radio. We've generally come up with a number between 12 and 16 percent. We used 16 percent for the Regina and the Saskatoon market, which we'll talk about in a few days, as the amount of dollars that are available for radio when we did our estimates, and that created just shy of $15 million in the Regina market. The way we came up with that 16 percent is taking the total Saskatchewan retail sales in 2005 of nine ‑‑ close to $9.9 billion. Taking four percent of that showed $395 million in total advertising dollars spent in the province. We then took the CRTC 2005 Radio Revenue Report of $63,000 ‑‑ $63 million, pardon me. 63,000 would not be enough. $63 million, and that is 16 percent of 395.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13683 Now, we mentioned in our presentation today that relative to the report that was published as an intervention, and I don't want to get into that if you don't want to, it showed that, in fact, the Regina and Saskatoon combined markets took 56 percent ‑‑ 56 to 57 percent, but we used 56 for the lower sake of the total Saskatchewan radio advertising revenue. That is $36 million between Regina and Saskatoon. We then extrapolated based on population, Regina having ‑‑ of the total population, Regina having 46 percent of the number, Saskatoon 54, that's $16,720,000 is what the six operators in town bill, which is about ‑‑ let me do the math here. It's $2.8 million dollars per station.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13684 Now, I want to just take you back to Fort McMurray when we uncovered an application by the OK Radio Group to switch or to increase their power, they showed a budget of $4,000,000 for a combo station operation in a very expensive market to operate, and they showed 20 percent PDIT. I scratch my head as to how six ‑‑ two three‑station combos with close to $9 million in revenue in the Regina market, which is certainly cheaper to operate, can't make more than three percent. It doesn't make sense to me.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13685 THE CHAIRPERSON: So your argument, then, is that PEBA is only part of the story, we should be looking at gross revenues?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13686 MR. GEMMELL: Yes, absolutely.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13687 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13688 MR. GEMMELL: They're getting $3 million a station in Saskatchewan as an average. It's 1.875 million if you take all 34 radio stations and the $64 million. If you take the city equation out and again the 56 percent to the city, it's just under a million dollars per radio station. You know, we know what we do in Melfort. We have a large staff. We have 32 staff in Melfort, so, of course, the staff costs are one of the bigger issues, but, again, it just doesn't add up to us, and I think total revenue is a very important factor to look at.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13689 THE CHAIRPERSON: Okay. Anything else you think we should look at?
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13690 MR. GEMMELL: Giving us two licences would be all right.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13691 THE CHAIRPERSON: No, no, I'm talking about, you know, how we can assess whether there's space in the market for another player?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13692 MR. GEMMELL: Well ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13693 MR. FABRO: Well, you know, I guess you have the ‑‑ the Commission has the luxury of knowing what's ‑‑ what the existing stations bill.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13694 THE CHAIRPERSON: Secret, secret.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13695 MR. FABRO: I know, it's all secret. We have to rely on third‑party numbers to try to come up with our estimate of going forward, and we have collaborated these numbers a number of ways, and we think that there's room in the market, and I guess we wouldn't have went through this application if we didn't think there ‑‑ we could make it work, and, I guess, you as being the judge and jury, you have the final say because you have the facts.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13696 MR. GEMMELL: As well, Gene, I'll just point out to ‑‑ our standard indicators that we used in Medicine Hat, and in the other markets, it's the FT report. We're expecting between 2006 and 2011 a 23 percent increase in retail sales in the Regina market only and about that same for Saskatoon, for that matter, so, you know, there is, you know, a steady, decent growth in this market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13697 THE CHAIRPERSON: Mmhmm, thank you. This is your time to shine for two minutes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13698 Oh, I'm sorry, Counsel?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13699 Sorry, anybody? Oh, Commissioner Williams...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13700 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Mr. Thunderchild, I'm interested in learning a bit more about your role within this ‑‑ this proposed radio station. These host of series of features to be known as The Bridge, which would highlight ‑‑ share Aboriginal community's culture and highlight successes and foster a greater understanding of Native issues and concerns. Can you describe or give me some sample of content? And I guess it's going to run a couple times a day. Do you know what times of day it's proposed that it runs, and just some ‑‑ does it run in the middle of the night or in the middle of the day or morning or noon or ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13701 MR. SINGER: I'll first of all ‑‑
LISTNUM 95 \l 13702 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: The content first.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13703 MR. SINGER: 10 ‑‑ 10 at ‑‑ oh, I'm sorry.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13704 MR. THUNDERCHILD: Thank you very much, Commissioner and Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13705 In regards to the content for The Bridge program, we have identified several ways in which we would approach this, and in terms of the success stories, we would concentrate on the positiveness, and we would work on the ‑‑ we would be language specific and culturally sensitive in our approach in identifying the demographics within the First Nations communities and that we have come down with five different language groups that exist within the City of Regina. And within those five language ‑‑ First Nation languages within Regina, there's dialects that are involved ‑‑ within the Cree itself, there's five that exist. And with the approach that will be taken, we will be using the First Nation language; that is, we're going to be focusing on, for instance, the community of Cowessess, which is 50 miles from here. We would say, (native language) which means, how are you, you know and as if ‑‑ (native language) which is Peepeekisis, the Saulteaux people. You know, they are a different First Nation language group, and that's how we would base our content and that, and it would build on the ‑‑ be on the positive of each individual and ‑‑ item that is going to be highlighted on these. And in terms of bridging and that, it will not only be centered on individuals that are in the field of music and broadcasting, but success stories in terms of economics in the business on how it affects the community of Regina and that, so that is one ‑‑ you know, the ideas behind this. And we are going to be opening eyes in terms of the real issue that, you know, exists in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13706 And with CJVR's presentation on their application for the licence and that, the First Nations communities have, you know, opened up, and said, hey, somebody is going to do more than talk the talk. We have ‑‑ with the Aboriginal scholarship incentive that is, you know, with the presentation on that, that goes beyond what others have been just thinking about. This group has thought it over and looked at the avenues that are available on that and have opened doors for the great big "C" word of communication, and I hope I'm ‑‑ I hope I'm not getting away from the question of content, but, basically, that entails what we want to display in our little segments.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13707 They will be two‑minute segments in which they'll be highlighting persons like Erroll Kinistino North of 60 fella, who will tell his story. Hey, (native language) I'm Erroll Kinistino. I went to the INCA program. Through this, you can achieve a ‑‑ you know, there is no limitations on this.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13708 And with the 15‑minute segments, we will, you know, portray and illustrate the ‑‑ maybe a doctor, a journalist, a broadcaster who have gone on and been successful and that. That is the ‑‑ what we have envisioned with the CJVR presentation.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13709 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Does this Bridge extend to the Metis people, or just First Nations, as you're describing?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13710 MR. THUNDERCHILD: In our eyes and in our interpretation of First Nations people, Commissioner and Madam Chair, we look at First Nations people as not being Inuit, not being Metis, not being any certain linguistic group, we all look at them as the same, as Isinuuk(ph), the Inuuk(ph), the people on that, it will be inclusive to the Metis population as well.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13711 COMMISSIONER WILLIAMS: Very good. Thank you very much.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13712 MR. THUNDERCHILD: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13713 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13714 Commissioner ‑‑ or Vice‑Chair Arpin...?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13715 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13716 Could you educate me and tell me what are the five languages that are spoken in the Regina area?
LISTNUM 95 \l 13717 MR. THUNDERCHILD: In the Regina area, I believe, Mr. Commissioner, there's Saulteaux, and there's the Dakota, Lakota, Nakotas, which are under the (native language) umbrella and that ‑‑ and we have Cree, which is the "Y" dialect in the southern part of this province.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13718 VICE‑CHAIR ARPIN: Thank you.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13719 MR. THUNDERCHILD: You're welcome.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13720 THE CHAIRPERSON: Here you are, two minutes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13721 MR. FABRO: Well, thank you very much, Madam Chair.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13722 I think, again, today there was some excellent questions from you and your panel, so I hope we answered them to your satisfaction.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13723 Madam Chair and Commissioners, CJVR's brand of radio is great music, locally relevant, community driven. We want our brand of radio on the streets of Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13724 We've done our homework here. Based on our analysis, there's room for ‑‑ in the market for two additional radio stations. In order to allow us to compete on a more equitable basis with existing operators, who have three licence each, we ask that you grant us, not one, but two licences.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13725 Our extensive market research has shown that there is a hole in the market. We've determined, through this research, that the two formats are classic rock and oldies, and we could fill the holes.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13726 We have filed with the Commission a rock‑solid business plan prepared by people who know the radio business, people who have loved it, lived it, listened to it, and worked at it for most or almost all their lives.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13727 Our collective wisdom is wrapped up in this plan. There is absolutely nothing left to chance. We have an excellent history, Madam Chair and Commissioners. CJVR has been a trusted friend to 150,000 listeners in over a hundred communities in northeast Saskatchewan for 40 years. We've capitalized on our history by taking great music, local relevance, community‑driven radio to the Whitecourt market, less than two months ago, and the market there has embraced us wholeheartedly. We are absolutely certain, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that the same thing would happen in Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13728 We offer the Canadian Broadcast System an independent voice. We are a small market broadcaster, yes, but one that needs to play in the city.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13729 The status quo for CJVR is unacceptable. We absolutely have to grow our business to fend against the Saskatchewan rural‑to‑urban population shift and the new licensee that has entered our market.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13730 Regina is a natural fit for our Melfort operation, and along with our Saskatoon application, which is going to be heard later this week, may be the last chance that we get to obtain another licence in Saskatchewan.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13731 For these reasons, Madam Chair and Commissioners, we ask that you award us two broadcaster's licences for the City of Regina.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13732 We thank you for hearing our application here today. We wish you a pleasant evening and a happy Halloween.
‑‑‑ Laughter / Rires
LISTNUM 95 \l 13733 THE CHAIRPERSON: Thank you, Mr. Fabro, Mr. Singer and panel.
LISTNUM 95 \l 13734 I was going to say watch out for the ghosts, and we will adjourn until 8:30 tomorrow morning, unless ‑‑ Madam Secretary, nothing? Okay, thank you.
‑‑‑ Whereupon the hearing adjourned at 1951,
to resume on Wednesday, November 1, 2006,
at 0830 / L'audience est ajournée à 1951,
pour reprendre le mardi 1 Novembre 2006
à 0830
REPORTERS
- Date modified: